EU Data Act Article 13 unfair contract terms check sheet for cloud, AI and SaaS data clauses: the always-unfair list, the presumed-unfair list, take-it-or-leave-it terms and older contracts from 12 September 2027, for accountants and SME clients
What you get: a finished Data Act unfair terms check sheet for accountants, tax advisers and bookkeepers reviewing their own and their clients' cloud, AI tool, SaaS and data supplier contracts. One row per data clause returns UNFAIR, NOT BINDING, PRESUMED UNFAIR, CHECK BY HAND, NOT UNILATERALLY IMPOSED, NOT UNFAIR, OUTSIDE or MISSING DATA, tells you whether Chapter IV applies now or from 12 September 2027 (with days left), and gives a to-do list citing the articles. Rebuild it from the formulas below (tested in LibreOffice on fifteen made-up rows). Also included: a term-type key, a checklist and a template letter to the supplier.
Deliverable: rebuild the Excel/LibreOffice check sheet from the column list and formulas in Step 1.
Short answer: under Article 13 of the EU Data Act (Regulation (EU) 2023/2854), a data term that a supplier imposed on your business on a take-it-or-leave-it basis is not binding on you if it is unfair. Three kinds of term are always unfair (Article 13(4)), seven are presumed unfair (Article 13(5)), and the rest face a general test (Article 13(3)). It covers terms about access to and use of data and liability and remedies for data obligations, not the price or the main subject matter. It applies to contracts concluded after 12 September 2025 now, and from 12 September 2027 to older contracts that are open-ended or run to at least 11 January 2034 (Article 50).
Why this lands on the accountant's desk
- 307 days left (from 9 Nov 2026) to 12 September 2027, when older open-ended cloud, AI tool and data contracts come into scope.
- Small firms rarely negotiate supplier terms. Article 13 only bites if you tried and could not change the term (Article 13(6)), so the evidence of asking matters.
- AI tool terms often let the supplier reuse your data or refuse an export. Those match the presumed-unfair types in Article 13(5)(b), (c) and (e).
Partner programme opening soon
Partner programme opening soon: join the free waitlist. Planned terms are 50% of each referred sale (75% once you have 5+ paying customers), single level, paid through Gumroad only from revenue received.
Step 1: the check sheet
Create a sheet named Terms with headers in row 1 and the first clause in row 2. Enter Y, N, Unsure, Indefinite, Fixed and the type codes exactly as shown, and columns B and D as dates. Create a sheet named Settings and put =TODAY() in B1 (our test file fixes B1 at 9 Nov 2026). Copy K2 to M2 down. TEXTJOIN works in Excel 2019 or later, LibreOffice and Google Sheets.
| Col | Header / formula | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| A | Contract and clause (your label) | Your label; no personal names needed |
| B | Date the contract was concluded | Enter as a date; Art 50 |
| C | Duration (Indefinite / Fixed) | Art 50 |
| D | Fixed end date (blank if indefinite) | Enter as a date; Art 50(b) |
| E | Term about data access or use, or liability and remedies for breach or termination of data obligations? (Y/N) | Art 13(1) |
| F | Unilaterally imposed: supplied by the other side and you could not change it despite trying? (Y/N/Unsure) | Art 13(6) |
| G | Term type (4a, 4b, 4c, 5a to 5g, or Other; see the key below) | Art 13(4), (5) |
| H | Reflects mandatory Union law or the default rule that would apply anyway? (Y/N) | Art 13(2) |
| I | Defines the main subject matter or the adequacy of the price? (Y/N) | Art 13(8) |
| J | For 5g only: open-ended contract, valid reason stated, reasonable notice and you can terminate free of charge? (Y/N) | Art 13(5), second subparagraph |
| K | Chapter IV timing: =IF(A2="","",IF(OR(B2="",C2="",AND(C2="Fixed",D2="")),"MISSING DATES",IF(B2>DATE(2025,9,12),"APPLIES NOW: CONCLUDED AFTER 12 SEP 2025",IF(AND(B2<=DATE(2025,9,12),C2="Fixed",D2<DATE(2034,1,11)),"NOT COVERED: CONCLUDED BY 12 SEP 2025 AND ENDS BEFORE 11 JAN 2034",IF(Settings!$B$1>=DATE(2027,9,12),"APPLIES SINCE 12 SEP 2027 (OLDER LONG CONTRACT)","APPLIES FROM 12 SEP 2027: "&(DATE(2027,9,12)-Settings!$B$1)&" DAYS LEFT"))))) | Vs Settings!B1 |
| L | Status: =IF(A2="","",IF(OR(B2="",C2="",E2="",F2="",G2="",H2="",I2="",AND(C2="Fixed",D2=""),AND(G2="5g",J2="")),"MISSING DATA: FILL B, C, E TO I (D IF FIXED, J IF TYPE 5g)",IF(E2="N","OUTSIDE ART 13: NOT A DATA ACCESS, USE, LIABILITY OR REMEDY TERM (ART 13(1))",IF(I2="Y","OUTSIDE ART 13: MAIN SUBJECT MATTER OR ADEQUACY OF PRICE (ART 13(8))",IF(H2="Y","NOT UNFAIR: REFLECTS MANDATORY OR DEFAULT UNION LAW (ART 13(2))",IF(AND(B2<=DATE(2025,9,12),C2="Fixed",D2<DATE(2034,1,11)),"OUTSIDE CHAPTER IV: OLDER CONTRACT ENDING BEFORE 11 JAN 2034 (ART 50)",IF(F2="N","NOT UNILATERALLY IMPOSED: NEGOTIATED OR INFLUENCED, NO UNFAIRNESS TEST (ART 13(6))",IF(F2="Unsure","CHECK BY HAND: WAS IT IMPOSED? KEEP PROOF OF YOUR ATTEMPT TO NEGOTIATE (ART 13(6))",IF(OR(G2="4a",G2="4b",G2="4c"),IF(B2>DATE(2025,9,12),"","FROM 12 SEP 2027: ")&"UNFAIR, NOT BINDING ON YOU (BLACKLIST ART 13(4)("&RIGHT(G2,1)&"))",IF(AND(G2="5g",J2="Y"),"NOT PRESUMED UNFAIR: ART 13(5) SECOND SUBPARAGRAPH CARVE-OUT; GENERAL TEST ONLY",IF(OR(G2="5a",G2="5b",G2="5c",G2="5d",G2="5e",G2="5f",G2="5g"),IF(B2>DATE(2025,9,12),"","FROM 12 SEP 2027: ")&"PRESUMED UNFAIR (ART 13(5)("&RIGHT(G2,1)&")): SUPPLIER MUST REBUT","CHECK BY HAND: GENERAL TEST, GROSS DEVIATION FROM GOOD COMMERCIAL PRACTICE (ART 13(3))"))))))))))) | UNFAIR / PRESUMED UNFAIR / CHECK BY HAND / NOT IMPOSED / NOT UNFAIR / OUTSIDE / MISSING DATA |
| M | To-do list: =IF(A2="","",TEXTJOIN("; ",TRUE,IF(LEFT(L2,7)="MISSING","fill the missing inputs first",""),IF(ISNUMBER(SEARCH("NOT BINDING",L2)),"write to the supplier that the term is not binding on you under Data Act Art 13 and ask for a corrected clause; the rest of the contract stays binding if the term is severable (Art 13(7))",""),IF(ISNUMBER(SEARCH("PRESUMED UNFAIR (",L2)),"ask the supplier to justify the term or replace it; the presumption stands unless they show it is not unfair in this case",""),IF(LEFT(L2,14)="CHECK BY HAND:",IF(F2="Unsure","find the emails or redlines showing you asked to change the term (the supplier must prove it was not imposed, Art 13(6))","compare the term with Art 13(4) and (5) as a yardstick and record why it does or does not grossly deviate from good commercial practice"),""),IF(AND(LEFT(L2,7)<>"MISSING",B2<=DATE(2025,9,12),C2="Indefinite"),"diary 12 Sep 2027: Chapter IV starts for this older open-ended contract",""),IF(AND(LEFT(L2,7)<>"MISSING",B2<=DATE(2025,9,12),C2="Fixed",D2>=DATE(2034,1,11)),"diary 12 Sep 2027: Chapter IV starts for this older long contract",""),IF(LEFT(L2,11)="OUTSIDE CHA","no Data Act unfairness test; national contract law still applies",""),IF(OR(LEFT(L2,7)="MISSING",LEFT(L2,7)="OUTSIDE"),"","the parties cannot contract out of Art 13 (Art 13(9))"),IF(LEFT(L2,7)="MISSING","","record who checked and the date"))) | Cites each article |
Term-type key for column G
| Code | The term's object or effect is to | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 4a | Excludes or limits the supplier's liability for intentional acts or gross negligence | Always unfair, Art 13(4)(a) |
| 4b | Excludes your remedies for non-performance, or the supplier's liability for breach | Always unfair, Art 13(4)(b) |
| 4c | Gives the supplier the exclusive right to decide whether the data conform to the contract, or to interpret any term | Always unfair, Art 13(4)(c) |
| 5a | Inappropriately limits remedies or liability, or extends your liability | Presumed unfair, Art 13(5)(a) |
| 5b | Lets the supplier access and use your data in a way significantly detrimental to your legitimate interests, especially commercially sensitive data, trade secrets or IP | Presumed unfair, Art 13(5)(b) |
| 5c | Stops you using the data you provided or generated during the contract, or limits that use so you cannot use, capture, access or control it adequately | Presumed unfair, Art 13(5)(c) |
| 5d | Stops you terminating within a reasonable period | Presumed unfair, Art 13(5)(d) |
| 5e | Stops you getting a copy of the data you provided or generated, during the contract or within a reasonable period after it ends | Presumed unfair, Art 13(5)(e) |
| 5f | Lets the supplier terminate at unreasonably short notice, given your chance to switch and the financial detriment, except on serious grounds | Presumed unfair, Art 13(5)(f) |
| 5g | Lets the supplier substantially change the price or the nature, format, quality or quantity of the data with no valid reason and no right for you to terminate | Presumed unfair, Art 13(5)(g), with a carve-out |
| Other | Any other one-sided data term | General test, Art 13(3) |
The 5g carve-out (Article 13(5), second subparagraph): in an open-ended contract the supplier may reserve the right to change terms if the contract states a valid reason, the supplier must give reasonable notice and you can terminate at no cost.
Step 2: what the test rows returned
Tested in LibreOffice Calc on 9 Nov 2026 with Settings!B1 fixed at 9 Nov 2026, on fifteen made-up rows (no real supplier or business) plus an empty row. All fifteen gave the intended timing and status; the empty row stayed blank; no formula errors. A contract concluded on exactly 12 September 2025 and ending in 2030 (example 12) came out as not covered, because Article 50 says "on or before".
| Example | Chapter IV timing | Status |
|---|---|---|
| 1: AI tool SaaS, no liability even for gross negligence | APPLIES NOW: CONCLUDED AFTER 12 SEP 2025 | UNFAIR, NOT BINDING ON YOU (BLACKLIST ART 13(4)(a)) |
| 2: cloud contract, no exit for 5 years | APPLIES FROM 12 SEP 2027: 307 DAYS LEFT | FROM 12 SEP 2027: PRESUMED UNFAIR (ART 13(5)(d)): SUPPLIER MUST REBUT |
| 3: old CRM contract ending Feb 2027 | NOT COVERED: CONCLUDED BY 12 SEP 2025 AND ENDS BEFORE 11 JAN 2034 | OUTSIDE CHAPTER IV: OLDER CONTRACT ENDING BEFORE 11 JAN 2034 (ART 50) |
| 4: machine data, you may not use your own data | APPLIES FROM 12 SEP 2027: 307 DAYS LEFT | FROM 12 SEP 2027: PRESUMED UNFAIR (ART 13(5)(c)): SUPPLIER MUST REBUT |
| 5: liability cap we negotiated down | APPLIES NOW: CONCLUDED AFTER 12 SEP 2025 | NOT UNILATERALLY IMPOSED: NEGOTIATED OR INFLUENCED, NO UNFAIRNESS TEST (ART 13(6)) |
| 6: click-through terms, no record of asking | APPLIES NOW: CONCLUDED AFTER 12 SEP 2025 | CHECK BY HAND: WAS IT IMPOSED? KEEP PROOF OF YOUR ATTEMPT TO NEGOTIATE (ART 13(6)) |
| 7: GDPR processor clause copied from Art 28 | APPLIES NOW: CONCLUDED AFTER 12 SEP 2025 | NOT UNFAIR: REFLECTS MANDATORY OR DEFAULT UNION LAW (ART 13(2)) |
| 8: price per API call | APPLIES NOW: CONCLUDED AFTER 12 SEP 2025 | OUTSIDE ART 13: MAIN SUBJECT MATTER OR ADEQUACY OF PRICE (ART 13(8)) |
| 9: office lease clause | APPLIES NOW: CONCLUDED AFTER 12 SEP 2025 | OUTSIDE ART 13: NOT A DATA ACCESS, USE, LIABILITY OR REMEDY TERM (ART 13(1)) |
| 10: price change with notice and free exit | APPLIES NOW: CONCLUDED AFTER 12 SEP 2025 | NOT PRESUMED UNFAIR: ART 13(5) SECOND SUBPARAGRAPH CARVE-OUT; GENERAL TEST ONLY |
| 11: price change, no reason, no exit | APPLIES NOW: CONCLUDED AFTER 12 SEP 2025 | PRESUMED UNFAIR (ART 13(5)(g)): SUPPLIER MUST REBUT |
| 12: supplier decides if data conform | NOT COVERED: CONCLUDED BY 12 SEP 2025 AND ENDS BEFORE 11 JAN 2034 | OUTSIDE CHAPTER IV: OLDER CONTRACT ENDING BEFORE 11 JAN 2034 (ART 50) |
| 13: supplier reuses your data to train its AI | APPLIES NOW: CONCLUDED AFTER 12 SEP 2025 | PRESUMED UNFAIR (ART 13(5)(b)): SUPPLIER MUST REBUT |
| 14: other one-sided data term | APPLIES NOW: CONCLUDED AFTER 12 SEP 2025 | CHECK BY HAND: GENERAL TEST, GROSS DEVIATION FROM GOOD COMMERCIAL PRACTICE (ART 13(3)) |
| 15: half filled | MISSING DATES | MISSING DATA: FILL B, C, E TO I (D IF FIXED, J IF TYPE 5g) |
Step 3: checklist
- List every contract under which a supplier holds, processes or provides data for the business: cloud storage, accounting and payroll software, AI tools, CRM, connected devices, data feeds.
- Note the date each contract was concluded and whether it is open-ended or has a fixed end date.
- Pull out only the data terms: who may access and use the data, exports and copies, termination, liability and remedies.
- For each, record whether you tried to change it. If you never asked, Article 13 may not apply; ask now in writing for terms you can still renegotiate.
- Code each term with the key above and read the status.
- For UNFAIR and PRESUMED UNFAIR terms, write to the supplier (template below).
- Check the data processing agreement and sub-processor terms separately under GDPR (Article 28 DPA sheet).
- If you plan to leave a cloud or SaaS supplier, use the switching rules too (Data Act switching sheet).
- Diary 12 September 2027 for older open-ended or long contracts.
Step 4: letter to the supplier (template)
Subject: Clause [number] of our [service] contract and Article 13 of the EU Data Act. We are reviewing the data terms of our contract dated [date]. We asked to change clause [number] on [date] and were told the terms are standard and cannot be changed. The clause [describe effect, e.g. prevents us from obtaining a copy of the data we provided after termination]. In our view this term falls under Article 13(5)(e) of Regulation (EU) 2023/2854 and is presumed unfair, so it would not be binding on us; the rest of the contract would continue. Please confirm by [date] that you will replace it with a term that [gives us a copy of our data within a reasonable period after termination]. This letter is not a notice of termination.
Sources read
Read on 9 Nov 2026. Regulation (EU) 2023/2854 (Data Act), OJ L 22.12.2023, CELEX 32023R2854: recitals 58 to 62; Article 2, point (1) (definition of data); Article 13(1) to (9); Article 41; Article 50. EUR-Lex refused our automated fetch again today (HTTP 202 with an empty body), so we used our saved copy of the official EUR-Lex text of the Regulation and re-read the quoted wording against it on 9 Nov 2026. Not read for this guide: the Commission's recommended non-binding model contractual terms under Article 41; the Digital Omnibus proposal COM(2025) 837 and the texts negotiated on it, which could amend the Data Act (check before relying on this page); national contract law; case law; Article 3 and Chapter II design and access obligations for connected products. Our reading, flagged: "at least 10 years from 11 January 2024" read as an end date on or after 11 January 2034; checking the timing rule before the imposed test; treating terms you never tried to negotiate as outside the test; "national contract law still applies" to terms outside Chapter IV; and the column grades.
Frequently asked questions
Does the Data Act protect a small firm against one-sided cloud or AI tool terms?
Yes, for data terms. Article 13(1) of Regulation (EU) 2023/2854 says a contractual term concerning access to and use of data, or liability and remedies for the breach or termination of data related obligations, that one enterprise has unilaterally imposed on another is not binding on the latter if it is unfair. It protects any enterprise on the receiving end, not only SMEs, and the parties cannot exclude it or vary its effects (Article 13(9)).
When is a term unilaterally imposed?
Article 13(6): when one party supplied it and the other could not influence its content despite an attempt to negotiate it. The party that supplied the term must prove it was not imposed, and it cannot itself argue that its own term is unfair. Recital 59 adds that a term simply provided and accepted, or negotiated and agreed in amended form, is not unilaterally imposed. So keep the emails or redlines that show you asked.
What is the difference between the two lists?
Terms in Article 13(4) are always unfair, for example excluding liability for intentional acts or gross negligence. Terms in Article 13(5) are presumed unfair, for example stopping you getting a copy of your data or from terminating within a reasonable period; recital 62 says the supplier can rebut the presumption by showing the term is not unfair in the specific case. Anything else is tested under the general rule in Article 13(3): a gross deviation from good commercial practice in data access and use, contrary to good faith and fair dealing.
Does it apply to contracts we signed before September 2025?
Article 50: Chapter IV applies to contracts concluded after 12 September 2025. For contracts concluded on or before 12 September 2025 it applies from 12 September 2027, but only if they are of indefinite duration or due to expire at least 10 years from 11 January 2024 (that is, on or after 11 January 2034, our reading of the date). Shorter older contracts are not covered.
Can we challenge the price this way?
No. Article 13(8) excludes terms defining the main subject matter of the contract and the adequacy of the price, as against the data supplied in exchange. A price-change clause can still fall under Article 13(5)(g) if there is no valid reason and no right to terminate.
What happens to the rest of the contract?
Article 13(7): where the unfair term can be severed, the remaining terms stay binding. The sheet's to-do column reminds you to ask for a corrected clause rather than to walk away.
Related: AI supplier contract clauses · sub-processor change sheet · AI model supplier evidence sheet · Product Liability Directive software sheet · late payment claim sheet.
Keep each client's AI tools and their suppliers in one register: the EURO AI Register has a free edition.
Unadhi Guides are free, independent explainers. We correct errors as soon as we find them: write to mininglife7@gmail.com.