Electronic signature check sheet for accountants, tax advisers and small businesses under eIDAS: simple, advanced or qualified signature, company seals, legal effect, what your e-sign tool really gives and when a document still needs paper, under Regulation (EU) No 910/2014 as amended by Regulation (EU) 2024/1183
What you get: a finished, tested electronic signature check sheet for accountants, bookkeepers, tax advisers and the small businesses they advise. One row per document you or a client sign electronically: engagement letters, tax return authorisations, board minutes, contracts, invoices. You answer eight Y/N questions about the e-sign tool. Formulas tell you which level the signature really reaches (simple, advanced or qualified, or the same for a company seal), what legal effect it has under eIDAS, a to-do list with article numbers, and a result: FIX INPUT, CHECK THE FORM RULE, SIGN ON PAPER, A PERSON MUST SIGN, UPGRADE TO QUALIFIED, UPGRADE TO ADVANCED, CHECK THE PROVIDER'S CLAIM, KEEP THE EVIDENCE or OK. Also included: questions to send your e-sign provider, a one-minute client explanation and a checklist.
Partner programme opening soon: join the free waitlist. Planned terms are 50% of each referred sale (75% once you have 5+ paying customers), single level, paid through Gumroad only from revenue received.
Short answer: eIDAS knows three levels. Any electronic signature (a typed name, a scanned image, a click) cannot be refused as evidence only because it is electronic (Article 25(1)), but national law decides its weight (recital 49). An advanced signature must meet the four tests of Article 26. Only a qualified signature, an advanced signature made with a qualified signature creation device and based on a qualified certificate (Article 3(12)), has the same legal effect as a handwritten signature (Article 25(2)) and is recognised in every Member State (Article 24a(1)). Which level a document needs is a question of national law or the contract, not of eIDAS (Article 2(3)).
What to tell a client in one minute
"Most e-sign tools give you a simple electronic signature. That is fine for many everyday documents, and a court cannot throw it out just because it is electronic. But where the law or the other side asks for a handwritten signature, only a qualified electronic signature counts the same, and that needs a qualified certificate from a provider on an official EU trusted list. Some documents must still be signed on paper under national law. So before we sign electronically, we check what this document needs and what the tool really gives."
Why AI matters here
E-sign tools now add AI features: contract summaries, clause suggestions, automatic field filling and AI-assisted identity checks. None of these changes the signature level. The level depends only on the four tests in Article 26 and, for qualified, on the certificate and the device (Article 3(12)). Our reading: if an AI assistant or a colleague can apply your signature from a shared account, the "sole control" test in Article 26(c) is hard to meet, so answer column G with N. Recitals 51 and 52 accept signing devices held or managed by a third party (remote signing) only with mechanisms that keep the signatory in sole control.
The finished sheet
Create a sheet with two tabs. Codes (optional): the codes below with their sources. Signatures: row 1 headings, one document per row from row 2. Enter codes exactly as shown.
| Col | Input | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| A | Document (engagement letter, tax authorisation, board minute, invoice) | |
| B | PERSON (a natural person signs) or COMPANY (a legal person seals) | Art 3(9), (24) |
| C | Form needed by national law or the contract: NONE, ADVANCED, HANDWRITTEN, PAPER ONLY or NOT CHECKED | Art 2(3), 25 |
| D | What your e-sign provider says it gives: SIMPLE, ADVANCED or QUALIFIED | Art 3(10) to (12), (25) to (27) |
| E to H | Uniquely linked to the signer; identifies the signer; signer has sole control of the signing data; later changes detectable (Y/N) | Art 26(a) to (d), 36(a) to (d) |
| I | Qualified certificate from a qualified trust service provider on an EU trusted list? Y/N | Art 3(12), (15), 22 |
| J | Qualified signature or seal creation device, local or remote? Y/N | Art 3(23), (32), Annex II |
| K | Validation report or audit trail saved with the signed file? Y/N | our suggestion |
| L to P | Check, Level your answers support, Legal effect, To-do, Result | formulas below |
Paste these into row 2 and fill down (Google Sheets, Excel 2019 or later, LibreOffice):
L2: =IF(A2="","",IF(NOT(OR(B2="PERSON",B2="COMPANY")),"FIX: B MUST BE PERSON OR COMPANY",IF(NOT(OR(C2="NONE",C2="ADVANCED",C2="HANDWRITTEN",C2="PAPER ONLY",C2="NOT CHECKED")),"FIX: C MUST BE NONE, ADVANCED, HANDWRITTEN, PAPER ONLY OR NOT CHECKED",IF(NOT(OR(D2="SIMPLE",D2="ADVANCED",D2="QUALIFIED")),"FIX: D MUST BE SIMPLE, ADVANCED OR QUALIFIED",IF(NOT(AND(OR(E2="Y",E2="N"),OR(F2="Y",F2="N"),OR(G2="Y",G2="N"),OR(H2="Y",H2="N"),OR(I2="Y",I2="N"),OR(J2="Y",J2="N"),OR(K2="Y",K2="N"))),"FIX: E TO K MUST BE Y OR N","OK")))))
M2: =IF(OR(A2="",L2<>"OK"),"",CHOOSE(IF(AND(E2="Y",F2="Y",G2="Y",H2="Y"),IF(AND(I2="Y",J2="Y"),3,2),1),"SIMPLE","ADVANCED","QUALIFIED")&IF(B2="COMPANY"," SEAL"," SIGNATURE"))
N2: =IF(OR(A2="",L2<>"OK"),"",IF(IF(AND(E2="Y",F2="Y",G2="Y",H2="Y"),IF(AND(I2="Y",J2="Y"),3,2),1)=3,IF(B2="COMPANY","PRESUMED INTEGRITY AND CORRECT ORIGIN; RECOGNISED IN ALL MEMBER STATES (ART 35(2), ART 24A(1))","SAME LEGAL EFFECT AS A HANDWRITTEN SIGNATURE; RECOGNISED IN ALL MEMBER STATES (ART 25(2), ART 24A(1))"),IF(B2="COMPANY","CANNOT BE REFUSED AS EVIDENCE ONLY FOR BEING ELECTRONIC OR NOT QUALIFIED (ART 35(1)); NO PRESUMPTION","CANNOT BE REFUSED AS EVIDENCE ONLY FOR BEING ELECTRONIC OR NOT QUALIFIED (ART 25(1)); NATIONAL LAW DECIDES ITS WEIGHT (RECITAL 49)")))
O2: =IF(OR(A2="",L2<>"OK"),"",TEXTJOIN("; ",TRUE,IF(C2="NOT CHECKED","Check national law and the contract for the form this document needs; eIDAS does not change form rules (Art 2(3))",""),IF(C2="PAPER ONLY","National law requires paper for this document: sign by hand (Art 2(3))",""),IF(AND(B2="COMPANY",C2="HANDWRITTEN"),"A seal proves a company document's origin and integrity, not a person's signature (Art 3(25), recital 59): have an authorised person sign with a qualified signature (our reading)",""),IF(AND(AND(AND(C2<>"NOT CHECKED",C2<>"PAPER ONLY",NOT(AND(B2="COMPANY",C2="HANDWRITTEN"))),OR(C2="ADVANCED",C2="HANDWRITTEN",D2<>"SIMPLE")),E2="N"),"Not uniquely linked to the signer (Art 26(a) / 36(a))",""),IF(AND(AND(AND(C2<>"NOT CHECKED",C2<>"PAPER ONLY",NOT(AND(B2="COMPANY",C2="HANDWRITTEN"))),OR(C2="ADVANCED",C2="HANDWRITTEN",D2<>"SIMPLE")),F2="N"),"Does not identify the signer (Art 26(b) / 36(b))",""),IF(AND(AND(AND(C2<>"NOT CHECKED",C2<>"PAPER ONLY",NOT(AND(B2="COMPANY",C2="HANDWRITTEN"))),OR(C2="ADVANCED",C2="HANDWRITTEN",D2<>"SIMPLE")),G2="N"),"Signer has no sole control of the signing data (Art 26(c) / 36(c))",""),IF(AND(AND(AND(C2<>"NOT CHECKED",C2<>"PAPER ONLY",NOT(AND(B2="COMPANY",C2="HANDWRITTEN"))),OR(C2="ADVANCED",C2="HANDWRITTEN",D2<>"SIMPLE")),H2="N"),"Later changes to the document are not detectable (Art 26(d) / 36(d))",""),IF(AND(AND(AND(C2<>"NOT CHECKED",C2<>"PAPER ONLY",NOT(AND(B2="COMPANY",C2="HANDWRITTEN"))),OR(C2="HANDWRITTEN",D2="QUALIFIED")),I2="N"),"Use a qualified certificate from a qualified trust service provider on an EU trusted list (Art 3(12), 3(15), Art 22)",""),IF(AND(AND(AND(C2<>"NOT CHECKED",C2<>"PAPER ONLY",NOT(AND(B2="COMPANY",C2="HANDWRITTEN"))),OR(C2="HANDWRITTEN",D2="QUALIFIED")),J2="N"),"Sign on a qualified signature (or seal) creation device, local or remote (Art 3(23) / 3(32), Annex II)",""),IF(AND(AND(C2<>"NOT CHECKED",C2<>"PAPER ONLY",NOT(AND(B2="COMPANY",C2="HANDWRITTEN"))),IF(D2="SIMPLE",1,IF(D2="ADVANCED",2,3))>IF(AND(E2="Y",F2="Y",G2="Y",H2="Y"),IF(AND(I2="Y",J2="Y"),3,2),1)),"Your provider calls this "&D2&" but your answers support only "&CHOOSE(IF(AND(E2="Y",F2="Y",G2="Y",H2="Y"),IF(AND(I2="Y",J2="Y"),3,2),1),"SIMPLE","ADVANCED","QUALIFIED")&": ask for written proof",""),IF(K2="N","Save the signed file with its validation report or audit trail (our suggestion)","")))
P2: =IF(A2="","",IF(L2<>"OK","FIX INPUT",IF(C2="NOT CHECKED","CHECK THE FORM RULE",IF(C2="PAPER ONLY","SIGN ON PAPER",IF(AND(B2="COMPANY",C2="HANDWRITTEN"),"A PERSON MUST SIGN",IF(IF(AND(E2="Y",F2="Y",G2="Y",H2="Y"),IF(AND(I2="Y",J2="Y"),3,2),1)<IF(C2="NONE",1,IF(C2="ADVANCED",2,3)),IF(IF(C2="NONE",1,IF(C2="ADVANCED",2,3))=3,"UPGRADE TO QUALIFIED","UPGRADE TO ADVANCED"),IF(IF(D2="SIMPLE",1,IF(D2="ADVANCED",2,3))>IF(AND(E2="Y",F2="Y",G2="Y",H2="Y"),IF(AND(I2="Y",J2="Y"),3,2),1),"CHECK THE PROVIDER'S CLAIM",IF(K2="N","KEEP THE EVIDENCE","OK"))))))))
The rules the sheet uses
- Electronic signature (Article 3(10)): data in electronic form attached to or logically associated with other data and used by the signatory to sign. The signatory is a natural person (Article 3(9)).
- Legal effect (Article 25): an electronic signature shall not be denied legal effect and admissibility as evidence solely because it is electronic or not qualified (25(1)); a qualified electronic signature has the equivalent legal effect of a handwritten signature (25(2)). Recital 49: otherwise it is for national law to define the legal effect.
- Advanced (Article 26(1)): uniquely linked to the signatory; capable of identifying the signatory; created using signature creation data the signatory can, with a high level of confidence, use under their sole control; linked to the signed data so any later change is detectable.
- Qualified (Article 3(12)): an advanced signature created by a qualified signature creation device (Annex II) and based on a qualified certificate (Article 3(15), Annex I) issued by a qualified trust service provider. Member States publish trusted lists of these providers (Article 22).
- Cross-border: qualified signatures and seals based on a qualified certificate issued in one Member State are recognised as qualified in all others (Article 24a(1), inserted by Regulation (EU) 2024/1183, which deleted Article 25(3) and Article 35(3)).
- Seals (Articles 3(25), 35, 36): a company's electronic seal ensures origin and integrity; the same four tests apply (Article 36); a qualified seal enjoys a presumption of integrity and correct origin (Article 35(2)). Recital 58: where a qualified seal is required, a qualified signature of the company's authorised representative should be equally acceptable.
- Form rules stay national (Article 2(3) as amended): eIDAS does not affect Union or national law on the conclusion and validity of contracts, other form rules or sector-specific form requirements.
- Electronic documents (Article 46): an electronic document shall not be denied legal effect and admissibility as evidence solely because it is electronic.
- Coming: European Digital Identity Wallets must let all natural persons sign with qualified electronic signatures by default and free of charge (Article 5a(5)(g), inserted by Regulation (EU) 2024/1183); Member States may limit the free use to non-professional purposes (recital 20). Wallets are due within 24 months of the implementing acts (Article 5a(1)); we did not check those dates.
Questions to send your e-sign provider (copy and fill)
Subject: Which signature level do we get? Dear [provider], We use [product / plan] to sign [document types]. Please confirm in writing: 1. Which level of electronic signature under Regulation (EU) No 910/2014 our plan gives: simple, advanced (Article 26) or qualified (Article 3(12)). 2. For advanced: how the signature is uniquely linked to and identifies the signer, how the signer keeps sole control of the signing data, and how later changes are detected. 3. For qualified: the name of the qualified trust service provider that issues the certificate, the national trusted list it appears on, and the qualified signature creation device used (local or remote). 4. Whether any AI feature in the product can place a signature or fill a signature field without the signer's own action. 5. What validation report or audit trail we receive with each signed document, and in which format. Kind regards, [name, firm]
What we tested
The formulas were built into a workbook and recalculated in LibreOffice with 20 test rows covering every result (qualified with and without certificate or device, advanced with and without each test, simple signatures with and without an audit trail, a provider claiming more than the answers support, unchecked and paper-only form rules, company seals for documents that need a handwritten signature, an advanced requirement and no requirement, and five kinds of bad input). We ran it twice, in two different row orders. 20 of 20 results matched both times, an empty row stayed blank and no cell returned an error.
Checklist before the next engagement letter round
- For each document type you sign: form rule found in national law or the contract (column C), not guessed.
- Documents that national law keeps on paper listed.
- Written answer from each e-sign provider on the level it gives (template above).
- For qualified: provider found on the national trusted list.
- Shared signing accounts and AI auto-sign features switched off for anything that must be advanced or qualified.
- Company seals used only where a seal is enough; a person signs where a signature is required.
- Signed file saved together with its validation report or audit trail.
Keep the AI tools in a register
An e-sign tool with AI features is one of the AI tools a firm should list. Add it to the EURO AI Register free edition: it runs in your browser with no account and no upload and covers your first 10 AI systems, with purpose, data and owner. Attach this sheet as the evidence record for how the firm signs. Neither the sheet nor the register is legal advice or proof of compliance.
Related free sheets: ViDA e-invoicing readiness sheet · Article 28 processor agreement check · AI supplier contract clauses · client AI inventory for accountants.
Limits and our reading
- Read: the provisions listed at the top, in the 2014 Official Journal text and in the 2024 amending Regulation. Not read: a consolidated text, Annexes I and II in detail, the full amended Article 32 and new Article 32a on validation, implementing acts on standards for advanced signatures (Article 26(2), new), trusted lists themselves, corrigenda, and national laws on form and on the evidential weight of signatures.
- Our reading: the sheet treats "HANDWRITTEN" as met only by a qualified signature (Article 25(2)); it treats a company seal as not enough where a person's handwritten signature is required, based on Article 3(25) and recital 59; it treats a shared or AI-operated signing account as failing sole control. Columns B to K are your answers, not checked. The level shown is what your answers support, not a certification.
Questions
Is a typed name or a clicked 'I agree' a valid electronic signature in the EU?
It is an electronic signature (Article 3(10) of Regulation (EU) No 910/2014). It cannot be refused as evidence only because it is electronic or not qualified (Article 25(1)), but national law decides how much weight it carries (recital 49). Only a qualified electronic signature has the same legal effect as a handwritten signature (Article 25(2)).
What makes an electronic signature 'advanced'?
Article 26: it is uniquely linked to the signatory, capable of identifying the signatory, created using signature creation data the signatory can, with a high level of confidence, use under their sole control, and linked to the signed data so that any later change is detectable.
What makes it 'qualified'?
An advanced electronic signature created by a qualified electronic signature creation device and based on a qualified certificate for electronic signatures (Article 3(12)). Qualified certificates are issued by qualified trust service providers, which appear on national trusted lists (Article 22).
Is a qualified signature from another Member State accepted?
Yes. Qualified electronic signatures based on a qualified certificate issued in one Member State are recognised as qualified in all other Member States (Article 24a(1), inserted by Regulation (EU) 2024/1183, which deleted the old Article 25(3)).
Does eIDAS decide which documents may be signed electronically?
No. The Regulation does not affect Union or national law on the conclusion and validity of contracts, other legal or procedural form rules, or sector-specific form requirements (Article 2(3) as amended by Regulation (EU) 2024/1183). Check national law for each document type.
What is an electronic seal and when does a company use one?
An electronic seal is data attached to other data to ensure its origin and integrity, created by a legal person (Article 3(24), (25)). Recital 59 says seals serve as evidence that a document was issued by a legal person. A qualified seal enjoys a presumption of integrity and correct origin (Article 35(2)).
Unadhi Guides are free, independent explainers. We correct errors as soon as we find them: write to mininglife7@gmail.com.