Consumer review check sheet for EU web shops: "verified" labels, the how-we-check-reviews notice and fake reviews (Unfair Commercial Practices Directive Article 7(6), Annex I points 23b and 23c) for accountants, bookkeepers and web agencies
Partner programme opening soon: join the free waitlist. Planned terms are 50% of each referred sale (75% once you have 5+ paying customers), single level, paid through Gumroad only from revenue received.
What you get: a finished consumer review check sheet in three tabs. The product pages tab has one row per product page: a product scraper fills the page list, you answer eight yes/no questions, and one formula writes the fix list with the legal reference for each line. The label finder tab works like this: paste the review box text and a formula flags "verified" or "customer review" labels in eight languages. The steps tab lists the checks the Commission gives as examples. You also get a copy-ready "how we check reviews" notice and a client email. Made-up example rows show how it fills in. We tested the formulas in a spreadsheet before publishing.
Short answer: since 28 May 2022 (Directive (EU) 2019/2161, Article 7), three EU rules apply to every web shop that shows consumer reviews or star ratings. Article 7(6) of the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive 2005/29/EC: if a trader provides access to consumer reviews, information about whether and how it ensures the reviews come from consumers who actually used or purchased the product is "material". Leaving it out can be a misleading omission. Annex I point 23b: saying the reviews come from such consumers without "reasonable and proportionate steps" to check is always unfair. Annex I point 23c: submitting or commissioning fake reviews, or misrepresenting reviews (for example publishing only the positive ones), is always unfair. National fines can reach at least 4% of annual turnover in coordinated cross-border cases (Article 13(3)).
Why accountants, bookkeepers and web agencies should look at this now
- Almost every shop theme shows stars. Shopify and WooCommerce review apps print labels such as "Verified buyer" by default. The label is a statement under point 23b, so the client needs a real check behind it.
- The notice is usually missing. Many small shops show reviews with no word on how they are collected, whether negative ones are published or how the average score is worked out. The Commission's guidance says this information belongs next to the reviews (section 4.2.4).
- Review incentives are common. "10% off for a review" emails, free samples and influencer seeding create rewarded reviews. Recital 47 of Directive 2019/2161 asks traders to say whether reviews have been sponsored or influenced by a contractual relationship.
- It is a quick, billable check. About 10 minutes per shop for three product pages, with one fix list you can send to the client or their web designer.
Step 1: get the page list (scrapers, free during launch)
- Put your client shop homepages in a list. Run the E-commerce Product Data Scraper with
maxProductsPerShop: 20. It returns one row per product withurl,shopandtitle. ItsSHOPS_SUMMARYrecord gives each shop a status (ok,blocked-by-terms,blocked-by-robots,no-products-found...). Pick three product pages per shop: the best seller, a new product and one with a low rating if you can see one. - Optional: run the Contact Details Scraper on the same homepages to get each shop's role mailbox (info@, support@) for sending the fix list. Personal addresses are dropped by default.
- Both Actors check robots.txt and scan each shop's terms of service first. Shops that forbid crawling are skipped for free and reported. The scrapers do not read or judge reviews. The review checks (columns D to K below) are done by hand, and the label finder tab speeds them up.
Step 2: tab 1, product pages (one row per page)
| Column | What to write | Source |
|---|---|---|
| A. Product page URL | url from the product scraper | Actor output |
| B. Shop | shop | Actor output |
| C. Scraper status | Shop status from SHOPS_SUMMARY | Actor output |
| D. Reviews or star ratings shown | Yes/No, including widgets from a review service | UCPD Art. 7(6) |
| E. Labelled as buyer, verified or customer reviews | Yes/No (use tab 2). The guidance says plain "customer reviews" can be enough | Annex I 23b; guidance 4.2.4 |
| F. "How we check reviews" notice reachable from the reviews | Yes/No: text or a clearly visible link on the same page as the reviews | Art. 7(6); guidance 4.2.4 |
| G. Notice says whether all reviews, positive and negative, are published | Yes/No | Art. 7(6), Rec. 47 |
| H. Notice says how the average score is calculated | Yes/No | Art. 7(6); guidance 4.2.4 |
| I. A real check step exists | Yes/No/Unknown: ask the client, e.g. invitations only after an order, order number required, email verification | Annex I 23b; Rec. 47 |
| J. Rewarded or sponsored reviews marked | Yes/No/N/A (N/A = the client gives no rewards for reviews) | Art. 7(6), Rec. 47 |
| K. Bought, staff-written or filtered reviews | Yes/No/Unknown: ask the client. "Filtered" means negative reviews held back for no valid reason | Annex I 23c; Rec. 49 |
| L. Fix list | Formula below | our working rule |
| M. Result | Formula below: OK / FIX / STOP NOW / CHECK BY HAND | our working rule |
L2 (fix list), Google Sheets or Excel 365:
=IF(AND(C2<>"",C2<>"ok"),"CHECK BY HAND (scraper: "&C2&")",
IF(D2="No","",TEXTJOIN("; ",TRUE,
IF(K2="Yes","STOP: remove bought, staff-written or filtered reviews (UCPD Annex I 23c)",""),
IF(K2="Unknown","Ask client: any paid, staff-written or filtered reviews? (Annex I 23c)",""),
IF(F2<>"Yes","Add a how-we-check-reviews notice next to the reviews (UCPD Art. 7(6))",""),
IF(AND(E2="Yes",I2<>"Yes"),"Remove the verified or customer label, or add a real purchase check (Annex I 23b)",""),
IF(AND(F2="Yes",G2<>"Yes"),"Say whether all reviews, positive and negative, are published (Art. 7(6), Rec. 47)",""),
IF(AND(F2="Yes",H2<>"Yes"),"Explain how the average star score is calculated (Art. 7(6), Commission guidance 4.2.4)",""),
IF(J2="No","Mark reviews given for a reward or discount (Art. 7(6), Rec. 47)",""))))
M2 (result): =IF(LEFT(L2,5)="CHECK","CHECK BY HAND",IF(ISNUMBER(SEARCH("STOP:",L2)),"STOP NOW",IF(L2="","OK","FIX")))
Example rows (made up, for illustration only). We entered these rows in a spreadsheet, and the formulas returned the results shown:
| B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | M |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| example-shoes.de | ok | Yes | Yes | No | No | N/A | No | FIX (add notice; label without a check) | ||
| example-tea.nl | ok | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | OK |
| example-lamps.fr | blocked-by-terms | CHECK BY HAND | ||||||||
| example-bikes.at | ok | Yes | No | Yes | No | No | Unknown | No | Unknown | FIX (ask client; add 3 notice details) |
| example-toys.es | ok | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | STOP NOW |
Step 3: tab 2, label finder (paste the review box text)
Open each product page, copy the text of the review box (heading, star summary, badges) and paste it into column B, with the page URL in column A.
C2, works in Excel, Google Sheets and LibreOffice:
=IF(B2="","",IF(SUMPRODUCT(--ISNUMBER(SEARCH({"verified","verifiziert","vérifié","geverifieerd","verificad","verificat","zweryfikowan","customer review","kundenbewertung","avis client","klantbeoordeling","opiniones de clientes","recensioni clienti","opinie klientów"},B2)))>0,"LABEL FOUND: set E to Yes","no buyer or customer label"))
The word list is our suggestion, not a legal term from the Directive. It catches common English, German, French, Dutch, Spanish, Italian, Portuguese and Polish labels; add the words your clients' review apps use. "No label found" does not mean E is No: read the box yourself.
Step 4: tab 3, check steps (what counts as "reasonable and proportionate")
Section 4.2.4 of the Commission's guidance (2021/C 526/01) lists these as possible steps. What is enough depends on the business model, its size and the level of risk. Small shops are not expected to match large review sites and marketplaces, and checks must not make honest reviewing too hard.
| Step | Client does it? (Yes/No) | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Ask for information that shows the purchase or use, e.g. an order or booking number | Rec. 47; guidance 4.2.4 | |
| Require reviewers to register | guidance 4.2.4 | |
| Technical checks that the reviewer is a consumer (e.g. email verification, IP address check) | guidance 4.2.4 | |
| Clear rules for reviewers banning fake and undisclosed sponsored reviews | guidance 4.2.4 | |
| Tools that detect fraudulent reviews automatically | guidance 4.2.4 | |
| A way to handle complaints about suspicious reviews | guidance 4.2.4 |
Practices to stop (Annex I 23c, Recital 49, guidance 4.2.4): buying reviews or likes, or asking staff, friends or paid people to write them; publishing only positive reviews and deleting negative ones; linking a customer's endorsement to different content than they meant; pre-filled positive review templates; contacting customers during moderation to get them to change or withdraw a negative review; and average ratings built on undisclosed or opaque criteria. Removing fake negative reviews as part of a real check remains allowed.
What the law says, in short
- Article 7(6) UCPD (inserted by Article 3(4)(c) of Directive 2019/2161): "Where a trader provides access to consumer reviews of products, information about whether and how the trader ensures that the published reviews originate from consumers who have actually used or purchased the product shall be regarded as material."
- Recital 47 of Directive 2019/2161: traders should say whether processes are in place, how the checks are made, and how reviews are processed, for example whether all reviews, positive or negative, are posted and whether reviews have been sponsored or influenced by a contractual relationship with a trader.
- Commission guidance, section 4.2.4: the duty applies to any trader giving access to reviews, also through a third-party review tool shown on its site. The information must be clear and intelligible and available on the same interface where the reviews are shown, including through clearly identified, prominent links. It covers how reviews are sourced, whether all are published and how average scores are calculated. "Reviews" includes ratings.
- Annex I points 23b and 23c (inserted by Article 3(7)(b) of Directive 2019/2161) are practices that are unfair "in all circumstances". No test of the effect on the consumer is needed.
- Penalties, Article 13 (replaced by Article 3(6)): effective, proportionate and dissuasive. In coordinated actions under Article 21 of Regulation (EU) 2017/2394, the maximum fine must be at least 4% of the trader's annual turnover in the Member States concerned, or at least EUR 2 million where turnover information is not available. National amounts and procedures are set by each Member State.
- Dates: Member States had to adopt the rules by 28 November 2021 and apply them from 28 May 2022 (Directive 2019/2161, Article 7(1)).
Copy-ready "how we check reviews" notice (our suggestion)
Put it directly above or below the reviews, or link to it there with a visible link such as "How we check reviews". Change it to match what the client really does. Never claim a check that does not happen:
"How we check reviews. We invite reviews only from customers who have placed an order, by an email sent [X] days after delivery. Each review is linked to an order number. We publish all reviews, positive and negative, except those that break our review rules (abusive language, personal data, or not about the product). The star score is the average of all published reviews for this product over [all time / the last X months]. Customers who received [a discount / a free product] for a review are marked as such. Questions about a review: [role email]."
If the client does not check reviews: remove "verified" and "customer" labels, and say plainly: "We do not check whether reviewers have bought the product."
Client email: "Hello [name], EU consumer law (Directive 2005/29/EC, Article 7(6) and Annex I points 23b and 23c) requires shops that show reviews to explain whether and how they check them, and forbids 'verified' labels without a real check. We looked at [pages]. The fix list is in the attached sheet. Most items are a short notice next to the reviews and a setting in your review app. [your name]"
Try it on one client shop first
Run the product scraper on one shop, check three product pages, then do the rest. Related free sheets: green claims check · withdrawal button check · GPSR product page check · unit price check.
Frequently asked questions
Does a small web shop have to explain how it checks reviews?
Yes, if it shows consumer reviews or ratings. Article 7(6) of Directive 2005/29/EC treats information on whether and how the trader ensures reviews come from real buyers or users as material. If the shop does not check, it should say so and must not present the reviews as coming from buyers.
Can a shop label reviews as "verified"?
Only if it takes reasonable and proportionate steps to check that they come from consumers who actually used or purchased the product, for example by linking reviews to orders. Otherwise it is a banned practice under Annex I point 23b.
Can a shop delete negative reviews?
Publishing only positive reviews and deleting negative ones misrepresents reviews and is banned under Annex I point 23c (Recital 49 of Directive 2019/2161). Removing fake negative reviews as part of a genuine check of where reviews come from remains allowed (Commission guidance, section 4.2.4).
Not legal advice. The sheet helps a person find missing review information and risky labels. It does not decide whether a client's checks are enough, and it does not cover national rules or penalties. When in doubt, ask your consumer authority or a lawyer. Spotted an error? Write to mininglife7@gmail.com and we correct it.
Sources
- Directive 2005/29/EC on unfair commercial practices, consolidated text 28.5.2022: Articles 7(1), 7(2), 7(6), 13; Annex I points 23b, 23c — eur-lex.europa.eu, CELEX 02005L0029-20220528 (read 29 Oct 2026)
- Directive (EU) 2019/2161 of 27 November 2019 (OJ L 328, 18.12.2019): Recitals 47, 49; Article 3(4)(c), 3(6), 3(7)(b); Article 7(1) — CELEX 32019L2161 (read 29 Oct 2026)
- Commission Notice, Guidance on the interpretation and application of Directive 2005/29/EC (2021/C 526/01, OJ C 526, 29.12.2021): section 4.2.4 User reviews — CELEX 52021XC1229(05) (read 29 Oct 2026)
- Unadhi Actors on Apify Store: E-commerce Product Data Scraper and Contact Details Scraper (build 0.1.3 READMEs read through the Apify API on 29 Oct 2026)
Unadhi Guides are free, independent explainers. We correct errors as soon as we find them: write to mininglife7@gmail.com.