Whistleblowing channel check sheet for accountants: 50-worker rule, 7-day acknowledgement, 3-month feedback and AI tools in the channel (Directive (EU) 2019/1937, AI Act Article 87) for business clients
What you get: a finished reporting channel check sheet for accountants, tax advisers and bookkeepers to use with business clients. One row per client: enter the headcount and eleven short answers, and the sheet says whether the EU Whistleblower Directive requires an internal reporting channel (REQUIRED, CHECK or NOT REQUIRED BY ART 8(3)), gives a result (OK, FIX, SET UP CHANNEL, CHECK BY HAND) and a to-do list with the Article behind each item. Also included: a report log that works out the 7-day acknowledgement and 3-month feedback deadlines, a procedure checklist, a list of forbidden retaliation for managers, and a client email. Made-up example rows show how it fills in.
Short answer: Directive (EU) 2019/1937 requires private-sector legal entities with 50 or more workers to set up internal reporting channels and follow-up procedures (Article 8(1) and (3)). The 50-worker threshold does not apply to entities within the scope of the Union acts in Parts I.B and II of its Annex, which include financial services and anti-money-laundering rules (Article 8(4)). The channel must protect the reporter's identity, acknowledge a report within seven days and give feedback within three months (Article 9(1)). Reports may be made in writing or orally, or both (Article 9(2)). Under the EU AI Act, the same Directive applies to reports of infringements of the AI Act (Regulation (EU) 2024/1689, Article 87), so AI tools used in a channel need the same care as the rest of it.
Why clients ask their accountant this question
- Headcount crosses 50. You see the payroll first. The obligation for entities with 50 to 249 workers had to be in national law by 17 December 2023 (Article 26(2)); for others the transposition date was 17 December 2021 (Article 26(1)).
- Bank, insurer or investor questionnaires ask whether the company has a whistleblowing channel.
- Clients want an AI tool to do it: a chatbot for intake, automatic call transcripts, or a general AI assistant to summarise reports. The Directive's confidentiality and record-keeping rules (Articles 16 to 18) still apply.
- Some small firms are in scope regardless of size because they fall under the financial services or anti-money-laundering acts listed in the Annex (Article 8(4)).
Step 1: tab 1, client list (one row per client)
| Column | What to write | Source |
|---|---|---|
| A | Client name | Your client list |
| B | Number of workers (a number). National law decides how workers are counted; use the client's payroll figure and note the method | Art 8(3) |
| C | Falls within the scope of a Union act in Part I.B or Part II of the Annex (for example financial services, insurance distribution, anti-money-laundering Directive (EU) 2015/849, statutory audit Directive 2006/43/EC, civil aviation or maritime safety, offshore oil and gas)? Y, N or ? | Art 8(4); Annex |
| D | National law requires a channel below 50 workers for this sector? Y, N or ? | Art 8(7) |
| E | Internal reporting channel in place? Y or N | Art 8(1) |
| F | Reports accepted in writing and orally (phone or voice message), with a meeting on request? Y or N | Art 9(2) |
| G | Impartial person or department named to follow up? Y or N | Art 9(1)(c) |
| H | Only authorised staff can see reports and the reporter's identity? Y or N | Arts 9(1)(a), 16(1) |
| I | Clear information on how to report externally to the competent authorities? Y or N | Art 9(1)(g) |
| J | Channel run by: type exactly Internal, Third party or Shared | Art 8(5)-(6) |
| K | AI tool that touches reports: type exactly None, Transcription, Chatbot intake or General AI assistant | Arts 16-18; AI Act Arts 50(1), 87 |
| L | Employment contracts, NDAs or policies that waive or limit the right to report? Y or N | Art 24 |
| M | Required? =IF(A2="","",IF(OR(N(B2)>=50,C2="Y",D2="Y"),"REQUIRED",IF(OR(C2="?",D2="?"),"CHECK","NOT REQUIRED BY ART 8(3)"))) | Formula |
| N | Result: =IF(A2="","",IF(AND(M2="REQUIRED",E2<>"Y"),"SET UP CHANNEL",IF(OR(K2="General AI assistant",M2="CHECK"),"CHECK BY HAND",IF(AND(M2="NOT REQUIRED BY ART 8(3)",E2<>"Y"),"NOT REQUIRED: CHECK NATIONAL LAW",IF(O2="","OK","FIX"))))) | Formula (our working rule) |
| O | To do: =TEXTJOIN("; ",TRUE,IF(AND(M2="REQUIRED",E2<>"Y"),"set up a channel and a follow-up procedure (Arts 8(1), 9(1))",""),IF(AND(E2="Y",F2="N"),"accept reports in writing and orally, and a meeting on request (Art 9(2))",""),IF(AND(E2="Y",G2="N"),"name an impartial person or department to follow up (Art 9(1)(c))",""),IF(AND(E2="Y",H2="N"),"limit access to authorised staff (Arts 9(1)(a), 16(1))",""),IF(AND(E2="Y",I2="N"),"tell people how to report to the authorities (Art 9(1)(g))",""),IF(AND(J2="Shared",N(B2)>249),"sharing is allowed only with 50-249 workers (Art 8(6))",""),IF(J2="Third party","check the provider applies the Art 9(1) safeguards (Art 8(5)) and has a GDPR contract (Art 17)",""),IF(K2="Transcription","record or transcribe calls only with consent; offer the transcript to check, correct and sign (Art 18(2))",""),IF(K2="Chatbot intake","chatbot intake: identity seen only by authorised staff (Art 16(1)); collect nothing clearly irrelevant (Art 17); ask the supplier how people are told it is AI (AI Act Art 50(1))",""),IF(K2="General AI assistant","stop pasting reports into a general AI assistant until checked: identity must stay with authorised staff (Arts 9(1)(a), 16(1))",""),IF(L2="Y","remove clauses that waive or limit reporting rights (Art 24)","")) | Formula |
Copy the formulas into row 2 and fill down. TEXTJOIN works in Excel 2019 or later, Microsoft 365, Google Sheets and LibreOffice. The result in column N is our working rule for sorting a client list quickly, not a legal test. "NOT REQUIRED: CHECK NATIONAL LAW" means Article 8(3) does not require a channel, but a Member State may require one below 50 workers after a risk assessment (Article 8(7)) and may go further than the Directive (Article 25(1)).
Example rows (made up) and what the sheet returns
| Client | Workers | Key answers | Required? | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Example 1: bakery chain | 62 | Channel in place, all Y, internal, no AI | REQUIRED | OK |
| Example 2: logistics firm | 120 | No channel | REQUIRED | SET UP CHANNEL |
| Example 3: web agency | 18 | No channel, no Annex act, no national rule | NOT REQUIRED BY ART 8(3) | NOT REQUIRED: CHECK NATIONAL LAW |
| Example 4: small payment firm | 12 | Annex act = Y; written only; no external info; third party | REQUIRED | FIX (3 items) |
| Example 5: manufacturer | 310 | Shared channel; call transcription; NDA limits reporting | REQUIRED | FIX (3 items) |
| Example 6: hotel group | 85 | Access not limited; reports pasted into a general AI assistant | REQUIRED | CHECK BY HAND |
| Example 7: farm co-op | 40 | National rule = ? | CHECK | CHECK BY HAND |
| Example 8: retailer | 75 | Third-party channel with chatbot intake | REQUIRED | FIX (2 items) |
We tested all formulas in LibreOffice Calc on these rows before publishing.
Step 2: tab 2, report log (deadlines worked out)
Every report must be recorded, in line with the confidentiality rules (Article 18(1)). Keep the log itself where only authorised staff can open it. Do not put the reporter's name in it; use a reference.
| Column | What to write | Source |
|---|---|---|
| A | Reference (R1, R2 ...), no names | Art 16(1) |
| B | Date received | Art 9(1)(b) |
| C | Date acknowledgement sent (blank if not yet) | Art 9(1)(b) |
| D | Acknowledgement due: =IF(B2="","",B2+7) | Art 9(1)(b): within seven days of receipt |
| E | Feedback due: =IF(B2="","",IF(C2<>"",EDATE(C2,3),EDATE(B2+7,3))) | Art 9(1)(f): three months from acknowledgement, or from the end of the seven-day period if none was sent |
| F | Date feedback given | Art 5(13) |
| G | Status: =IF(B2="","",IF(F2<>"","FEEDBACK GIVEN",IF(AND(C2="",TODAY()>D2),"ACK LATE",IF(C2="","ACK DUE",IF(TODAY()>E2,"FEEDBACK LATE",IF(TODAY()>E2-14,"FEEDBACK DUE SOON","OPEN")))))) | Formula (14-day warning is our choice) |
Format D and E as dates. Tested with a fixed date of 29 Oct 2026 in place of TODAY(): received 25 Oct, no acknowledgement → ACK DUE (due 1 Nov 2026, feedback due 1 Feb 2027); received 10 Oct, no acknowledgement → ACK LATE; acknowledged 24 Jul → FEEDBACK LATE (due 24 Oct); acknowledged 1 Aug → FEEDBACK DUE SOON (due 1 Nov); acknowledged 3 Sep → OPEN (due 3 Dec); feedback given → FEEDBACK GIVEN. "Feedback" means telling the reporter what action is planned or taken and why (Article 5(13)); it does not have to be the final outcome.
Checklist: the procedure (Article 9 and Article 18)
- ☐ Channel designed and run securely so the reporter's identity and any third party named stay confidential, with no access for non-authorised staff (Art 9(1)(a)).
- ☐ Acknowledgement of receipt within seven days (Art 9(1)(b)).
- ☐ Impartial person or department named to follow up, keep in touch with the reporter, ask for more information and give feedback (Art 9(1)(c)); it may be the same person who receives reports.
- ☐ Diligent follow-up (Art 9(1)(d)); for anonymous reports, where national law provides for it (Art 9(1)(e), Art 6(2)).
- ☐ Feedback within three months (Art 9(1)(f)).
- ☐ Clear, easily accessible information on reporting externally to the competent authorities (Art 9(1)(g), Art 7(3)).
- ☐ Written and/or oral reporting; oral by phone or voice messaging, and a physical meeting on request within a reasonable time (Art 9(2)).
- ☐ Recorded phone line: recording or a complete and accurate transcript only with the reporter's consent, and the reporter can check, rectify and sign the transcript (Art 18(2)). Unrecorded line: accurate minutes, which the reporter can check, rectify and sign (Art 18(3)). Meetings: records only with consent (Art 18(4)).
- ☐ Reports stored no longer than necessary and proportionate (Art 18(1)); personal data clearly not relevant to a report not collected, or deleted without undue delay (Art 17).
- ☐ Third-party provider running the channel applies the same Article 9(1) safeguards (Art 8(5)).
- ☐ Shared receipt and investigation only for entities with 50 to 249 workers, and each entity still keeps confidentiality, gives feedback and addresses the breach (Art 8(6)).
- ☐ No contract, policy or arbitration clause waives or limits the rights (Art 24).
When AI tools touch the channel
- Call transcription: Article 18(2) allows a recording or a "complete and accurate transcript" prepared by the staff members responsible, and only with consent. If an AI tool drafts the transcript, a responsible staff member should check it, and the reporter must be offered the chance to check, rectify and sign it. See our AI meeting note-taker setup sheet.
- Chatbot intake: the identity must not reach anyone beyond authorised staff (Article 16(1)), and data clearly irrelevant to the report should not be collected (Article 17). The chatbot's provider must design it so people know they are interacting with an AI system unless that is obvious (AI Act Article 50(1)); see our Article 50 chatbot disclosure checklist.
- General AI assistants: pasting a report into a general-purpose AI tool shares its content, and possibly the reporter's identity, with a further service. Check this against Articles 9(1)(a) and 16(1) before anyone does it, and check the supplier contract under the GDPR (Article 17 of the Directive points to Regulation (EU) 2016/679); see our processor agreement check sheet and retention schedule for chat logs and transcripts.
- Reports about AI itself: the Directive applies to reports of infringements of the AI Act (AI Act Article 87), so a worker who reports a suspected AI Act infringement is protected under the same rules, and the client's channel should be ready to receive such reports.
For managers: what counts as retaliation (Article 19)
Retaliation, threats of it and attempts at it are prohibited, including: suspension, dismissal or equivalent; demotion or withheld promotion; transfer of duties, change of location, reduced wages or changed hours; withheld training; negative performance assessment or reference; disciplinary measures or financial penalties; coercion, intimidation, harassment or ostracism; discrimination or unfair treatment; not converting or not renewing a temporary contract, or ending it early; harm to reputation (including on social media) or financial loss; blacklisting; early termination of a contract for goods or services; cancellation of a licence or permit; psychiatric or medical referrals (Article 19(a)-(o)). In court, a detriment after a report is presumed to be retaliation unless the employer proves duly justified grounds (Article 21(5)). Protection extends to facilitators, colleagues and relatives who could suffer retaliation (Article 4(4)).
Email to business clients (template)
Subject: Do you need a whistleblowing channel? 5-minute check
Dear [name],
Under the EU Whistleblower Directive (EU) 2019/1937, as transposed in [country], private companies with 50 or more workers must have an internal reporting channel, and some sectors (for example financial services and anti-money-laundering) must have one whatever their size. Reports must be acknowledged within seven days and answered with feedback within three months.
Your current headcount on our payroll records is [number]. Could you tell us: (1) whether you have a reporting channel and who runs it, (2) whether people can report in writing and by phone, (3) who follows up on reports, and (4) whether any AI tool (call transcription, chatbot, AI assistant) handles reports?
We will send you a one-page to-do list. This is not legal advice; for the national details we suggest a lawyer or the national authority's guidance.
Kind regards, [firm]
Keep the channel's AI tools in a register
List every AI tool that touches the channel (transcription, chatbot, assistant) in the EURO AI Register free edition. It runs in your browser with no account and no upload, covers your first 10 AI systems and 10 evidence records, the screening questions, duties by role with dates, and a printable Article 4 AI-literacy record. Attach this check sheet row as the evidence record.
When a client has more than 10 systems, the EURO AI Register membership starts at $19 a month and adds unlimited systems, rule updates and email help. Neither tool is legal advice or proof of compliance.
Partner programme opening soon
Partner programme opening soon: join the free waitlist. Planned terms are 50% of each referred sale (75% once you have 5+ paying customers), single level, paid through Gumroad only from revenue received.
Limits and open points
This is a Directive: companies follow their national transposing law, which can be stricter (Article 25(1)), can require channels below 50 workers (Article 8(7)), decides whether anonymous reports must be accepted (Article 6(2)), and sets penalties for hindering reports, retaliation and breaches of confidentiality (Article 23). The Directive covers breaches of the Union law areas in Article 2 and its Annex; Member States may extend protection to other areas (Article 2(2)). Where sector acts in Part II of the Annex have their own reporting rules, those apply first (Article 3(1)). The Annex is a dynamic list, so check the current consolidated version on EUR-Lex. We read the Directive as published in OJ L 305 of 26.11.2019. For the national rules, get advice and check the national authority's guidance.
Frequently asked questions
Which companies must have a whistleblowing channel?
Private-sector legal entities with 50 or more workers (Article 8(3)), and, regardless of size, entities within the scope of the Union acts in Parts I.B and II of the Annex, such as financial services and anti-money-laundering rules (Article 8(4)). Member States may require it for smaller entities after a risk assessment (Article 8(7)).
What are the deadlines for handling a report?
Acknowledge receipt within seven days and give feedback within a reasonable timeframe of no more than three months from the acknowledgement, or from the end of the seven-day period if no acknowledgement was sent (Article 9(1)(b) and (f)).
Can a small company use an outside provider or share a channel?
Yes. A third party may operate the channel if it applies the Article 9(1) safeguards (Article 8(5)). Entities with 50 to 249 workers may share resources for receiving and investigating reports, but each keeps its duties of confidentiality, feedback and addressing the breach (Article 8(6)).
Can we use AI to transcribe whistleblower calls?
Article 18(2) allows a recording or a complete and accurate transcript only with the reporter's consent, prepared by the staff members responsible, and the reporter must be able to check, rectify and sign it. Treat an AI transcript as a draft that a responsible staff member checks.
Not legal advice. The sheet helps sort a client list; it does not decide whether a company complies. Spotted an error? Write to mininglife7@gmail.com and we correct it.
Sources
- Directive (EU) 2019/1937 of 23 October 2019 on the protection of persons who report breaches of Union law, OJ L 305, 26.11.2019, p. 17: Articles 2, 3(1), 4, 5(13), 6(2), 7(3), 8, 9, 16, 17, 18, 19, 21(5), 23, 24, 25(1), 26 and the Annex (Parts I.B and II) — eur-lex.europa.eu, CELEX 32019L1937 (read 29 Oct 2026)
- Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (AI Act): Article 50(1), Article 87 and recital 172 — eur-lex.europa.eu, CELEX 32024R1689 (read 29 Oct 2026)
Unadhi Guides are free, independent explainers. We correct errors as soon as we find them: write to mininglife7@gmail.com.