CSRD value chain cap answer sheet for accountants and SME clients: which ESG questionnaire items a company with up to 1,000 employees may decline under Directive (EU) 2026/470 and the voluntary standard in Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1560, from financial years starting 1 January 2027
What you get: a finished, tested value chain cap answer sheet for accountants, bookkeepers and tax advisers whose SME clients get sustainability (ESG) questionnaires from large customers. One row per question. Formulas tell you whether the client is a protected undertaking (1,000 employees or fewer), whether the question is inside the cap (the 23 datapoints in Annex II of Delegated Regulation 2026/1560, with the smaller list for 10 employees or fewer), and give a result: ANSWER, MAY DECLINE, SHARE VOLUNTARILY, CAP NOT YET, CAP DOES NOT APPLY, NOT PROTECTED, ASK PURPOSE or FIX. A to-do column cites the Article. Ready-to-send size self-declaration and decline wording are below the sheet.
Partner programme opening soon: join the free waitlist. Planned terms are 50% of each referred sale (75% once you have 5+ paying customers), single level, paid through Gumroad only from revenue received.
Short answer: after Omnibus I, only companies and groups with more than EUR 450 million net turnover and more than 1,000 employees on average must publish sustainability reports (new Article 19a(1) and 29a(1) of Directive 2013/34/EU; Article 5(2) of Directive 2022/2464 for financial years from 1 January 2027). A company in their value chain that did not exceed an average of 1,000 employees in the preceding financial year is a "protected undertaking": it has a statutory right to decline any information beyond the voluntary standard when the request is for that sustainability reporting (Article 19a(3)). The voluntary standard and its cap list are in Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1560; the cap applies from the reporting company's financial years beginning on or after 1 January 2027 (its Article 4). Countries must put the Directive into national law by 19 March 2027 (Directive 2026/470, Article 5).
What to tell a client in one minute
- You probably do not have to report yourself. Mandatory reporting is now only for companies over EUR 450 million turnover and 1,000 employees.
- Big customers may still ask you questions for their own report. If you had 1,000 employees or fewer on average last year, they can only require the items on the cap list; you may say no to the rest (Article 19a(3)).
- They must tell you which questions go beyond the cap and that you have a right to decline (Article 19a(3), point (c)).
- A contract clause that forces you to give more for their CSRD report is not binding, but the rest of the contract is (Article 19a(3), point (b)).
- The cap does not cover everything. Questions for due diligence, a bank loan, or the customer's own risk management are outside it.
Why AI tools matter here
Large customers now send ESG questionnaires through supplier portals, and many SMEs answer them with AI writing tools or let a tool pre-fill every field. Check the cap first: anything outside the 23 datapoints is optional for a protected client in a CSRD request, and an AI tool should not volunteer it by default. If your client uses AI tools to prepare answers, list them in the free edition of the EURO AI Register so you can also answer the AI questions in the same questionnaire. See also our AI Act customer questionnaire answer sheet, the NIS2 supplier security questionnaire sheet and the Accounting Directive company size check sheet.
The rules the sheet uses
| Rule | What the text says | Where |
|---|---|---|
| Who must report | Over EUR 450 million net turnover and over 1,000 employees on average (also at group level) | Dir 2013/34 Art 19a(1), 29a(1) as amended by Dir 2026/470 Art 2 |
| Protected undertaking | In the value chain of a reporting company and not over an average of 1,000 employees during the preceding financial year, on its balance sheet date | Art 19a(3), 29a(3) |
| Self-declaration | The reporting company may rely on the supplier's self-declaration of size, unless it knows or should know it is manifestly incorrect | Art 19a(3) |
| Right to decline | Protected undertakings may decline information beyond the voluntary standard, for CSRD reporting requests | Art 19a(3) |
| Contracts | May not require more than the voluntary standard for CSRD purposes; a contrary clause is not binding, the rest stays binding | Art 19a(3), points (a), (b) |
| Tell the supplier | Requests beyond the standard must say which items exceed it and that the supplier may decline | Art 19a(3), point (c) |
| Outside the cap | Requests for other purposes, including due diligence; the cap creates no duty to give anything | Art 19a(3) |
| The cap list | Only the datapoints in Annex II; fewer for 10 employees or fewer | Del Reg 2026/1560 Art 3, Annex II |
| From when | Financial years beginning on or after 1 January 2027 | Del Reg 2026/1560 Art 4 |
| National law | By 19 March 2027 | Dir 2026/470 Art 5 |
| Due diligence (CSDDD) | From 26 July 2029: ask partners with fewer than 5,000 employees only for information that cannot reasonably be obtained by other means | Dir 2024/1760 Art 8(2a), Art 37 as amended |
| Banks and investors | Only encouraged to keep requests to the voluntary standard | Del Reg 2026/1560 recital 5 |
The cap list (tab Cap, rows 2 to 24)
Copy this table into a tab called Cap: column A code, B disclosure, C reference, D datapoint, E X if in the cap for 10 employees or fewer, F X if in the cap for more than 10. The full references (for example "B3 Para 32, first sentence") are in Annex II.
| Code | DR | Datapoint | 10 or fewer | More than 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CAP01 | B1 | Selected module option (basic and/or comprehensive) | yes | yes |
| CAP02 | B1 | Choice of reporting basis (individual or consolidated) | yes | yes |
| CAP03 | B1 | General undertaking’s information | yes | yes |
| CAP04 | B3 | Total energy consumption in MWh | no | yes |
| CAP05 | B3 | Estimated absolute gross greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions | no | yes |
| CAP06 | B6 | Total water withdrawal | no | yes |
| CAP07 | B7 | Circular economy principles application | no | yes |
| CAP08 | B7 | Total weight of waste generated, with a breakdown between hazardous and non-hazardous waste | no | yes |
| CAP09 | B7 | Proportion of waste diverted to recycling or reuse | no | yes |
| CAP10 | B8 | Number of employees (in headcount or full-time equivalent) per type of employment contract | yes | yes |
| CAP11 | B8 | Number of employees (in headcount or full-time equivalent) per gender | yes | yes |
| CAP12 | B9 | Number and rate of recordable work-related accidents | yes | yes |
| CAP13 | B10 | Whether the employees receive pay that is equal or above applicable minimum wage for the country it reports on | yes | yes |
| CAP14 | B10 | Percentage of employees covered by collective bargaining agreements | yes | yes |
| CAP15 | B10 | Average number of annual training hours per employee | yes | yes |
| CAP16 | C1 | Description of significant groups of products and/or services offered | no | yes |
| CAP17 | C1 | Description of significant market(s) the undertaking operates in | no | yes |
| CAP18 | C1 | Description of main business relationships | no | yes |
| CAP19 | C5 | Employee turnover rate | no | yes |
| CAP20 | C6 | Code of conduct or human rights policy | no | yes |
| CAP21 | C6 | Complaints-handling mechanism | no | yes |
| CAP22 | C7 | Confirmed incidents in its own workforce | no | yes |
| CAP23 | C7 | Confirmed incidents involving workers in the value chain, affected communities, consumers and end-users | no | yes |
The sheet, one row per question (tab Questions, columns A to R)
Headers in row 1, inputs from row 2, formulas M2 to R2 filled down. Tab Settings: B1 =TODAY(), B2 2027-01-01 (cap start), B3 2027-03-19 (national law deadline).
| Col | What goes in it | Based on |
|---|---|---|
| A | Client (the company being asked) | You |
| B | Client's average employees during the preceding financial year | Art 19a(3) |
| C, D | Requester and the question in a few words | You |
| E | Purpose: CSRD, CSDDD, BANK, OTHER or UNKNOWN | Art 19a(3) |
| F | Start date of the requester's reporting financial year (CSRD rows) | Del Reg Art 4 |
| G | Matching cap code CAP01 to CAP23, or NONE | Annex II |
| H | Requester marked the extra items and your right to decline: Y / N | Art 19a(3)(c) |
| I | Asked under a signed contract: Y / N | Art 19a(3)(b) |
| J | Client wants to share anyway: Y / N | Voluntary |
| K | Notes | You |
| M | Input check: OK or FIX with the reason | Helper |
| N | Size band: PROTECTED (10 OR FEWER), PROTECTED (11 TO 1000), NOT PROTECTED (OVER 1000) | Art 19a(3), Annex II |
| O | Inside the cap for this size: YES / NO | Annex II |
| P | Value chain cap applies: YES, NOT YET, NO with the reason, or UNKNOWN | Art 19a(3), Del Reg Art 4 |
| Q | To-do with cites | As cited |
| R | Result | Summary |
Formulas (row 2; fill down). In Excel files saved by some tools TEXTJOIN shows as _xlfn.TEXTJOIN; that is the same function.
M2: =IF(A2="","",IF(OR(B2="",NOT(ISNUMBER(B2))),"FIX: ENTER THE CLIENT'S AVERAGE EMPLOYEES FOR THE PRECEDING FINANCIAL YEAR",IF(B2<0,"FIX: EMPLOYEES CANNOT BE NEGATIVE",IF(NOT(OR(E2="CSRD",E2="CSDDD",E2="BANK",E2="OTHER",E2="UNKNOWN")),"FIX: PURPOSE MUST BE CSRD, CSDDD, BANK, OTHER OR UNKNOWN",IF(AND(E2="CSRD",F2=""),"FIX: ENTER THE START DATE OF THE REQUESTER'S REPORTING FINANCIAL YEAR",IF(AND(G2<>"NONE",COUNTIF(Cap!$A$2:$A$24,G2)=0),"FIX: CAP CODE MUST BE CAP01 TO CAP23 FROM THE CAP TAB, OR NONE",IF(NOT(AND(OR(H2="",H2="Y",H2="N"),OR(I2="",I2="Y",I2="N"),OR(J2="",J2="Y",J2="N"))),"FIX: COLUMNS H, I AND J MUST BE Y, N OR EMPTY","OK")))))))
N2: =IF(NOT(M2="OK"),"",IF(B2<=10,"PROTECTED (10 OR FEWER)",IF(B2<=1000,"PROTECTED (11 TO 1000)","NOT PROTECTED (OVER 1000)")))
O2: =IF(NOT(M2="OK"),"",IF(G2="NONE","NO",IF(VLOOKUP(G2,Cap!$A$2:$F$24,IF(B2<=10,5,6),FALSE)="X","YES","NO")))
P2: =IF(NOT(M2="OK"),"",IF(E2="UNKNOWN","UNKNOWN: ASK THE PURPOSE",IF(E2<>"CSRD","NO: NOT FOR CSRD SUSTAINABILITY REPORTING",IF(B2>1000,"NO: OVER 1000 EMPLOYEES",IF(F2<Settings!$B$2,"NOT YET: REQUESTER'S FINANCIAL YEAR STARTS BEFORE "&TEXT(Settings!$B$2,"YYYY-MM-DD"),"YES")))))
Q2: =IF(A2="","",TEXTJOIN("; ",TRUE,IF(M2="OK","","Fix the input shown in column M"),IF(AND(M2="OK",P2="YES"),"Send the size self-declaration below; the requester may rely on it (Art 19a(3))",""),IF(AND(M2="OK",P2="YES",O2="YES"),"Inside the value chain cap ("&G2&", Delegated Reg 2026/1560 Annex II): answer from your voluntary standard data",""),IF(AND(M2="OK",P2="YES",O2="NO",J2<>"Y"),"Beyond the cap: you may decline this item (Art 19a(3)); use the decline wording below",""),IF(AND(M2="OK",P2="YES",O2="NO",H2<>"Y"),"The requester should have told you which items exceed the cap and that you may decline (Art 19a(3)(c)): ask them to mark the items",""),IF(AND(M2="OK",P2="YES",O2="NO",I2="Y"),"A contract term requiring more than the cap for CSRD reporting is not binding (Art 19a(3)(b)); the rest of the contract stays binding",""),IF(AND(M2="OK",P2="YES",O2="NO",J2="Y"),"You chose to share voluntarily: that is allowed; keep a note that it was voluntary",""),IF(AND(M2="OK",LEFT(P2,3)="NOT"),"Cap applies from financial years starting on or after 1 Jan 2027 (Delegated Reg 2026/1560 Art 4); offer your voluntary standard data first",""),IF(AND(M2="OK",E2="CSRD",B2>1000),"Over 1000 employees: not a protected undertaking (Art 19a(3)(b)(i)); check your own CSRD scope",""),IF(AND(M2="OK",E2="CSDDD"),"Due diligence requests are outside the cap; from 26 Jul 2029 large companies may ask partners with fewer than 5000 employees only for information they cannot reasonably get otherwise (CSDDD Art 8(2a))",""),IF(AND(M2="OK",E2="BANK"),"Outside the cap; banks and investors are only encouraged to keep to the voluntary standard (Delegated Reg 2026/1560 recital 5)",""),IF(AND(M2="OK",E2="OTHER"),"Outside the cap: answer under your contract or negotiate",""),IF(AND(M2="OK",E2="UNKNOWN"),"Ask the requester whether this is for sustainability reporting under the Accounting Directive (CSRD)",""),IF(AND(M2="OK",E2="CSRD",Settings!$B$1<Settings!$B$3),"National law for the cap is due by "&TEXT(Settings!$B$3,"YYYY-MM-DD")&" (Directive 2026/470 Art 5): check your country's text",""),IF(AND(M2="OK",O2="YES",B2<=10),"10 or fewer employees: only the cap items marked for that size can be required","")))
R2: =IF(A2="","",IF(NOT(M2="OK"),"FIX",IF(E2="UNKNOWN","ASK PURPOSE",IF(P2="YES",IF(O2="YES","ANSWER",IF(J2="Y","SHARE VOLUNTARILY","MAY DECLINE")),IF(LEFT(P2,3)="NOT","CAP NOT YET",IF(P2="NO: OVER 1000 EMPLOYEES","NOT PROTECTED","CAP DOES NOT APPLY"))))))
Size self-declaration (copy and fill)
Size self-declaration for sustainability reporting requests Company: [name], [registration number] We confirm that on our balance sheet date of [date] we did not exceed an average of 1,000 employees during the preceding financial year ([number] employees on average). We are therefore a protected undertaking under Article 19a(3) / 29a(3) of Directive 2013/34/EU as amended by Directive (EU) 2026/470. [Name, role, date]
Decline wording (copy and fill)
Thank you for your questionnaire of [date]. We attach our size self-declaration. We have answered the items that are within the voluntary standard in Annex II of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1560 ([list cap codes]). As a protected undertaking we decline to provide items [list] because they exceed the voluntary standard (Article 19a(3) of Directive 2013/34/EU). If any item is requested for a purpose other than your sustainability reporting, please tell us the purpose.
What we tested
Seventeen made-up questions in LibreOffice (xlsx → ods → csv), in two runs (today 10 Nov 2026, then 1 Apr 2027). A 40-employee client asked for energy use (CAP04: ANSWER), Scope 3 emissions (not in the cap: MAY DECLINE) and its pay gap with "share anyway" (SHARE VOLUNTARILY); an 8-employee client asked for energy use (not in the cap for 10 or fewer: MAY DECLINE) and employees by gender (CAP11: ANSWER); a 1,500-employee client (NOT PROTECTED); a request for a financial year starting 1 Jan 2026 (CAP NOT YET); bank and due diligence requests (CAP DOES NOT APPLY); an unknown purpose (ASK PURPOSE); exactly 1,000 employees asked for GHG emissions (still protected: ANSWER); exactly 10 employees asked for employee turnover (MAY DECLINE); and five bad inputs (unknown cap code, missing employees, missing financial year, unknown purpose, "maybe" in a Y/N column), each FIX with the reason. All 17 + 17 results as intended, the empty row stays blank, 0 errors; the "check your national law" to-do shows before 19 Mar 2027 and disappears after.
Checklist before 1 January 2027
- For each client, write down average employees for the last financial year and keep a signed size self-declaration ready.
- Collect the cap datapoints the client can answer (energy, GHG estimate, water, waste, staff numbers, accidents, minimum wage, collective bargaining, training hours, and the comprehensive items if over 10 employees).
- Log every questionnaire question in the sheet with its purpose.
- Answer cap items; decline or share the rest by choice, and keep the note.
- Check supplier contracts for ESG clauses that demand more than the cap.
- Check what AI tools the client uses to fill questionnaires and what they send.
Limits and our reading
- Not read, flagged: national laws transposing Directive 2026/470 (due 19 March 2027); the full text of Annex I of Delegated Regulation 2026/1560 beyond paragraph 27 and the paragraphs named in Annex II; EFRAG guidance; the revised ESRS delegated act; Recommendation 2025/1710 (no longer producing legal effects, recital 5).
- Our reading: the sheet uses one employee number for both the 1,000 test and the 10-employee split in Annex II (Annex II does not say how to count the 10); a question is "inside the cap" only if it matches an Annex II datapoint (recital 4 says only essential datapoints are covered); purpose CSRD covers both individual (Art 19a) and group (Art 29a) reports; the cap start date is read against the requester's financial year.
Questions
Can an SME refuse a large customer's ESG questionnaire after Omnibus I?
Partly. If it did not exceed an average of 1,000 employees in the preceding financial year, it may decline any information beyond the voluntary standard when the request is for the customer's sustainability reporting (Article 19a(3) of Directive 2013/34/EU as amended by Directive (EU) 2026/470).
What information is inside the value chain cap?
The 23 datapoints in Annex II of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1560, such as total energy use in MWh, estimated GHG emissions, water withdrawal, waste, employee numbers by contract type and gender, accidents, minimum wage, collective bargaining coverage and training hours. Companies with 10 employees or fewer have a shorter list.
When does the value chain cap apply?
Article 3 of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1560 applies from financial years beginning on or after 1 January 2027. Member States must transpose Directive 2026/470 by 19 March 2027.
Is a contract clause demanding full ESG data binding?
A clause requiring a protected undertaking to give more than the voluntary standard for CSRD reporting is not binding; the rest of the contract remains binding (Article 19a(3), point (b)).
Does the cap cover bank or due diligence questionnaires?
No. It covers only requests for sustainability reporting under the Accounting Directive. Banks are only encouraged to keep to the voluntary standard, and due diligence requests fall under the CSDDD, where from 26 July 2029 partners with fewer than 5,000 employees should only be asked for information that cannot reasonably be obtained otherwise.
Who must still publish a CSRD report?
Companies and groups exceeding both EUR 450 million net turnover and an average of 1,000 employees during the financial year, for financial years starting on or after 1 January 2027.
Unadhi Guides are free, independent explainers. We correct errors as soon as we find them: write to mininglife7@gmail.com.