"Is it an AI system?" check sheet for accountants: sort a small business client's software list under Article 3(1) of the EU AI Act and the Commission guidelines C(2025) 5053
What you get: a finished "Is it an AI system?" check sheet for accountants, tax advisers and bookkeepers to run over a small business client's software list. One row per tool or feature; you answer six short questions and the sheet gives a result (AI SYSTEM: ADD TO REGISTER, LIKELY NOT AN AI SYSTEM, ASK VENDOR or CHECK BY HAND) plus the reason with the paragraph of the Commission's guidelines behind it. A tab of questions to send software vendors, a "what follows" checklist and a client email follow. Made-up example rows show how it fills in.
Short answer: the EU AI Act only applies to software that meets the definition of an "AI system" in Article 3(1) of Regulation (EU) 2024/1689. The key test is whether the system infers how to generate outputs (predictions, content, recommendations or decisions), using machine learning or logic- and knowledge-based techniques (Recital 12). Software that only follows rules written by people, basic data processing such as standard spreadsheets and sorting or filtering, descriptive statistics and charts, classical heuristics, and simple prediction such as "next month = the average" is outside the definition according to the Commission's guidelines (C(2025) 5053, paragraphs 40 to 51). The guidelines are not binding, give no automatic list and say each system must be assessed on its own features (paragraphs 6, 7 and 62).
Why clients ask their accountant this question
- Everything is sold as "AI" now. Clients see the label on their ledger app, scanner, CRM and email tool and ask whether the AI Act now applies to them. The label is not the test; the way the feature works is.
- The answer decides the rest of the AI Act. Prohibited practices (Article 5), high-risk rules (Article 6) and transparency duties (Article 50) only apply to AI systems. Even then, the Commission notes that the vast majority of AI systems will not be subject to any regulatory requirements under the AI Act (guidelines paragraph 63).
- AI literacy applies to every AI system in use. Providers and deployers must take measures to support the development of AI literacy of staff who operate or use AI systems on their behalf (Article 4 as replaced by Regulation (EU) 2026/1744, which also says no specific level has to be guaranteed for any individual). A business can only do that if it knows which tools are AI systems.
- Using a tool at work makes the business a "deployer". Article 3(4): any person using an AI system under its authority, except in a personal non-professional activity.
The seven parts of the definition (Article 3(1))
"'AI system' means a machine-based system that is designed to operate with varying levels of autonomy and that may exhibit adaptiveness after deployment, and that, for explicit or implicit objectives, infers, from the input it receives, how to generate outputs such as predictions, content, recommendations, or decisions that can influence physical or virtual environments." The guidelines split this into seven elements (paragraph 9). For a client software list, three do the work:
| Element | What it means in practice | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Infers how to generate outputs | Built with machine learning (supervised, unsupervised, self-supervised, reinforcement, deep learning; language models are given as an example) or logic- and knowledge-based approaches that reason from encoded knowledge (expert systems, inference engines). This is the "key, indispensable condition". | Recital 12; guidelines paras 26, 30-39 |
| Some autonomy | The system produces an output without a person manually specifying it. A system that needs manual inputs but then produces the output itself still counts. Only systems with full manual human involvement are excluded. | Recital 12; paras 17-20 |
| Outputs | Predictions, content, recommendations or decisions. A recommendation applied automatically becomes a decision. | paras 52-58 |
| Adaptiveness | Self-learning after deployment is not required ("may"). A tool that never changes can still be an AI system. | paras 22-23 |
Step 1: tab 1, software list (one row per tool or feature)
| Column | What to write | Source |
|---|---|---|
| A | Tool or feature (list AI features of a bigger product separately) | Client's software list |
| B | Vendor or product | Invoice or app store |
| C | What it does, in one line | Vendor documentation |
| D | Built with machine learning, including a language model or other trained model? Y, N or ? | Recital 12; paras 32-38 |
| E | Reasons from encoded expert knowledge (expert system, inference engine), beyond fixed if-then steps? Y, N or ? | para 39 |
| F | Only rules, formulas, filters or macros written by people? Y or N | Recital 12; para 46 |
| G | Only basic statistics: totals, averages, charts, a "mean" baseline forecast, or long-established optimisation such as linear or logistic regression? Y or N | paras 42, 47, 49-51 |
| H | Output: type exactly Prediction, Content, Recommendation, Decision or None | paras 52-58 |
| I | Produces its output without a person specifying it each time? Y or N | paras 17-18 |
| J | Result: =IF(A2="","",IF(OR(D2="?",E2="?"),"ASK VENDOR",IF(OR(D2="Y",E2="Y"),IF(OR(G2="Y",H2="None",I2="N"),"CHECK BY HAND","AI SYSTEM: ADD TO REGISTER"),IF(OR(F2="Y",G2="Y"),"LIKELY NOT AN AI SYSTEM","CHECK BY HAND")))) | Formula (our working rule) |
| K | Reason: =TEXTJOIN("; ",TRUE,IF(D2="Y","learns from data (paras 32-38)",""),IF(E2="Y","infers from encoded knowledge (para 39)",""),IF(OR(D2="?",E2="?"),"technique unknown: send the vendor questions",""),IF(F2="Y","only rules written by people (Recital 12, para 46)",""),IF(G2="Y","only basic statistics or simple prediction (paras 42, 47, 49-51)",""),IF(H2="None","no prediction, content, recommendation or decision (paras 52-58)",""),IF(I2="N","every output set by a person (paras 17-18)","")) | Formula |
| L | Evidence (link to vendor page or reply) and date checked | Your file |
The result in column J is our working rule for sorting a list quickly, not a legal test. "CHECK BY HAND" means the answers point both ways (for example, a trained model whose vendor says it is plain linear regression); read guidelines paragraphs 40 to 51 for that row and write down your reasoning in column L.
Example data (made up, to show how the sheet fills in; no real products):
| A | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Example 1: fee spreadsheet | SUMIF and lookup formulas, no AI features switched on | N | N | Y | N | None | N | LIKELY NOT AN AI SYSTEM | only rules written by people (Recital 12, para 46); no prediction, content, recommendation or decision (paras 52-58); every output set by a person (paras 17-18) |
| Example 2: bank feed auto-categorisation | Suggests an account code per bank line, learns from corrections | Y | N | N | N | Recommendation | Y | AI SYSTEM: ADD TO REGISTER | learns from data (paras 32-38) |
| Example 3: invoice data capture | Reads supplier invoices into the ledger; vendor page only says "smart" | ? | ? | Content | Y | ASK VENDOR | technique unknown: send the vendor questions | ||
| Example 4: website FAQ chatbot | Answers visitor questions in its own words | Y | N | N | N | Content | Y | AI SYSTEM: ADD TO REGISTER | learns from data (paras 32-38) |
| Example 5: sales report | Totals, averages and trend charts | N | N | N | Y | None | N | LIKELY NOT AN AI SYSTEM | only basic statistics or simple prediction (paras 42, 47, 49-51); no prediction, content, recommendation or decision (paras 52-58); every output set by a person (paras 17-18) |
| Example 6: cash-flow forecast | Next month = average of the last 12 months | N | N | Y | Y | Prediction | Y | LIKELY NOT AN AI SYSTEM | only rules written by people (Recital 12, para 46); only basic statistics or simple prediction (paras 42, 47, 49-51) |
| Example 7: stock reorder tool | Vendor says: linear regression on past sales, unchanged for years | Y | N | N | Y | Recommendation | Y | CHECK BY HAND | learns from data (paras 32-38); only basic statistics or simple prediction (paras 42, 47, 49-51) |
| Example 8: email rule | Moves mail with "invoice" in the subject to a folder | N | N | Y | N | None | Y | LIKELY NOT AN AI SYSTEM | only rules written by people (Recital 12, para 46); no prediction, content, recommendation or decision (paras 52-58) |
We tested both formulas in LibreOffice Calc on these rows on 29 Oct 2026. In older Excel without TEXTJOIN, use the column J result alone.
Step 2: tab 2, questions for the software vendor (for every "ASK VENDOR" row)
- Does this feature use a machine learning model, including a large language model, trained on data? If so, whose model is it?
- If it is rule-based: were all the rules written by people, or does the system derive rules or conclusions itself from a knowledge base?
- What does it produce: predictions, generated text or images, recommendations, or decisions?
- Is any output applied automatically, without a person reviewing it?
- Does it change its behaviour while in use, for example by learning from our corrections?
- Do you see yourselves as the provider of an AI system under Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 for this feature? Where is that documented?
Paste the reply or link into column L and change D and E from ? to Y or N.
Checklist: what follows for each "AI SYSTEM" row
- ☐ List it in the AI inventory with the business's role (usually deployer, Article 3(4)).
- ☐ AI literacy: record the measures taken for the staff who use it (Article 4, as replaced by Regulation (EU) 2026/1744).
- ☐ Check it is not used for a prohibited practice (Article 5: applies since 2 February 2025; two points added by Regulation (EU) 2026/1744 apply from 2 December 2026).
- ☐ Check whether the use falls in an Annex III area such as hiring or creditworthiness; high-risk rules for those systems apply from 2 December 2027 (Article 113, third paragraph, point (c), as amended by Regulation (EU) 2026/1744).
- ☐ Chatbots and generated content: check the transparency duties in Article 50 (the Regulation applies generally from 2 August 2026).
- ☐ Re-check the row when the vendor adds a new feature. For "LIKELY NOT" rows, keep the reason in column K as your note of why the tool is outside the AI Act.
Email to small business clients (template)
Subject: Which of your tools count as "AI" under the EU AI Act?
Hello [name],
Many software tools now call themselves "AI". Under the EU AI Act only some of them are "AI systems", and that is the starting point for the AI literacy duty and for any further checks. Please send us by [date] a list of the software and add-ons your business pays for or uses at work (accounting, invoicing, CRM, email, website chat, scanning, scheduling, HR), and tell us which features you actually switched on. We will sort each one into "AI system", "likely not" or "ask the vendor" using the Commission's guidelines, and send you the short list of vendor questions where we cannot tell. This is a working list, not legal advice.
Thank you,
[your name]
Related free sheets: client AI inventory for accountants · provider or deployer role check · Article 4 AI literacy record · Annex III high-risk check · Article 5 prohibited practices list.
Keep the AI rows in a register
Copy every "AI SYSTEM: ADD TO REGISTER" row into the EURO AI Register free edition. It runs in your browser with no account and no upload, covers your first 10 AI systems and 10 evidence records, the screening questions, duties by role with dates, and a printable Article 4 AI-literacy record. Attach this sheet as the evidence record for the "is it AI?" decision.
When a client has more than 10 systems, the EURO AI Register membership starts at $19 a month and adds unlimited systems, rule updates and email help. Neither tool is legal advice or proof of compliance.
Partner programme opening soon
Partner programme opening soon: join the free waitlist. Planned terms are 50% of each referred sale (75% once you have 5+ paying customers), single level, paid through Gumroad only from revenue received.
Limits and open points
The Commission's guidelines are not binding; only the Court of Justice of the European Union can give an authoritative interpretation (paragraph 7), and the Commission says no automatic determination or exhaustive list is possible (paragraph 62). The guidelines do not cover general-purpose AI models (paragraph 64). Article 3(1) itself was not changed by Regulation (EU) 2026/1744, but several other articles were, so read the current text on EUR-Lex. This sheet covers the AI Act only: data protection, consumer and sector rules apply separately. When a row matters, for example hiring or credit decisions, get advice.
Frequently asked questions
Is an Excel spreadsheet an AI system under the AI Act?
A standard spreadsheet without AI-enabled features is given by the Commission as an example of basic data processing outside the definition (guidelines paragraph 46). AI features switched on inside a spreadsheet are a separate row to check.
Does a tool have to keep learning to be an AI system?
No. Article 3(1) says the system "may" exhibit adaptiveness after deployment; the Commission says this is not a decisive condition (paragraphs 22 and 23). The decisive condition is the capability to infer (paragraph 26).
Is a chatbot built on a language model an AI system?
The guidelines give language models that learn to predict the next token as an example of self-supervised machine learning, and content generated with GPT-type models as an AI output (paragraphs 36 and 56). Using one at work normally makes the business a deployer.
Not legal advice. The sheet helps sort a software list; it does not decide whether the AI Act applies to a business. Spotted an error? Write to mininglife7@gmail.com and we correct it.
Sources
- Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (AI Act), OJ L, 12.7.2024: Recitals 12 and 13, Articles 3(1), 3(4), 4, 50, 111, 113 — eur-lex.europa.eu, CELEX 32024R1689, and its document information page listing changes by 32026R1744 (read 29 Oct 2026)
- Regulation (EU) 2026/1744 of 8 July 2026 (Digital Omnibus on AI), OJ L, 24.7.2026: Article 1 points (5), (39) and (40), replacing Article 4 and amending Articles 111 and 113 — eur-lex.europa.eu, CELEX 32026R1744 (read 29 Oct 2026)
- Commission Guidelines on the definition of an artificial intelligence system established by Regulation (EU) 2024/1689, C(2025) 5053 final, 29.7.2025, paragraphs 6-64 — AI Act Service Desk, European Commission (PDF) (read 29 Oct 2026)
Unadhi Guides are free, independent explainers. We correct errors as soon as we find them: write to mininglife7@gmail.com.