Staff monitoring and HR AI tool check sheet for accountants, payroll bureaus and their SME clients: works agreements, emotion AI ban, high-risk HR tools (GDPR Article 88, C-34/21, C-65/23, AI Act Article 5(1)(f), Annex III point 4)
What you get: a finished staff monitoring and HR AI tool check sheet for accountants, tax advisers, payroll bureaus, bookkeepers and the small employers they advise. One row per tool used on staff (mood or emotion detection, keystroke or screen monitoring, performance scores, AI shift planners, CV screeners, meeting transcription, HR and payroll systems, vehicle tracking): type in twelve short answers and the sheet returns the AI Act status (prohibited, exception claimed, likely high-risk from 2 Dec 2027, or not high-risk on these answers), a GDPR status (STOP, FIX GAPS, CHECK BY HAND or OK), the timing against the go-live date and a to-do list citing the article or judgment behind each step. Also included: a 10-question checklist, a staff notice paragraph, a letter to staff representatives, questions for the HR or AI supplier and a client email. Formulas tested in LibreOffice on ten made-up rows.
Short answer: GDPR Article 88 lets EU countries, by law or collective agreements (including works agreements, recital 155), set more specific rules for staff data. The Court of Justice has made two points clear. First, such national rules count only if they include the suitable and specific safeguards in Article 88(2), otherwise they must be disregarded (C-34/21, 30 March 2023). Second, a works agreement does not lower the GDPR floor: it must still meet Articles 5, 6(1) and 9, and a court can fully review whether the processing was really "necessary" (C-65/23, 19 December 2024, a case about real staff data copied to a US group parent's HR cloud during a test). Separately, the AI Act has banned AI that infers staff emotions since 2 February 2025 (except for medical or safety reasons), and lists recruitment, task allocation and performance monitoring tools as high-risk, with deployer duties for those from 2 December 2027.
Why this lands on the accountant's desk
- Payroll bureaus and bookkeepers hold the staff data and are often asked by clients which HR or monitoring tool is "OK to switch on".
- Clients buy tools with AI features switched on by default: mood scores in call-centre software, productivity scores in time trackers, AI rota planners. The AI Act ban and the GDPR questions arrive with the next update, not with a new purchase.
- Supplier questionnaires, bank and insurer due diligence increasingly ask whether staff are monitored, on what legal basis and whether a DPIA exists.
Step 1: tab 1, Staff tools (one row per tool)
Create a sheet named Staff tools with headers in row 1 and the first tool in row 2. Create a second sheet named Settings and put =TODAY() in B1. Copy the formulas in M2 to P2 down as far as needed. In Excel 2019 or later, LibreOffice or Google Sheets, TEXTJOIN works as written.
| Column | What to write | Source |
|---|---|---|
| A | Tool or feature used on staff (for example "AI shift planner") | You |
| B | What it does: Emotion or mood detection, Keystroke or screen monitoring, Performance scoring, Task allocation, CV screening or recruitment, Meeting transcription, HR records or payroll or Location tracking | AI Act Art 5(1)(f), Annex III point 4 |
| C | Emotion tool only: is it there for a medical or safety reason? Y or N | AI Act Art 5(1)(f) |
| D | Is it used to evaluate staff, or to make or support decisions on hiring, pay, promotion, dismissal or tasks? Y or N | Annex III point 4(a)-(b) |
| E | Health, trade union, biometric or other Article 9(1) data? Y or N | GDPR Art 9(1)-(2) |
| F | Legal basis written down: Contract, Legal obligation, Legitimate interest, Consent, Works or collective agreement or None | GDPR Art 6(1), 88, recital 155 |
| G | Staff representatives informed? Y, N or No reps | AI Act Art 26(7) |
| H | Staff told in writing, with the tool named? Y or N | GDPR Art 13 |
| I | Would a less intrusive way do the job? Y, N or Not checked | GDPR Art 5(1)(c) |
| J | DPIA done? Y or N | GDPR Art 35 |
| K | Does the data leave the EU/EEA, including to a group parent? Y or N | GDPR Chapter V, C-65/23 facts |
| L | Go-live date (blank if not known) | You |
| M | AI Act status (our reading): =IF(A2="","",IF(AND(B2="Emotion or mood detection",C2<>"Y"),"PROHIBITED SINCE 2 FEB 2025 (AI ACT ART 5(1)(f))",IF(B2="Emotion or mood detection","EXCEPTION CLAIMED: MEDICAL OR SAFETY (CHECK IT)",IF(OR(B2="Performance scoring",B2="Task allocation",B2="CV screening or recruitment",D2="Y"),"LIKELY HIGH-RISK, ANNEX III POINT 4 (DEPLOYER DUTIES FROM 2 DEC 2027)","NOT HIGH-RISK ON THESE ANSWERS (OUR READING)")))) | AI Act Art 5(1)(f), 113, Annex III point 4, Reg (EU) 2026/1744 |
| N | GDPR status: =IF(A2="","",IF(LEFT(M2,10)="PROHIBITED","STOP: SWITCH OFF THE EMOTION FEATURE",IF(F2="None","STOP: NO LEGAL BASIS (ART 6(1))",IF(I2="Y","STOP: A LESS INTRUSIVE WAY EXISTS (ART 5(1)(c))",IF(OR(H2<>"Y",AND(J2<>"Y",OR(E2="Y",LEFT(M2,6)="LIKELY",OR(B2="Keystroke or screen monitoring",B2="Location tracking",B2="Emotion or mood detection")))),"FIX GAPS BEFORE (FURTHER) USE",IF(OR(F2="Consent",F2="Works or collective agreement",I2<>"N",E2="Y",K2="Y",G2="N",LEFT(M2,9)="EXCEPTION"),"CHECK BY HAND","OK ON THESE ANSWERS")))))) | GDPR Art 5(1)(c), 6(1), 13, 35; C-65/23 |
| O | Timing (uses Settings!B1 = today): =IF(A2="","",IF(L2="","NO GO-LIVE DATE",IF(L2<=Settings!$B$1,IF(OR(LEFT(N2,4)="STOP",LEFT(N2,3)="FIX"),"LIVE FOR "&(Settings!$B$1-L2)&" DAYS WITH OPEN ISSUES","LIVE"),IF(L2-Settings!$B$1<=14,"GO-LIVE IN "&(L2-Settings!$B$1)&" DAYS: URGENT","GO-LIVE IN "&(L2-Settings!$B$1)&" DAYS")))) | You |
| P | To-do list: =IF(A2="","",TEXTJOIN("; ",TRUE,IF(LEFT(M2,10)="PROHIBITED","switch off emotion or mood inference on staff now: banned at the workplace since 2 Feb 2025 unless for medical or safety reasons (AI Act Art 5(1)(f), Art 113(a))",""),IF(LEFT(M2,9)="EXCEPTION","write down the medical or safety reason and why the tool is needed for it; the exception is narrow (Art 5(1)(f), recital 44)",""),IF(F2="None","pick and record a legal basis before any further use (GDPR Art 6(1)); no basis means stop",""),IF(F2="Consent","staff consent is rarely freely given given the employment relationship: check national law and prefer another basis (Art 4(11), 7(4), recitals 43 and 155; our reading)",""),IF(F2="Works or collective agreement","the agreement must still meet GDPR Art 5, 6(1) and 9(1)-(2) and a court can fully review whether the processing is necessary (C-65/23)",""),IF(I2="Y","use the less intrusive way: data must be adequate, relevant and limited to what is necessary (Art 5(1)(c)); C-65/23 claimant argued dummy data would have sufficed for a test",""),IF(I2="Not checked","write down why no less intrusive way works (necessity, Art 5(1)(c), 6(1))",""),IF(E2="Y","health, union membership, biometric or other Art 9(1) data: name the Art 9(2) condition, e.g. 9(2)(b) employment law with safeguards",""),IF(H2<>"Y","tell staff in writing before use: purpose, legal basis, recipients, transfers, retention (Art 13(1)-(2))",""),IF(AND(J2<>"Y",OR(E2="Y",LEFT(M2,6)="LIKELY",OR(B2="Keystroke or screen monitoring",B2="Location tracking",B2="Emotion or mood detection"))),"do a DPIA before (further) use: monitoring or evaluating staff with new technology is likely high risk (Art 35(1), 35(3)(a); our reading)",""),IF(K2="Y","data leaves the EU/EEA (including to a group parent, as in C-65/23): check the transfer basis in Chapter V",""),IF(AND(LEFT(M2,6)="LIKELY",G2<>"Y"),"inform staff representatives and affected staff before use (AI Act Art 26(7), from 2 Dec 2027; national consultation rules may apply sooner)",IF(G2="N","check national rules on informing or consulting staff representatives (not covered here)","")),IF(LEFT(M2,6)="LIKELY","prepare for deployer duties from 2 Dec 2027: use per instructions, human oversight, keep logs, tell affected people (Art 26(1)-(2), 26(6), 26(11))",""),"record who decided, why and the date")) | As cited in each item |
Step 2: what the test rows returned
Tested in LibreOffice Calc on 2 Nov 2026 with Settings!B1 fixed at 2 Nov 2026, on ten made-up rows (no real business). All ten gave the intended result; an empty row stays blank; no formula errors.
| Made-up row | AI Act status (M) | GDPR status (N) | Timing (O) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Webcam mood score in a call centre | PROHIBITED SINCE 2 FEB 2025 | STOP: SWITCH OFF THE EMOTION FEATURE | LIVE FOR 154 DAYS WITH OPEN ISSUES |
| 2 Driver fatigue alert in vans (safety) | EXCEPTION CLAIMED: MEDICAL OR SAFETY | CHECK BY HAND | GO-LIVE IN 29 DAYS |
| 3 AI CV screener for shop staff | LIKELY HIGH-RISK, ANNEX III POINT 4 | CHECK BY HAND | GO-LIVE IN 8 DAYS: URGENT |
| 4 Keystroke logger on bookkeepers' PCs, consent | NOT HIGH-RISK ON THESE ANSWERS | STOP: A LESS INTRUSIVE WAY EXISTS | LIVE FOR 48 DAYS WITH OPEN ISSUES |
| 5 Payroll bureau runs payroll in an EU cloud | NOT HIGH-RISK ON THESE ANSWERS | OK ON THESE ANSWERS | LIVE |
| 6 Group HR cloud tested with real staff data, US parent | NOT HIGH-RISK ON THESE ANSWERS | FIX GAPS BEFORE (FURTHER) USE | GO-LIVE IN 18 DAYS |
| 7 AI shift planner allocates tasks by speed | LIKELY HIGH-RISK, ANNEX III POINT 4 | FIX GAPS BEFORE (FURTHER) USE | NO GO-LIVE DATE |
| 8 Van GPS tracking, no basis recorded | NOT HIGH-RISK ON THESE ANSWERS | STOP: NO LEGAL BASIS (ART 6(1)) | LIVE FOR 32 DAYS WITH OPEN ISSUES |
| 9 AI meeting notes, staff told, DPIA done | NOT HIGH-RISK ON THESE ANSWERS | OK ON THESE ANSWERS | LIVE |
| 10 Sales performance score used for bonus | LIKELY HIGH-RISK, ANNEX III POINT 4 | OK ON THESE ANSWERS | GO-LIVE IN 74 DAYS |
Step 3: the 10-question checklist
- Have we listed every tool that records, scores or watches staff, including AI features inside existing software?
- Does any tool infer emotions, mood or stress from faces, voice or typing? If yes and not for a medical or safety reason, switch the feature off (AI Act Art 5(1)(f)).
- Is each tool used to evaluate staff or to support decisions on hiring, pay, promotion, dismissal or tasks? If yes, treat it as likely high-risk under Annex III point 4 and plan for 2 Dec 2027.
- Have we written down the legal basis for each tool (GDPR Art 6(1))?
- Where we rely on a works or collective agreement, does that agreement itself respect Articles 5, 6(1) and 9 and include the Article 88(2) safeguards (C-34/21, C-65/23)?
- Could a less intrusive way do the same job, for example dummy data for a test, aggregate reports instead of individual scores (Art 5(1)(c))?
- Are health, union, biometric or other Article 9(1) data involved, and if so, which Article 9(2) condition applies?
- Have staff been told in writing, naming the tool, the purpose, the recipients and how long data is kept (Art 13)?
- Have we done a DPIA where the monitoring or evaluation is likely to result in a high risk (Art 35)?
- Does any data leave the EU/EEA, including to a group parent, and if so on what Chapter V basis?
Step 4: templates
Staff notice paragraph
From [date] we use [tool] for [purpose, e.g. planning shifts]. It processes [data categories]. Our legal basis is [basis under GDPR Article 6(1)][; for health or other special category data: Article 9(2)(..)]. The data is seen by [roles/suppliers] and kept for [period]. [It is / It is not] used to evaluate individual performance or to make decisions about you. [Data is transferred to [country] on the basis of [Chapter V basis].] You can ask for access, correction or erasure and object where the GDPR allows it: write to [contact].
Letter to staff representatives (before go-live)
Dear [works council / staff representatives], we plan to introduce [tool] from [date] for [purpose]. Attached: what data it uses, who sees it, whether it scores or evaluates individuals, the supplier, where data is stored, retention and the DPIA summary. We will not switch on [feature, e.g. emotion or productivity scoring]. Please tell us by [date] if you want to discuss it, or if national rules require consultation or agreement before we start.
Questions for the HR or AI supplier
1. Does any feature infer emotions, mood or stress of users? Can it be switched off for all our staff? 2. Is the tool intended for recruitment, task allocation, or monitoring or evaluating performance (AI Act Annex III point 4)? 3. Where is our staff data stored and is it accessible from outside the EU/EEA, including by group companies? 4. Can we test with dummy data before loading real staff data? 5. What logs and instructions for use will you provide?
Client email from the accountant or payroll bureau
Hello [name], before we load staff data into [tool] or switch on its new AI features, could you fill in the attached one-row check (12 answers, about 10 minutes)? It flags anything banned since February 2025 (AI that reads staff emotions), tools that become high-risk from December 2027, and gaps such as a missing staff notice or DPIA. It is not legal advice; for anything marked STOP we suggest speaking to an employment or data protection lawyer.
Related free guides
- Emotion recognition check sheet (AI Act Article 5(1)(f) ban)
- AI Act Annex III high-risk check for small businesses
- AI at work: staff and applicant notice template
- DPIA screening sheet (nine criteria)
- International transfer check sheet for US AI suppliers
- GDPR Article 22 automated decision sheet
Keep each tool, its supplier and its evidence in one place
Record each staff tool, its supplier, the AI Act answer and the evidence (supplier answers, staff notice, DPIA) in the EURO AI Register free edition. It runs in your browser with no account and no upload, covers your first 10 AI systems and 10 evidence records, the screening questions, duties by role with dates, and a printable Article 4 AI-literacy record.
When a client has more than 10 systems, the EURO AI Register membership starts at $19 a month and adds unlimited systems, rule updates and email help. Neither tool is legal advice or proof of compliance.
Partner programme opening soon
Partner programme opening soon: join the free waitlist. Planned terms are 50% of each referred sale (75% once you have 5+ paying customers), single level, paid through Gumroad only from revenue received.
Limits and open points
Read for this guide (2 Nov 2026, EUR-Lex): GDPR Articles 4(11), 5(1)(c), 6(1), 7(4), 9(2)(b), 13(1)-(2), 35(1)-(3), 88(1)-(3) and recitals 43 and 155; Court of Justice C-34/21 rulings and paras 59-61, 71-74; C-65/23 facts (paras 15-19) and paras 59-60 and rulings; AI Act (EU) 2024/1689 Article 5(1)(f), recital 44, Article 26(1)-(12), Article 113 and Annex III point 4; Regulation (EU) 2026/1744 (Digital Omnibus on AI) amendments to Article 113. We searched the Omnibus text for amendments to Article 5(1)(f) and Article 26 and found none (our check).
Not read for this guide: national employment data laws and works council rules (for example German, French or Austrian co-determination rules), EDPB or national authority guidance on employee monitoring and DPIA lists, the Commission guidelines on prohibited AI practices and on Article 6 high-risk classification, AI Act Article 6(3) exceptions, Chapter V transfer rules beyond the fact that they apply, and the 2024 EU directive on working conditions in app-based gig work.
Our reading, not the law's words: the category list in column B, the "likely high-risk" grade in column M, treating keystroke, screen and location monitoring as DPIA-likely, the "consent is weak" advice, the 14-day "URGENT" window and the sample wording in the templates. The Court of Justice left the final assessment in both cases to the national courts.
Frequently asked questions
Can a works agreement or collective agreement make staff monitoring lawful on its own?
Not on its own. The Court of Justice held that national rules adopted under GDPR Article 88(1), including rules in a collective agreement, must still require compliance with Article 5, Article 6(1) and Article 9(1) and (2), and that the parties' margin of discretion on what is 'necessary' does not stop a national court from carrying out a full review (C-65/23, 19 December 2024, rulings 1 and 2).
Is an AI tool that reads staff emotions allowed at work?
Since 2 February 2025 the AI Act prohibits the placing on the market, putting into service for this purpose or use of AI systems to infer emotions of a natural person in the areas of workplace and education institutions, except where the system is intended for medical or safety reasons (Article 5(1)(f), applying under Article 113(a)).
Are HR and staff-monitoring AI tools high-risk under the AI Act?
Annex III point 4 lists AI systems intended for recruitment or selection and AI systems intended to make decisions affecting terms of work-related relationships, promotion or termination, to allocate tasks based on individual behaviour or personal traits, or to monitor and evaluate performance and behaviour. Under Article 113 as amended by Regulation (EU) 2026/1744, the high-risk rules for Annex III systems apply from 2 December 2027. Article 6(3) exceptions can apply and are not assessed by this sheet.
Can we rely on staff consent?
GDPR Article 4(11) requires consent to be freely given, and recital 43 says consent should not be a valid ground where there is a clear imbalance between the person and the controller. Recital 155 lets national law or collective agreements set the conditions for employee consent. Our reading: for staff monitoring, plan for another legal basis and check national law.
Not legal advice. The sheet helps sort staff tools one by one; it does not decide legal questions. Spotted an error? Write to mininglife7@gmail.com and we correct it.
Sources
- Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR): Articles 4(11), 5(1)(c), 6(1), 7(4), 9(2)(b), 13, 35, 88, recitals 43, 155 — eur-lex.europa.eu, CELEX 32016R0679 (read 2 Nov 2026)
- Court of Justice, Case C-34/21 Hauptpersonalrat der Lehrerinnen und Lehrer, judgment of 30 March 2023 (First Chamber), paras 59-61, 71-74 and rulings — CELEX 62021CJ0034 (read 2 Nov 2026)
- Court of Justice, Case C-65/23 MK v K GmbH, judgment of 19 December 2024 (Eighth Chamber), paras 15-19, 59-60 and rulings — CELEX 62023CJ0065 (read 2 Nov 2026)
- Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (AI Act): Article 5(1)(f), recital 44, Article 26, Article 113, Annex III point 4 — CELEX 32024R1689 (read 2 Nov 2026)
- Regulation (EU) 2026/1744 (Digital Omnibus on AI), OJ L 24.7.2026, amendment of Article 113 — CELEX 32026R1744 (read 2 Nov 2026)
Unadhi Guides are free, independent explainers. We correct errors as soon as we find them: write to mininglife7@gmail.com.