Letter from the data protection authority about a client's AI tool: GDPR Article 31 and 58(1) reply sheet with reply-by dates for accountants and their SME clients (records, breach file, complaint, order)
What you get: a finished authority letter reply sheet for accountants, tax advisers and bookkeepers whose small business clients receive a letter or email from a data protection authority about an AI tool (a chatbot, note-taker, AI phone answering, camera analytics, an AI invoice reader). One row per item the authority asks for: type in ten short answers and the sheet returns the reply-by date, the days left, a result (PREPARE ANSWER, COMPLETE THE GAPS, GAP, ASK AI SUPPLIER NOW, CHECK SECRECY RULES, BINDING ORDER, PREPARE VISIT or DONE) and a to-do list with the GDPR Article behind each step. Also included: a checklist for reading the letter, a cover letter for the reply, an email to the AI supplier and a client email. Formulas tested in LibreOffice on nine made-up rows.
Short answer: a business that uses personal data (the controller) and its AI supplier (the processor) "shall cooperate, on request, with the supervisory authority" (GDPR Article 31). The authority may order them to provide any information it requires, notify an alleged infringement, and obtain access to personal data and to premises (Article 58(1)(a), (d), (e), (f)). The record of processing must be made available on request (Article 30(4)) and breaches must be documented so the authority can check them (Article 33(5)). The GDPR does not set a fixed reply period for these requests: the date is the one in the letter, under national procedure. Missing it, or refusing access, is itself a fineable failure (Article 83(5)(e)), while the degree of cooperation counts when fines are decided (Article 83(2)(f)).
Why clients bring these letters to their accountant
- The accountant is often the first adviser who sees it, because it arrives with the post or in the general mailbox.
- Much of what is asked sits with the accountant or the AI supplier: software lists, contracts, invoices showing which AI tools are paid for, staff numbers for the Article 30(5) question.
- The deadline is short and set in the letter, often in days, and nobody owns it.
- Accounting and tax firms are themselves bound by professional secrecy; GDPR Article 90 lets Member States adapt the authority's access powers for such firms, so access requests need a check first.
Step 1: tab 1, Letter (one row per item the authority asks for)
| Column | What to write | Source |
|---|---|---|
| A | Client and the AI tool concerned | The letter |
| B | What the authority asks for, in its words | The letter |
| C | Type: Information, Records, Breach file, Access to data, Premises visit, Alleged infringement, Complaint or Order | Art 58(1)(a), (d), (e), (f); Art 30(4); Art 33(5); Art 77; Art 58(2) |
| D | Date of the letter (a date) | The letter |
| E | Reply-by date stated in the letter (a date), if there is one | The letter |
| F | Days given, if the letter says "within n days" instead of a date | The letter |
| G | Does the client already hold it? Y, Partly or N | Client files |
| H | Is it held by the AI supplier (processor)? Y or N | Art 28(3)(h) |
| I | Does it include data covered by professional secrecy (for example an accounting or tax firm's client files)? Y or N | Art 90 |
| J | Status: Not started, Drafted or Sent | You |
| K | Reply by: =IF(E2<>"",E2,IF(AND(D2<>"",F2<>""),D2+F2,"")) | Formula |
| L | Days left: =IF(K2="","",K2-Settings!$B$1) (Settings!B1 holds the check date; put =TODAY() there in your copy) | Formula |
| M | Result: =IF(B2="","",IF(J2="Sent","DONE: KEEP A COPY",IF(C2="Order","BINDING ORDER: COMPLY OR GET ADVICE NOW",IF(C2="Premises visit","PREPARE VISIT: CHECK NATIONAL PROCEDURE",IF(I2="Y","CHECK SECRECY RULES BEFORE SENDING",IF(AND(H2="Y",G2<>"Y"),"ASK AI SUPPLIER NOW",IF(G2="N","GAP: EXPLAIN AND FIX",IF(G2="Partly","COMPLETE THE GAPS","PREPARE ANSWER")))))))) | Formula (our working rule) |
| N | Deadline: =IF(OR(B2="",J2="Sent"),"",IF(K2="","NO DATE: CONFIRM WITH THE AUTHORITY",IF(L2<0,"LATE BY "&-L2&" DAYS: CONTACT THE AUTHORITY TODAY",IF(L2=0,"DUE TODAY",IF(L2<=3,"DUE IN "&L2&" DAYS: URGENT","DUE IN "&L2&" DAYS"))))) | Formula |
| O | To-do: =IF(OR(B2="",J2="Sent"),"",TEXTJOIN("; ",TRUE,IF(C2="Information","answer what is asked, with facts and documents: the authority may order any information it requires (Art 58(1)(a)) and controllers must cooperate on request (Art 31)",""),IF(C2="Records","send the record of processing activities, which must be made available on request (Art 30(4)); if the client has fewer than 250 staff, check whether the Art 30(5) exemption applies and say why",""),IF(C2="Breach file","send the breach documentation: facts, effects and remedial action (Art 33(5))",""),IF(C2="Access to data","arrange access to the personal data and information asked for (Art 58(1)(e))",""),IF(C2="Premises visit","agree date and people; access to premises follows national procedural law (Art 58(1)(f), recital 129)",""),IF(C2="Alleged infringement","reply with facts and the fixes made: cooperation to remedy counts when fines are decided (Art 58(1)(d), Art 83(2)(f))",""),IF(C2="Complaint","a person has complained (Art 77): check whether their request was missed (Art 12 to 22) and answer them too",""),IF(C2="Order","an order under Art 58(2) is binding; non-compliance can be fined up to EUR 20 million or 4% (Art 83(6)); a challenge goes to the national court (Art 78(1))",""),IF(AND(H2="Y",G2<>"Y"),"ask the AI supplier for the information it must make available (Art 28(3)(h))",""),IF(I2="Y","check national rules on professional secrecy before giving access (Art 90)",""),IF(G2="N","say plainly what is missing and when it will be fixed; do not create backdated documents",""),"keep a copy of the letter, the reply and the date sent")) | Formula |
Copy the formulas into row 2 and fill down. Format columns D, E and K as dates and L as a number. TEXTJOIN works in Excel 2019 or later, Microsoft 365, Google Sheets and LibreOffice. Column M is our working rule for sorting the work, not a legal test: it checks sent items first, then binding orders, premises visits, professional secrecy, items held by the AI supplier and gaps.
Example rows (made up) and what the sheet returns at 29 Oct 2026
| Example (made up) | Key answers | Reply by | Result | Deadline |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1: dental clinic, AI phone answering: list of AI tools | Information, date in letter, Partly held, Drafted | 2026-11-03 | COMPLETE THE GAPS | DUE IN 5 DAYS |
| 2: web shop, AI chatbot: record of processing | Records, 14 days from 22 Oct, not held | 2026-11-05 | GAP: EXPLAIN AND FIX | DUE IN 7 DAYS |
| 3: recruitment agency, AI CV tool: breach documentation | Breach file, 14 days from 12 Oct, held | 2026-10-26 | PREPARE ANSWER | LATE BY 3 DAYS: CONTACT THE AUTHORITY TODAY |
| 4: accounting firm, AI invoice reader: copy of client files | Access to data, secrecy Y | 2026-11-10 | CHECK SECRECY RULES BEFORE SENDING | DUE IN 12 DAYS |
| 5: salon, AI booking assistant: supplier contract and sub-processors | Information, held by AI supplier, not by client | 2026-11-01 | ASK AI SUPPLIER NOW | DUE IN 3 DAYS: URGENT |
| 6: estate agent, AI note-taker: customer complaint | Complaint, 30 days from 15 Oct | 2026-11-14 | PREPARE ANSWER | DUE IN 16 DAYS |
| 7: gym, AI camera analytics: stop until DPIA done | Order, date in letter | 2026-11-28 | BINDING ORDER: COMPLY OR GET ADVICE NOW | DUE IN 30 DAYS |
| 8: bakery, AI email assistant: questionnaire | Information, Sent | 2026-10-15 | DONE: KEEP A COPY | (empty) |
| 9: tutoring firm, AI chatbot: inspection visit | Premises visit, no date | (empty) | PREPARE VISIT: CHECK NATIONAL PROCEDURE | NO DATE: CONFIRM WITH THE AUTHORITY |
The to-do for row 2, for example, reads: "send the record of processing activities, which must be made available on request (Art 30(4)); if the client has fewer than 250 staff, check whether the Art 30(5) exemption applies and say why; say plainly what is missing and when it will be fixed; do not create backdated documents; keep a copy of the letter, the reply and the date sent".
Step 2: checklist for reading the letter (10 minutes)
- Who sent it: name of the authority, reference number, contact person. Check it is the real authority (address and phone on its own website, not in the email).
- Is it a request, a notice or a decision? A request for information (Article 58(1)(a)), a notice of an alleged infringement (Article 58(1)(d)) or a binding measure under Article 58(2), such as an order to bring processing into compliance "within a specified period", a limitation or ban, or a fine. Recital 129 says a legally binding measure should be in writing, give reasons and refer to the right to an effective remedy.
- The date: enter the reply-by date or the number of days into columns E or F. If there is no date, ask the authority which date applies.
- Is there a complaint behind it? If a person complained (Article 77), look for the data request they sent first: an access, erasure or objection request that was missed is a common cause. The authority must keep the complainant informed of progress and outcome (Articles 57(1)(f) and 77(2)), so your reply will shape what the person is told.
- Which AI tool and which supplier: the supplier must make available all information necessary to show it meets Article 28 (Article 28(3)(h)). Ask early.
- Existing documents: record of processing (Article 30), breach documentation (Article 33(5)), DPIA (Article 35), processor agreement (Article 28), privacy notice (Articles 13 and 14). Send what exists; do not backdate what does not.
- Professional secrecy: if access to an accounting or tax firm's client files is asked for, check the national rules adopted under Article 90 and the professional body's guidance first.
Related sheets: Article 30 records of processing, personal data breach 72-hour sheet, Article 28 processor agreement (DPA) clause check and Article 12 one-month reply tracker for data requests.
Cover letter for the reply (template)
Subject: Your reference [ref], letter of [date]: reply of [client name]
Dear [name],
Thank you for your letter of [date] concerning [AI tool / processing]. We wish to cooperate fully (GDPR Article 31). Please find attached: (1) [item, for example our record of processing activities]; (2) [item]; (3) [item]. For [item], we do not yet hold this document; we will provide it by [date] and explain the steps taken in the meantime. For [item], the information is held by our supplier [supplier name]; we asked for it on [date] and will forward it on receipt. If anything is unclear, please contact [name, role, email].
Kind regards, [name, role], [client name]
Email to the AI supplier (template)
Subject: Information needed for a data protection authority request, reply by [date]
Hello,
We have received a request from [authority] about our use of [AI tool]. Under GDPR Article 28(3)(h) and [clause number] of our data processing terms, please send us by [date, a few days before the authority's date]: [your current sub-processor list / where our data is processed / your security measures / logs or records for our account / other item]. Please confirm receipt today.
Kind regards, [client name]
Email to business clients (template)
Subject: Letters from the data protection authority: forward them to us the same day
Dear [name],
If you receive a letter or email from the data protection authority, for example about a chatbot, AI phone answering, cameras or a customer complaint, please forward it to us the same day with the envelope or email date. The reply date in the letter is short, and the GDPR requires you to cooperate (Article 31). We will log each item asked for, give you the reply-by date, list what you hold and what we must ask your AI supplier for, and prepare a cover letter.
This is a first sort, not legal advice. For orders, fines or visits we will recommend specialist advice. Kind regards, [firm]
Keep the AI tool list ready before any letter arrives
The first question in many letters is "which AI tools do you use, for what, and with which supplier?". Record each AI tool, its supplier and the evidence (contract, notices, replies) in the EURO AI Register free edition. It runs in your browser with no account and no upload, covers your first 10 AI systems and 10 evidence records, the screening questions, duties by role with dates, and a printable Article 4 AI-literacy record.
When a client has more than 10 systems, the EURO AI Register membership starts at $19 a month and adds unlimited systems, rule updates and email help. Neither tool is legal advice or proof of compliance.
Partner programme opening soon
Partner programme opening soon: join the free waitlist. Planned terms are 50% of each referred sale (75% once you have 5+ paying customers), single level, paid through Gumroad only from revenue received.
Limits and open points
Not read for this guide: we built it from the text of Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR) on EUR-Lex. We did not read national procedural law on authority requests, deadlines and inspections, the national rules notified under Article 90, any EU regulation laying down additional procedural rules for cross-border GDPR enforcement, or EDPB and national authority guidance; check them for the client's country. Open points: the GDPR sets no fixed reply period for Article 58(1) requests; the period comes from the letter and national law. "Contact the authority before the date passes" and "do not backdate documents" are our practical advice, not rules in the text. The fine amounts in Article 83 are maximums; the amount depends on the Article 83(2) factors. The sheet sorts the work; it does not decide legal questions, and orders, fines and inspections call for a lawyer.
Frequently asked questions
Does a small business have to answer a letter from the data protection authority?
Yes. Controllers and processors shall cooperate, on request, with the supervisory authority (GDPR Article 31), and the authority may order them to provide any information it requires (Article 58(1)(a)). Failure to provide access in violation of Article 58(1) can be fined (Article 83(5)(e)).
How long does a business have to reply?
The GDPR does not set a fixed period for these requests. The reply date is the one in the authority's letter, under national procedural law. If no date is given, ask the authority.
Must the record of processing be sent?
The record of processing activities must be made available to the supervisory authority on request (GDPR Article 30(4)). Enterprises with fewer than 250 employees are exempt from keeping it only in the cases set out in Article 30(5).
Can the AI supplier be asked for documents?
Yes. The processor must make available to the controller all information necessary to demonstrate compliance with GDPR Article 28 and allow for and contribute to audits (Article 28(3)(h)). The processor must also cooperate with the authority on request (Article 31).
Not legal advice. The sheet helps sort a data protection authority letter; it does not decide legal questions. Spotted an error? Write to mininglife7@gmail.com and we correct it.
Sources
- Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR): Article 28(3)(h), Article 30(4)-(5), Article 31, Article 33(5), Article 57(1)(f), Article 58(1)-(4), Article 77, Article 78(1)-(3), Article 83(2), (5), (6), Article 90, recitals 82 and 129 — eur-lex.europa.eu, CELEX 32016R0679 (read 29 Oct 2026)
Unadhi Guides are free, independent explainers. We correct errors as soon as we find them: write to mininglife7@gmail.com.