Toy warnings check sheet for EU web shops before the Christmas sales: age limits and Annex V warnings visible before an online purchase (Article 11(2), Toy Safety Directive 2009/48/EC), exact wording, no warning that conflicts with a baby toy, and what Regulation (EU) 2025/2509 changes from 1 August 2030, for accountants, bookkeepers and web agencies
What you get: a finished toy warnings check sheet for EU web shops, one row per toy listing (one row per warning if a toy needs more than one). You fill short Y/N answers from the product page and the box, and the formulas return a scope check (toy for children under 14, Article 2 exclusions), an age warning check, a category warning check with the exact Annex V wording to paste, a conflicting warning check (a baby toy marked “not suitable for children under 36 months”), a language check, a to-do list with the Article behind each line and a result (OK, ADD AGE, ADD WARNING, FIX WORDING, REMOVE WARNING, TRANSLATE, NOT IN SCOPE or FIX INPUT). Also included: a manufacturer request and a client email. We tested the formulas in LibreOffice on twenty made-up listings, before and after fixes, before publishing.
Short answer: under Article 11(2) of Directive 2009/48/EC, warnings that decide the purchase, such as the minimum or maximum user age and the other Annex V warnings, must be clearly visible to the consumer before the purchase, including when the purchase is made online. A photo of the box is easy to miss; put the words on the page. The warnings in Annex V Part B points 2 to 10 (for example “Only for domestic use” or “Protective equipment should be worn. Not to be used in traffic”) must be used as worded (Article 11(1)), and a toy must not carry a warning that conflicts with its intended use. The new Regulation (EU) 2025/2509 keeps the online rule (Article 6(3)) and applies from 1 August 2030 (Article 59).
Partner programme opening soon: join the free waitlist. Planned terms are 50% of each referred sale (75% once you have 5+ paying customers), single level, paid through Gumroad only from revenue received.
Why accountants, bookkeepers and web agencies should look at this now
- Christmas is the toy season. Shops add gift ranges in November, often by bulk import from a supplier feed. The feed carries the title, price and photos; the warning text is easy to lose.
- Distributors must check before selling. Before making a toy available, a distributor must verify the conformity marking and that the toy comes with instructions and safety information in a language consumers in that country easily understand (Article 7(2)).
- Importers count as the manufacturer's stand-in. A client who buys toys from outside the EU and puts them on the EU market is an importer (Article 3(5)), with its own duties (Article 6). The purchase files a bookkeeper keeps show who imported the stock.
- It pairs with our product safety page sheet (GPSR Article 19), which covers the manufacturer name, address and product identifier on the page.
Step 1: list the toys (scraper, free during launch)
- Run the Shopify & WooCommerce Product + Price Tracker on each client shop. It returns products, prices, stock, variants, SKU/GTIN, images and descriptions from independent Shopify, WooCommerce and schema.org shops, and skips shops whose robots.txt or terms forbid scraping. The Actor has no Actor fee (checked on the public Apify API, 17 Nov 2026); you pay only your own Apify usage.
- Filter for toy words (toy, Spielzeug, jouet, giocattolo, juguete, speelgoed, zabawka) and search the descriptions for
36 months,3 years,0-3,Warning,Achtung,AttentionandAvvertenza. That fills column G and gives a first answer for column I. - The scraper does not decide the facts. Take the age limit and the warnings from the box or the manufacturer, and check by eye that the words are on the page before the buy button.
- Need the manufacturers' or importers' contacts to send the request below? The Website Contact Scraper returns emails (MX-checked), phones and social profiles from their websites, one de-duplicated row per site.
The Annex V warnings (Directive 2009/48/EC)
| Code (column H) | Toys | Warning | Point |
|---|---|---|---|
| UNDER 36 MONTHS | Toys that might be dangerous for children under 36 months | A warning such as “Not suitable for children under 36 months” or “Not suitable for children under three years” (or the graphic), with a brief note of the hazard, which may be in the instructions | 1 |
| ACTIVITY | Activity toys (swings, slides, climbing frames) | “Only for domestic use” | 2 |
| FUNCTIONAL | Functional toys (scale models of real appliances) | “To be used under the direct supervision of an adult” | 3 |
| CHEMICAL | Chemistry sets and similar | “Not suitable for children under (age) years. For use under adult supervision” | 4 |
| SKATES OR SCOOTER | Skates, roller skates, inline skates, skateboards, scooters and toy bicycles sold as toys | “Protective equipment should be worn. Not to be used in traffic” | 5 |
| AQUATIC | Aquatic toys | “Only to be used in water in which the child is within its depth and under adult supervision” | 6 |
| TOY IN FOOD | Toys in or mixed with food | “Toy inside. Adult supervision recommended” | 7 |
| MASK OR HELMET | Imitation protective masks and helmets | “This toy does not provide protection” | 8 |
| COT STRING | Toys strung across a cradle, cot or pram | “To prevent possible injury by entanglement, remove this toy when the child starts trying to get up on its hands and knees in a crawling position” | 9 |
| FRAGRANCE GAME | Olfactory board games, cosmetic kits and gustative games with listed fragrances | “Contains fragrances that may cause allergies” | 10 |
Part A adds that the user limits include at least the minimum or maximum user age and, where appropriate, the user's abilities, weight limits and the need for adult supervision. Point 1 does not apply to toys that are manifestly unsuitable for children under 36 months.
Step 2: the sheet, one row per listing (columns A to T)
Create a tab called Toys. Row 1 holds the headers below; paste the formulas into N2 to T2 and fill down. Type the answers exactly as shown. The formulas use IF, AND, OR, LEFT, MID, MATCH, ISNA, CHOOSE and TEXTJOIN (Excel 2019 or later, Microsoft 365, Google Sheets, LibreOffice). The binary .xlsx is kept in our working copy only (we publish text files); rebuild it from the formulas below.
| Col | What goes in it | Based on |
|---|---|---|
| A–C | Shop, product page URL, product title | Product scraper |
| D | Designed or intended for play by children under 14? Y/N | Art 2(1) |
| E | Excluded by Article 2(2) or listed in Annex I? Y/N | Art 2(1), 2(2), Annex I |
| F | Client's role: MANUFACTURER, IMPORTER or DISTRIBUTOR | Art 3(3), 3(5), 3(6) |
| G | Minimum or maximum user age shown on the page before purchase? Y/N | Art 11(2), Annex V Part A |
| H | Warning category: NONE or one of the ten codes in the table above | Annex V Part B |
| I | That category warning shown in words on the page? Y/N (leave blank for NONE) | Art 11(2) |
| J | Wording exactly as in Annex V? Y/N (points 2–10) | Art 11(1) |
| K | Toy meant for children under 36 months? Y/N | Art 11(1), Annex V point 1 |
| L | Warnings in a language buyers in the target country easily understand? Y/N | Art 4(7), 7(2), 11(3) |
| M | Notes | You |
| N | Scope | Art 2 |
| O | Age warning check | Art 11(2), Annex V Part A |
| P | Category warning check, with the wording to paste | Art 11(1)–(2), Annex V Part B |
| Q | Conflicting warning check | Art 11(1) |
| R | Language check | Art 4(7), 7(2), 11(3) |
| S | To-do list with Article cites | As cited |
| T | Result | Summary |
Formulas (row 2; fill down). In Excel files saved by some tools TEXTJOIN shows as _xlfn.TEXTJOIN; that is the same function.
N2: =IF(A2="","",IF(AND(D2<>"Y",D2<>"N"),"FIX: DESIGNED OR INTENDED FOR PLAY BY CHILDREN UNDER 14? Y OR N (D)",IF(D2="N","NOT IN SCOPE: NOT A TOY UNDER ART 2(1)",IF(AND(E2<>"Y",E2<>"N"),"FIX: EXCLUDED BY ART 2(2) OR ANNEX I? Y OR N (E)",IF(E2="Y","NOT IN SCOPE: EXCLUDED BY ART 2(2) OR ANNEX I",IF(ISNA(MATCH(F2,{"MANUFACTURER","IMPORTER","DISTRIBUTOR"},0)),"FIX: ROLE MANUFACTURER, IMPORTER OR DISTRIBUTOR (F)","IN SCOPE: TOY, "&F2))))))
O2: =IF(LEFT(N2,2)<>"IN","",IF(AND(G2<>"Y",G2<>"N"),"FIX: AGE LIMIT SHOWN ON THE PAGE BEFORE PURCHASE? Y OR N (G)",IF(G2="N","ADD THE MINIMUM OR MAXIMUM USER AGE TO THE PRODUCT PAGE, VISIBLE BEFORE PURCHASE (ART 11(2), ANNEX V PART A)","OK")))
P2: =IF(LEFT(N2,2)<>"IN","",IF(ISNA(MATCH(H2,{"NONE","UNDER 36 MONTHS","ACTIVITY","FUNCTIONAL","CHEMICAL","SKATES OR SCOOTER","AQUATIC","TOY IN FOOD","MASK OR HELMET","COT STRING","FRAGRANCE GAME"},0)),"FIX: WARNING CATEGORY MUST BE ONE OF THE 11 CODES (H)",IF(H2="NONE","OK",IF(AND(I2<>"Y",I2<>"N"),"FIX: CATEGORY WARNING SHOWN ON THE PAGE? Y OR N (I)",IF(I2="N","ADD THE WARNING TO THE PAGE BEFORE PURCHASE: '"&CHOOSE(MATCH(H2,{"NONE","UNDER 36 MONTHS","ACTIVITY","FUNCTIONAL","CHEMICAL","SKATES OR SCOOTER","AQUATIC","TOY IN FOOD","MASK OR HELMET","COT STRING","FRAGRANCE GAME"},0),"","Not suitable for children under 36 months (or under three years) plus the hazard","Only for domestic use","To be used under the direct supervision of an adult","Not suitable for children under [age] years. For use under adult supervision","Protective equipment should be worn. Not to be used in traffic","Only to be used in water in which the child is within its depth and under adult supervision","Toy inside. Adult supervision recommended","This toy does not provide protection","To prevent possible injury by entanglement, remove this toy when the child starts trying to get up on its hands and knees in a crawling position","Contains fragrances that may cause allergies")&"' (ART 11(2), ANNEX V PART B POINT "&(MATCH(H2,{"NONE","UNDER 36 MONTHS","ACTIVITY","FUNCTIONAL","CHEMICAL","SKATES OR SCOOTER","AQUATIC","TOY IN FOOD","MASK OR HELMET","COT STRING","FRAGRANCE GAME"},0)-1)&")",IF(H2="UNDER 36 MONTHS","OK",IF(AND(J2<>"Y",J2<>"N"),"FIX: WORDING EXACTLY AS IN ANNEX V? Y OR N (J)",IF(J2="N","USE THE EXACT WORDING: '"&CHOOSE(MATCH(H2,{"NONE","UNDER 36 MONTHS","ACTIVITY","FUNCTIONAL","CHEMICAL","SKATES OR SCOOTER","AQUATIC","TOY IN FOOD","MASK OR HELMET","COT STRING","FRAGRANCE GAME"},0),"","Not suitable for children under 36 months (or under three years) plus the hazard","Only for domestic use","To be used under the direct supervision of an adult","Not suitable for children under [age] years. For use under adult supervision","Protective equipment should be worn. Not to be used in traffic","Only to be used in water in which the child is within its depth and under adult supervision","Toy inside. Adult supervision recommended","This toy does not provide protection","To prevent possible injury by entanglement, remove this toy when the child starts trying to get up on its hands and knees in a crawling position","Contains fragrances that may cause allergies")&"' (ART 11(1), ANNEX V PART B POINT "&(MATCH(H2,{"NONE","UNDER 36 MONTHS","ACTIVITY","FUNCTIONAL","CHEMICAL","SKATES OR SCOOTER","AQUATIC","TOY IN FOOD","MASK OR HELMET","COT STRING","FRAGRANCE GAME"},0)-1)&")","OK"))))))))
Q2: =IF(LEFT(N2,2)<>"IN","",IF(AND(K2<>"Y",K2<>"N"),"FIX: TOY MEANT FOR CHILDREN UNDER 36 MONTHS? Y OR N (K)",IF(AND(K2="Y",H2="UNDER 36 MONTHS"),"REMOVE THE UNDER-36-MONTHS WARNING: IT CONFLICTS WITH THE INTENDED USE; ASK THE MANUFACTURER (ART 11(1))","OK")))
R2: =IF(LEFT(N2,2)<>"IN","",IF(AND(L2<>"Y",L2<>"N"),"FIX: WARNINGS IN A LANGUAGE BUYERS IN THE TARGET COUNTRY EASILY UNDERSTAND? Y OR N (L)",IF(L2="N","TRANSLATE THE WARNINGS AND CHECK THE NATIONAL LANGUAGE RULE (ART 4(7), 7(2), 11(3))","OK")))
S2: =IF(A2="","",TEXTJOIN("; ",TRUE,IF(LEFT(N2,4)="FIX:","Fix input: "&MID(N2,6,200),""),IF(LEFT(N2,3)="NOT","No toy warning duty: "&MID(N2,15,200),""),IF(OR(O2="",O2="OK"),"",IF(LEFT(O2,4)="FIX:","Fix input: "&MID(O2,6,200),O2)),IF(OR(P2="",P2="OK"),"",IF(LEFT(P2,4)="FIX:","Fix input: "&MID(P2,6,200),P2)),IF(OR(Q2="",Q2="OK"),"",IF(LEFT(Q2,4)="FIX:","Fix input: "&MID(Q2,6,200),Q2)),IF(OR(R2="",R2="OK"),"",IF(LEFT(R2,4)="FIX:","Fix input: "&MID(R2,6,200),R2))))
T2: =IF(A2="","",IF(OR(LEFT(N2,4)="FIX:",LEFT(O2,4)="FIX:",LEFT(P2,4)="FIX:",LEFT(Q2,4)="FIX:",LEFT(R2,4)="FIX:"),"FIX INPUT",IF(LEFT(N2,3)="NOT","NOT IN SCOPE",IF(LEFT(Q2,6)="REMOVE","REMOVE WARNING",IF(O2<>"OK","ADD AGE",IF(LEFT(P2,3)="ADD","ADD WARNING",IF(LEFT(P2,3)="USE","FIX WORDING",IF(R2<>"OK","TRANSLATE","OK"))))))))
What we tested
Twenty made-up listings in LibreOffice (xlsx → ods → csv). Run 1 (as found): a puzzle with the age on the page (OK); wooden blocks with no age (ADD AGE); a marble run whose small-parts warning is only on a box photo (ADD WARNING); a doll with the warning in the description (OK); a baby rattle marked “not for under 3” (REMOVE WARNING); a swing set with “Only for domestic use” (OK) and a climbing frame that says “home use” (FIX WORDING); a toy kitchen, a kick scooter and a knight helmet with no warning (ADD WARNING, each with the exact wording); a chemistry set, a surprise egg and a pram chain with correct warnings (OK); an arm ring with loose wording (FIX WORDING); a perfume kit and a board game shown only in English to German buyers (TRANSLATE); a Christmas bauble and a coin-operated mall ride (NOT IN SCOPE); and a category typo and a blank answer (FIX INPUT). Run 2 repeated the rows after the fixes a shop would make. 20/20 gave the intended result in both runs, the empty row stayed blank, and no cell showed an error.
Manufacturer or importer request (template)
Subject: Toy warnings for our web shop pages Hello, Under Article 11(2) of the Toy Safety Directive 2009/48/EC, warnings that decide the purchase, such as the age limits and the Annex V warnings, must be clearly visible before purchase, including online. For each toy please send: 1. The minimum or maximum user age. 2. Every warning printed on the toy, label or packaging, word for word, in [languages]. 3. For toys marked "not suitable for children under 36 months": the hazard behind the warning (for example small parts). 4. Who placed the toy on the EU market (manufacturer or importer name and address). Items: [list with EAN or model number] Thank you, [Name], [Shop]
Client email
Subject: Your toy pages: warnings before the Christmas sales Hello, We checked [number] toy listings in your shop against the online warning rule of the Toy Safety Directive (Article 11(2)): - [number] pages show no age limit before purchase - [number] pages miss a warning required by Annex V, or show it only in a photo of the box - [number] warnings are not worded as Annex V requires - [number] pages need the warnings in the language of the country you sell to The attached sheet lists each listing and the fix, with the exact wording to paste. We prepared a request you can send to your suppliers for any missing warnings. Best regards, [Name]
What changes in 2030
- Regulation (EU) 2025/2509 repeals the Directive with effect from 1 August 2030 (Article 56) and applies from that date (Article 59); Articles 28 to 44 and 49 to 55 already apply from 1 January 2026.
- The online rule stays: warnings on user limits and the Annex III category warnings must be clearly visible to the consumer before purchase, including in distance sales (Article 6(3)).
- New: each toy needs a digital product passport (Article 19(1)); its data carrier must be clearly visible before any purchase, including in distance sales (Article 19(7)).
- Toys placed on the market in conformity with the Directive before 1 August 2030 can still be sold after that date (Article 57(1)).
Limits and our reading
- National law decides language rules and penalties. A Member State may set the language of warnings and safety instructions (Articles 4(7), 11(3)); we did not read national rules or penalties.
- Our reading, flagged: a warning that appears only inside a photo of the box is ADD WARNING, because it is easy to miss and not text a buyer can read on every screen; every toy row asks for an age limit, because Annex V Part A says the user limits include at least the minimum or maximum age; the Directive puts the marking duty on the manufacturer (Article 11(2)) and the check duty on the distributor (Article 7(2)), and we treat the web shop that shows the page as the one who must make the words visible online; for point 1 the sheet accepts any equivalent wording, as the text says “such as”. Whether a toy is “manifestly unsuitable” for under-3s is your call (Annex V point 1).
- Not covered: the safety requirements (Article 10, Annex II), chemicals limits, CE marking and conformity assessment, the GPSR online duties for web shops and marketplaces (see our GPSR sheet), and the Annex I list in detail.
- The scraper gives dated product data only. It does not decide whether a page complies.
FAQ
Must a web shop show toy warnings online?
Yes. Warnings which determine the decision to purchase the toy, such as the minimum and maximum ages for users and the other applicable Annex V warnings, must appear on the consumer packaging or be otherwise clearly visible to the consumer before the purchase, including where the purchase is made online (Article 11(2) of Directive 2009/48/EC).
Can we change the wording of a warning?
Not for Annex V Part B points 2 to 10: those warnings must be used as worded (Article 11(1)). For point 1 the text gives examples such as 'Not suitable for children under 36 months' or 'Not suitable for children under three years', or the graphic.
Can a baby toy say 'Not suitable for children under 36 months'?
No. A toy must not bear an Annex V Part B warning that conflicts with its intended use, as determined by its function, dimensions and characteristics (Article 11(1)).
What does a reseller have to check?
Before making a toy available, a distributor must verify that it bears the required conformity marking and comes with the required documents and with instructions and safety information in a language consumers in that Member State easily understand, and that the manufacturer and importer details and identification are there (Article 7(2)).
When does the new Toy Safety Regulation apply?
Regulation (EU) 2025/2509 applies from 1 August 2030, with Articles 28 to 44 and 49 to 55 applying from 1 January 2026 (Article 59). It keeps the rule that warnings must be visible before purchase in distance sales (Article 6(3)) and adds a digital product passport (Article 19). Toys placed on the market under the Directive before 1 August 2030 may still be sold (Article 57(1)).
Sources (read 17 Nov 2026)
- Directive 2009/48/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 18 June 2009 on the safety of toys (CELEX 32009L0048), EUR-Lex HTML of the Official Journal text: Articles 2, 3, 4, 6, 7, 11 and Annex V.
- Regulation (EU) 2025/2509 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 November 2025 on the safety of toys and repealing Directive 2009/48/EC (CELEX 32025R2509), EUR-Lex HTML: recitals 6, 12 and 34, Articles 6, 19, 56, 57 and 59.
- Product and contact scraper features and fees: Apify Store pages and the public Apify API, read 17 Nov 2026.
Related
- Product safety product-page check sheet (GPSR Article 19)
- Batteries check sheet for web shops
- Black Friday real discount check sheet (30-day lowest price)
- Gift guide product shortlist sheet
- Textile fibre composition check sheet
Unadhi Guides are free, independent explainers. We correct errors as soon as we find them: write to mininglife7@gmail.com.