Unadhi Guides

Controller or processor? GDPR role check sheet for accountants, payroll bureaus, bookkeepers and the AI suppliers they and their SME clients use (Articles 4(7), 4(8), 26, 28(10), C-683/21, EDPB Guidelines 07/2020)

Updated 29 Oct 2026 · Disclosure: the EURO AI Register mentioned below is an Unadhi product with a free edition. This guide is for information only, not legal advice.

What you get: a finished controller-or-processor role sheet for accountants, tax advisers, payroll bureaus and bookkeepers, and for the AI suppliers they and their small business clients use (AI invoice readers, chatbots, note-takers). One row per service or data flow: type in eleven short answers and the sheet returns the likely GDPR role (CONTROLLER, CONTROLLER (OWN PROFESSIONAL DUTIES), PROCESSOR (ART 28), SUB-PROCESSOR, JOINT CONTROLLERS (ART 26), SEPARATE CONTROLLERS, PROCESSOR, BUT CONTROLLER FOR ITS OWN USE (ART 28(10)), LIKELY CONTROLLER, UNCLEAR or NO PERSONAL DATA), the paperwork status (OK or GAP) and a to-do list citing the GDPR article, Court of Justice judgment or EDPB paragraph behind each step. Also included: a 9-question role checklist, two engagement letter clauses, an email to an AI supplier about using your data for its own purposes and a client email. Formulas tested in LibreOffice on eleven made-up rows.

Short answer: the controller is whoever "alone or jointly with others, determines the purposes and means of the processing"; a processor "processes personal data on behalf of the controller" (GDPR Article 4(7) and 4(8)). The EDPB uses the accountant as its own example: an accounting firm that audits a client under the rules of its profession, without detailed instructions, decides the purpose and means itself and is a controller; where no law sets the firm's duties and the client gives very detailed instructions, the firm "would indeed be acting as a processor" (EDPB Guidelines 07/2020, version 2.1, para 40). A payroll bureau following the employer's clear instructions on who to pay, what, when and how long to keep the data is the EDPB's example of a processor. And an AI supplier that starts using client data for its own purposes, such as its own business, is treated as a controller for that processing and infringes the GDPR (Article 28(10), EDPB para 81).

Why this question lands on the accountant's desk

Step 1: tab 1, Roles (one row per service or data flow)

Classify one party per row: your firm for each service, each AI supplier, or another firm. "Other party" means the business that hired or works with the party being classified.

ColumnWhat to writeSource
AService or data flow (for example "monthly payroll for Client X")You
BParty being classified: your firm, the AI supplier or another firmYou
CPurpose of the processing for that party: Other party only, Own too, Set by law (its own professional duties) or SharedArt 4(7), EDPB paras 35-36, 40
DWho decides the essential means: which data, whose data, how long and who receives it? Other party, This party or BothEDPB para 40
EDetailed documented instructions from the other party? Y or NArt 28(3)(a), Art 29
FDoes it also use the data for a purpose of its own, for example training its AI model or its own marketing? Y, N or UnknownArt 28(10), EDPB para 81
GIs the processing inseparable from the other party's, so it would not happen without both? Y or NArt 26(1), EDPB para 55
HEngaged by a processor, so a sub-processor? Y or NArt 28(2), 28(4)
IArticle 28 contract or terms in place? Y or NArt 28(3), 28(9)
JArticle 26 arrangement in place? Y or NArt 26(1)-(2)
KData: Personal, Anonymised or FictitiousArt 4(2), C-683/21
LLikely role: =IF(A2="","",IF(K2="Fictitious","NO PERSONAL DATA (FICTITIOUS)",IF(K2="Anonymised","NO PERSONAL DATA IF TRULY ANONYMOUS",IF(F2="Y",IF(C2="Other party only","PROCESSOR, BUT CONTROLLER FOR ITS OWN USE (ART 28(10))","CONTROLLER"),IF(C2="Shared",IF(G2="Y","JOINT CONTROLLERS (ART 26)","SEPARATE CONTROLLERS"),IF(C2="Set by law","CONTROLLER (OWN PROFESSIONAL DUTIES)",IF(C2="Own too","CONTROLLER",IF(OR(D2="Other party",E2="Y"),IF(H2="Y","SUB-PROCESSOR (ART 28(2), 28(4))","PROCESSOR (ART 28)"),IF(D2="This party","LIKELY CONTROLLER: DECIDES ESSENTIAL MEANS","UNCLEAR: GET INSTRUCTIONS IN WRITING")))))))))Formula (our reading)
MPaperwork: =IF(L2="","",IF(LEFT(L2,2)="NO","NONE: KEEP THE ANONYMISATION OR TEST-DATA NOTE",IF(ISNUMBER(SEARCH("PROCESSOR",L2)),IF(I2="Y",IF(F2="Y","GAP: OWN USE OUTSIDE INSTRUCTIONS",IF(F2="Unknown","GAP: ASK ABOUT OWN USE","OK: CONTRACT IN PLACE")),"GAP: ART 28 CONTRACT MISSING"),IF(LEFT(L2,5)="JOINT",IF(J2="Y","OK: ARRANGEMENT IN PLACE","GAP: ART 26 ARRANGEMENT MISSING"),IF(LEFT(L2,5)="UNCLE","GAP: ROLE UNCLEAR",IF(LEFT(L2,6)="LIKELY","GAP: ROLE LIKELY CONTROLLER","CHECK: OWN CONTROLLER DUTIES"))))))Formula
NTo-do: =IF(L2="","",TEXTJOIN("; ",TRUE,IF(LEFT(L2,2)="NO","data used for testing is still personal data unless anonymised so that the person is no longer identifiable, or fictitious (C-683/21)",""),IF(F2="Unknown","ask the supplier in writing whether it uses the data for its own purposes such as training its AI model, and put the answer in the contract",""),IF(AND(F2="Y",C2="Other party only"),"a processor that decides its own purposes and means for this use is a controller for it and infringes the GDPR (Art 28(10)): switch the setting off, change the terms or stop sending personal data",""),IF(AND(ISNUMBER(SEARCH("PROCESSOR",L2)),I2<>"Y"),"sign a contract with the Art 28(3) points (a) to (h), in writing, electronic form allowed (Art 28(9))",""),IF(H2="Y","a sub-processor needs the controller prior written authorisation and the same duties passed down (Art 28(2), 28(4)): tell the client",""),IF(ISNUMBER(SEARCH("PROCESSOR",L2)),"process only on documented instructions of the controller (Art 28(3)(a), Art 29) and keep a processor record (Art 30(2))",""),IF(OR(LEFT(L2,5)="UNCLE",LEFT(L2,6)="LIKELY"),"a processor must follow the controller instructions at least on purpose and essential means (EDPB 07/2020 para 80): get written instructions or accept the controller role",""),IF(AND(LEFT(L2,5)="JOINT",J2<>"Y"),"write the Art 26 arrangement (who answers data requests, who gives the Art 13/14 notice) and make its essence available; joint control exists even without an arrangement (C-683/21)",""),IF(LEFT(L2,5)="JOINT","people can use their rights against each joint controller whatever the arrangement says (Art 26(3))",""),IF(LEFT(L2,8)="SEPARATE","each controller answers only for the stages where it decides purposes and means (C-40/17)",""),IF(OR(LEFT(L2,10)="CONTROLLER",LEFT(L2,8)="SEPARATE",LEFT(L2,5)="JOINT",LEFT(L2,6)="LIKELY"),"controller duties: legal basis, privacy notice (Art 13/14), records (Art 30(1)), measures you can demonstrate (Art 24)",""),IF(C2="Set by law","EDPB 07/2020 accountants example: a firm auditing under its professional rules without detailed client instructions is a controller; say so in the engagement letter, no Art 28 contract for this flow",""),"write down who decided, why and the date"))Formula

Copy the formulas into row 2 and fill down. TEXTJOIN works in Excel 2019 or later, Microsoft 365, Google Sheets and LibreOffice. Column L is our reading of Article 4(7)-(8), Article 26, Article 28(10), the two judgments and the EDPB guidelines, written as a sorting rule: it checks test data first, then own use, shared purposes, professional duties and instructions. The role is a question of fact for each set of operations (EDPB para 82); the contract label does not decide it.

Example rows (made up) and what the sheet returns

Example (made up)Key answersLikely rolePaperwork
1: statutory audit of client accountsOur firm, purpose set by law, we decide the meansCONTROLLER (OWN PROFESSIONAL DUTIES)CHECK: OWN CONTROLLER DUTIES
2: monthly payroll run for a clientClient's purpose, client decides, written instructions, no contract yetPROCESSOR (ART 28)GAP: ART 28 CONTRACT MISSING
3: bookkeeping where the client gives no instructions and we set retention and accessClient's purpose, we decide the essential meansLIKELY CONTROLLER: DECIDES ESSENTIAL MEANSGAP: ROLE LIKELY CONTROLLER
4: AI invoice reader we use for client payrollAI supplier engaged by us as processor, terms in placeSUB-PROCESSOR (ART 28(2), 28(4))OK: CONTRACT IN PLACE
5: AI chatbot on a client web shop, terms allow training on chatsAI supplier, own use YPROCESSOR, BUT CONTROLLER FOR ITS OWN USE (ART 28(10))GAP: OWN USE OUTSIDE INSTRUCTIONS
6: AI note-taker for client meetings, training unclearAI supplier, own use Unknown, terms in placePROCESSOR (ART 28)GAP: ASK ABOUT OWN USE
7: joint webinar lead list with a law firmShared purpose, inseparable, no arrangementJOINT CONTROLLERS (ART 26)GAP: ART 26 ARRANGEMENT MISSING
8: testing a new client portal with made-up namesFictitious dataNO PERSONAL DATA (FICTITIOUS)NONE: KEEP THE ANONYMISATION OR TEST-DATA NOTE
9: bank paying salaries from the payroll fileBank, own purpose tooCONTROLLERCHECK: OWN CONTROLLER DUTIES
10: referral list passed to a tax adviser who then works aloneShared purpose, not inseparableSEPARATE CONTROLLERSCHECK: OWN CONTROLLER DUTIES
11: data entry help, decisions split, no instructions yetClient's purpose, both decide, no instructionsUNCLEAR: GET INSTRUCTIONS IN WRITINGGAP: ROLE UNCLEAR

The to-do for row 5, for example, reads: "a processor that decides its own purposes and means for this use is a controller for it and infringes the GDPR (Art 28(10)): switch the setting off, change the terms or stop sending personal data; process only on documented instructions of the controller (Art 28(3)(a), Art 29) and keep a processor record (Art 30(2)); write down who decided, why and the date". An empty row returns nothing.

Step 2: the 9-question role checklist (one service at a time)

  1. Why is the data processed, and for whom? Deciding the purpose is always for the controller; a processor "can never determine the purpose" (EDPB para 36).
  2. Who decides the essential means? Which data, for how long, who gets access and whose data: these are reserved to the controller. Software choice and detailed security can be left to a processor (EDPB para 40).
  3. Do professional rules set the task? For an audit done under the rules of the profession without detailed client instructions, the EDPB treats the accounting firm as a controller; it says the answer may differ where the processing is a limited, ancillary task (EDPB para 40, accountants example).
  4. Are there written instructions? A processor processes "only on documented instructions from the controller" (Article 28(3)(a)), and anyone acting under the controller's or processor's authority processes only on the controller's instructions (Article 29).
  5. Does anyone use the data for a purpose of its own? If a processor determines purposes and means, it "shall be considered to be a controller in respect of that processing" (Article 28(10)). Read the AI supplier's terms on model training and product improvement.
  6. Is another firm deciding with you? Joint control can come from a common decision or from converging decisions where the processing would not be possible without both (EDPB paras 54-55). No arrangement is needed for joint control to exist (C-683/21, operative part 2), but joint controllers must then set out their responsibilities in an arrangement, make its essence available, and people can use their rights against each of them (Article 26(1)-(3)).
  7. Is it only one stage? A website operator embedding a third-party plugin was a controller only for the collection and transmission it decided, not for what the plugin provider did afterwards (C-40/17 Fashion ID, operative part 2, decided under the old Directive 95/46). Under the same directive, the administrator of a fan page on a social network was held to be a controller (C-210/16 Wirtschaftsakademie, operative part 1).
  8. Did you commission a tool without touching the data? An entity that had an app developed and took part in deciding its purposes and means can be a controller even without processing the data itself, unless it expressly objected before release (C-683/21, operative part 1).
  9. Is it really personal data? Using personal data to test software is processing unless the data are anonymised so the person is no longer identifiable, or are fictitious (C-683/21, operative part 3).

Related sheets: Article 28 processor agreement (DPA) clause check, Article 26 joint controllers arrangement sheet, sub-processor change notice and objection sheet and Article 30 records of processing sheet.

Engagement letter clauses (templates)

Where the firm acts as controller (for example audit, tax returns, statutory accounts): For [services], [firm] decides how client personal data are processed under the rules of our profession and acts as a controller under the GDPR. We process the data only for these services and our legal and professional duties. Our privacy notice at [link] explains how.

Where the firm acts as processor (for example payroll processing on your instructions): For [services], [firm] processes personal data on your behalf and only on your documented instructions, as your processor. The attached data processing terms set out the points required by GDPR Article 28(3). We use these sub-processors: [list, including any AI tools], and we will tell you before adding or replacing one so that you can object.

Email to an AI supplier about using your data for its own purposes (template)

Subject: [AI tool], account [number]: do you use our data for your own purposes?

Hello,

We use [AI tool] to process personal data on behalf of our clients. Please confirm in writing by [date]: (1) whether you use any content, prompts, files or outputs from our account to train or improve your models or for any other purpose of your own; (2) if so, how to switch this off for our account and from which date; (3) which clause of your data processing terms says you process our data only on our documented instructions (GDPR Article 28(3)(a)); (4) your current list of sub-processors.

Kind regards, [name, firm]

Email to business clients (template)

Subject: Controller or processor? Our role for each service we do for you

Dear [name],

Data protection rules give each business a role for each service. For [audit / tax / statutory accounts] we decide how the data are handled under our professional rules, so we act as a controller. For [payroll / data entry] we act on your instructions, so we are your processor and we have sent you our processing terms. If a customer's questionnaire asks about us, please forward it and we will answer with the right role. Please also send us the list of AI tools you use with customer or staff data so we can check their terms with you.

This is a practical note, not legal advice. Kind regards, [firm]

Keep each AI tool, its supplier and its role in one place

Record each AI tool, its supplier, the role you worked out and the evidence (contract, settings, supplier answers) in the EURO AI Register free edition. It runs in your browser with no account and no upload, covers your first 10 AI systems and 10 evidence records, the screening questions, duties by role with dates, and a printable Article 4 AI-literacy record.

When a client has more than 10 systems, the EURO AI Register membership starts at $19 a month and adds unlimited systems, rule updates and email help. Neither tool is legal advice or proof of compliance.

Partner programme opening soon

Partner programme opening soon: join the free waitlist. Planned terms are 50% of each referred sale (75% once you have 5+ paying customers), single level, paid through Gumroad only from revenue received.

Limits and open points

Not read for this guide: we built it from the text of Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR) and the operative parts of judgments C-683/21, C-40/17 and C-210/16 on EUR-Lex, and from EDPB Guidelines 07/2020 version 2.1 (paras 31-44, 53-56, 67, 78-82 and the flowchart annex). We did not read the rest of those guidelines, other Court of Justice judgments on controllers (for example C-25/17 Jehovah's Witnesses, which the EDPB cites), national professional rules for accountants, auditors and tax advisers, national guidance from data protection authorities, the AI Act's provider and deployer roles (a separate question: see our AI Act provider or deployer role sheet), or any AI supplier's actual terms. Open points: column L is our sorting rule, not a legal test; the "Set by law" branch follows the EDPB example and may differ by country and by task, and the "SEPARATE CONTROLLERS" result for shared purposes that are not inseparable is our reading of EDPB para 55 and the flowchart. Where the answer matters, for example in a dispute, get legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

Is an accountant a controller or a processor under the GDPR?

It depends on the service. In the EDPB example, an accounting firm that audits a client under the rules of its profession, without detailed instructions, is a controller; where no law sets the firm's duties and the client gives very detailed instructions, it acts as a processor (EDPB Guidelines 07/2020, para 40). The same firm can be a controller for one service and a processor for another (para 82).

Is a payroll bureau a processor?

In the EDPB example, yes: a payroll administrator that pays salaries on the employer's clear instructions on who to pay, what amounts, by what date, how long to keep the data and what to send to the tax authority is a processor, even if it chooses its own software, as long as it does not go against or beyond those instructions (EDPB Guidelines 07/2020, para 40).

What if our AI supplier trains its model on our clients' data?

If a processor infringes the GDPR by determining the purposes and means of processing, it is considered a controller in respect of that processing (Article 28(10)); the EDPB says adding a purpose of its own makes the provider a controller for that processing and is an infringement (para 81). Ask the supplier in writing and switch the setting off or change the terms.

Do we need a contract to be joint controllers?

No. The Court of Justice held that classifying two entities as joint controllers does not require an arrangement between them (C-683/21, 5 December 2023, operative part 2). But once they are joint controllers, Article 26 requires them to set out their responsibilities in an arrangement and make its essence available to the people concerned.

Not legal advice. The sheet helps sort roles service by service; it does not decide legal questions. Spotted an error? Write to mininglife7@gmail.com and we correct it.

Sources

← All guides

Unadhi Guides are free, independent explainers. We correct errors as soon as we find them: write to mininglife7@gmail.com.