EU AI Act Article 5(1)(c) social scoring ban check sheet for accountants, tax advisers, payroll bureaus and SME clients (loyalty, employee, credit, public-authority style)
What you get: a finished Article 5(1)(c) social scoring ban check sheet for accountants, tax advisers, bookkeepers, payroll bureaus and the SME clients they advise. One row per scoring or rating practice (customer loyalty reused for credit or HR, employee score reused outside work, public-authority-style scoring of natural persons, and similar): type in twelve short answers and the sheet returns IN SCOPE OF ART 5(1)(c) BAN, EXCEPTION OR OUT OF SCOPE, CHECK BY HAND or STOP, the status versus today against the 2 February 2025 application date, and a to-do list citing the articles. Rebuild it from the formulas below (LibreOffice-tested). Also included: a short checklist and "what to tell the client" templates. Formulas tested in LibreOffice on twelve made-up rows. The existing prohibited practices list is a plain overview; this sheet is the fillable check for social scoring only. The emotion sheet covers only Article 5(1)(f).
Deliverable: rebuild the Excel/LibreOffice check sheet from the column list and formulas below (LibreOffice-tested on 12 sample rows + empty row). Keep one row per scoring or rating practice.
Short answer: from 2 February 2025 (AI Act Article 113), the Union prohibits placing on the market, putting into service or using AI systems that evaluate or classify natural persons or groups over a certain period of time based on social behaviour or known, inferred or predicted personal or personality characteristics, where the social score leads to detrimental treatment in unrelated social contexts and/or to treatment that is unjustified or disproportionate (Article 5(1)(c); recital 31). Recital 31 also says the ban should not affect lawful evaluation practices carried out for a specific purpose under Union and national law. The Digital Omnibus (Regulation (EU) 2026/1744) added intimate-image and CSAM bans as Article 5(1)(ba)/(bb) from 2 December 2026; it did not amend Article 5(1)(c) (our Omnibus check). Fines for Article 5 breaches sit under Article 99(3): up to EUR 35 000 000 or 7% of worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher (for SMEs, the lower of those two caps — Article 99(6)).
Why this lands on the accountant's, tax adviser's or payroll bureau's desk
- Clients reuse loyalty, HR and credit scores across contexts without noticing. Article 5(1)(c)(i) targets exactly that cross-context detriment.
- Payroll and HR tools often ship "attitude", "reliability" or "engagement" scores that can spill into housing, credit or shift cuts — the (i) and (ii) triggers.
- The ban has already applied since 2 February 2025. Anything still live that fits the test is overdue, not a future deadline.
- Article 5 fines are the top tier (Article 99(3)). Accountants are asked "is our scoring tool illegal?" — one row per practice answers with the article behind it.
Partner programme opening soon
Partner programme opening soon: join the free waitlist. Planned terms are 50% of each referred sale (75% once you have 5+ paying customers), single level, paid through Gumroad only from revenue received.
Step 1: the check sheet
Create a sheet named Practices with headers in row 1 and the first practice in row 2. Create a second sheet named Settings and put =TODAY() in B1 (our test file fixes B1 at 3 Nov 2026). Copy the formulas in M2 to O2 down as far as needed. In Excel 2019 or later, LibreOffice or Google Sheets, TEXTJOIN works as written. The formulas below are the deliverable. Binary workbook kept in the build stage; rebuild from these formulas if you need the file.
| Col | Header / formula | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| A | Scoring / rating practice (loyalty, employee, credit, supplier, public-authority style, other) | One row per practice |
| B | Type (Customer loyalty reused / Employee score / Credit or finance / Supplier or partner / Public-authority style / Other) | Your label |
| C | AI system evaluates or classifies? (Y/N) | Art 3(1) |
| D | Placed, put into service or used in the EU / output used in EU? (Y/N) | Art 2 |
| E | Natural persons or groups of natural persons? (Y/N) | Art 5(1)(c) |
| F | Over a certain period of time (ongoing / multi-context score)? (Y/N/Unsure) | Art 5(1)(c); recital 31 |
| G | Based on social behaviour or known/inferred/predicted personal or personality characteristics? (Y/N/Unsure) | Art 5(1)(c) |
| H | Leads to detrimental treatment in unrelated social contexts? (Y/N/Unsure) | Art 5(1)(c)(i) |
| I | Leads to unjustified or disproportionate treatment? (Y/N/Unsure) | Art 5(1)(c)(ii) |
| J | Claimed as lawful specific-purpose evaluation under Union/national law (recital 31)? (Y/N) | Recital 31 carve-out |
| K | Still in use / still offered today? (Y/N) | Drives STOP vs IN SCOPE |
| L | First used or first offered date (blank if planned only) | Date |
| M | Art 5(1)(c) result: =IF(A2="","",IF(C2<>"Y","EXCEPTION OR OUT OF SCOPE: NOT AN AI SYSTEM ON THESE ANSWERS",IF(D2<>"Y","EXCEPTION OR OUT OF SCOPE: NOT IN EU SCOPE ON THESE ANSWERS (ART 2)",IF(E2<>"Y","EXCEPTION OR OUT OF SCOPE: NOT EVALUATION OR CLASSIFICATION OF NATURAL PERSONS",IF(OR(F2="Unsure",F2=""),"CHECK BY HAND: PERIOD OF TIME UNCLEAR (ART 5(1)(c))",IF(F2<>"Y","EXCEPTION OR OUT OF SCOPE: NOT OVER A PERIOD OF TIME ON THESE ANSWERS",IF(OR(G2="Unsure",G2=""),"CHECK BY HAND: SOCIAL BEHAVIOUR OR PERSONALITY BASIS UNCLEAR (ART 5(1)(c))",IF(G2<>"Y","EXCEPTION OR OUT OF SCOPE: NOT BASED ON SOCIAL BEHAVIOUR OR PERSONALITY CHARACTERISTICS",IF(OR(H2="Y",I2="Y"),IF(J2="Y","CHECK BY HAND: LAWFUL SPECIFIC-PURPOSE CLAIM (RECITAL 31) — KEEP THE LEGAL BASIS",IF(K2="Y","STOP: IN SCOPE OF ART 5(1)(c) BAN — SWITCH OFF (LIVE SINCE 2 FEB 2025)","IN SCOPE OF ART 5(1)(c) BAN")),IF(AND(H2="N",I2="N"),"EXCEPTION OR OUT OF SCOPE: NO DETRIMENTAL TREATMENT OF TYPE (i) OR (ii) ON THESE ANSWERS","CHECK BY HAND: FILL DETRIMENTAL TREATMENT (i) AND (ii)")))))))))) | Ban / out of scope / check / STOP |
| N | Status vs today: =IF(A2="","",IF(LEFT(M2,9)="EXCEPTION","NO ART 5(1)(c) ACTION ON THESE ANSWERS",IF(LEFT(M2,5)="CHECK","CHECK BY HAND",IF(LEFT(M2,4)="STOP",IF(Settings!$B$1<DATE(2025,2,2),"GAP: BAN APPLIES FROM 2 FEB 2025: "&(DATE(2025,2,2)-Settings!$B$1)&" DAYS LEFT",IF(OR(L2="",L2<DATE(2025,2,2)),"OVERDUE: PROHIBITED SINCE 2 FEB 2025 ("&(Settings!$B$1-DATE(2025,2,2))&" DAYS) — STOP USE NOW","OVERDUE: PROHIBITED SINCE FIRST USE AFTER BAN ("&(Settings!$B$1-L2)&" DAYS) — STOP USE NOW")),IF(LEFT(M2,8)="IN SCOPE",IF(Settings!$B$1<DATE(2025,2,2),"DO NOT SWITCH ON: BAN FROM 2 FEB 2025","DO NOT SWITCH ON: BANNED SINCE 2 FEB 2025 (ART 113)"),"CHECK BY HAND"))))) | Vs Settings!B1 and 2 Feb 2025 |
| O | To-do list: =IF(A2="","",TEXTJOIN("; ",TRUE,IF(C2<>"Y","not an AI system on these answers (Art 3(1)): no Art 5(1)(c) ban for this row; keep the note",""),IF(AND(C2="Y",D2<>"Y"),"re-check whether the system is placed, put into service or used in the EU, or its output is used in the EU (Art 2(1))",""),IF(AND(C2="Y",D2="Y",E2<>"Y"),"Art 5(1)(c) covers evaluation or classification of natural persons or groups of persons; keep why this row is outside that",""),IF(AND(C2="Y",D2="Y",E2="Y",OR(F2="Unsure",F2="")),"decide whether the score builds over a certain period of time across contexts (Art 5(1)(c); recital 31)",""),IF(AND(C2="Y",D2="Y",E2="Y",F2="N"),"single-event or one-context rating is outside Art 5(1)(c) on these answers; keep that reason (recital 31)",""),IF(AND(C2="Y",D2="Y",E2="Y",F2="Y",OR(G2="Unsure",G2="")),"decide whether inputs are social behaviour or known, inferred or predicted personal or personality characteristics (Art 5(1)(c))",""),IF(AND(C2="Y",D2="Y",E2="Y",F2="Y",G2="N"),"outside Art 5(1)(c) input test on these answers; keep why",""),IF(AND(C2="Y",D2="Y",E2="Y",F2="Y",G2="Y",H2="Y"),"detrimental treatment in an unrelated social context is the Art 5(1)(c)(i) trigger; stop reuse of the score outside its original context",""),IF(AND(C2="Y",D2="Y",E2="Y",F2="Y",G2="Y",I2="Y"),"unjustified or disproportionate treatment is the Art 5(1)(c)(ii) trigger; stop or redesign the consequence",""),IF(AND(C2="Y",D2="Y",E2="Y",F2="Y",G2="Y",H2="N",I2="N"),"no detrimental treatment of type (i) or (ii) on these answers: keep evidence the score stays in its original, proportionate context (Art 5(1)(c); recital 31)",""),IF(AND(C2="Y",D2="Y",E2="Y",F2="Y",G2="Y",OR(H2="Y",I2="Y"),J2="Y"),"write down the Union or national law and the specific purpose claimed (recital 31); get a written expert view before treating it as out of the ban",""),IF(AND(OR(LEFT(M2,4)="STOP",LEFT(M2,8)="IN SCOPE"),K2="Y"),"switch the practice off now: Art 5 bans have applied since 2 February 2025 (Art 113); non-compliance with Art 5 can attract fines up to EUR 35 000 000 or 7% worldwide turnover (Art 99(3); for SMEs the lower of the two caps, Art 99(6))",""),IF(AND(OR(LEFT(M2,4)="STOP",LEFT(M2,8)="IN SCOPE"),K2<>"Y"),"do not switch this practice on: Art 5(1)(c) has prohibited it since 2 February 2025 (Art 113)",""),IF(OR(LEFT(M2,4)="STOP",LEFT(M2,8)="IN SCOPE"),"Digital Omnibus Reg (EU) 2026/1744 added Art 5(1)(ba)/(bb) intimate-image and CSAM bans from 2 Dec 2026; it did not amend Art 5(1)(c) social scoring (our Omnibus check)",""),"record who decided, why and the date")) | As cited in each item |
Step 2: what the test rows returned
Tested in LibreOffice Calc on 3 Nov 2026 with Settings!B1 fixed at 3 Nov 2026, on twelve made-up rows (no real business) plus an empty row. All twelve gave the intended result on the first run; the empty row stayed blank; no formula errors. Column grades and the recital 31 "CHECK BY HAND" treatment are flagged below as ours.
| Example | Art 5(1)(c) result | Status vs today (excerpt) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 Loyalty reused to refuse credit | STOP: IN SCOPE OF ART 5(1)(c) BAN — SWITCH OFF (LIVE SINCE 2 FEB 2025) | OVERDUE: PROHIBITED SINCE 2 FEB 2025 (639 DAYS) — STOP USE NOW |
| 2 Loyalty only for same-shop discounts | EXCEPTION OR OUT OF SCOPE: NO DETRIMENTAL TREATMENT OF TYPE (i) OR (ii) ON THESE ANSWERS | NO ART 5(1)(c) ACTION ON THESE ANSWERS |
| 3 HR score shared with landlord | STOP: IN SCOPE OF ART 5(1)(c) BAN — SWITCH OFF (LIVE SINCE 2 FEB 2025) | OVERDUE: PROHIBITED SINCE FIRST USE AFTER BAN (612 DAYS) — STOP USE NOW |
| 4 Credit score reused for hiring | STOP: IN SCOPE OF ART 5(1)(c) BAN — SWITCH OFF (LIVE SINCE 2 FEB 2025) | OVERDUE: PROHIBITED SINCE 2 FEB 2025 (639 DAYS) — STOP USE NOW |
| 5 One-off supplier rating | EXCEPTION OR OUT OF SCOPE: NOT OVER A PERIOD OF TIME ON THESE ANSWERS | NO ART 5(1)(c) ACTION ON THESE ANSWERS |
| 6 City score affecting parking permits | STOP: IN SCOPE OF ART 5(1)(c) BAN — SWITCH OFF (LIVE SINCE 2 FEB 2025) | OVERDUE: PROHIBITED SINCE 2 FEB 2025 (639 DAYS) — STOP USE NOW |
| 7 Manual paper checklist (no AI) | EXCEPTION OR OUT OF SCOPE: NOT AN AI SYSTEM ON THESE ANSWERS | NO ART 5(1)(c) ACTION ON THESE ANSWERS |
| 8 US-only employee score | EXCEPTION OR OUT OF SCOPE: NOT IN EU SCOPE ON THESE ANSWERS (ART 2) | NO ART 5(1)(c) ACTION ON THESE ANSWERS |
| 9 Planned loyalty→insurance (not live) | IN SCOPE OF ART 5(1)(c) BAN | DO NOT SWITCH ON: BANNED SINCE 2 FEB 2025 (ART 113) |
| 10 Personality badge, period unsure | CHECK BY HAND: PERIOD OF TIME UNCLEAR (ART 5(1)(c)) | CHECK BY HAND |
| 11 Marketing segment, no detriment | EXCEPTION OR OUT OF SCOPE: NO DETRIMENTAL TREATMENT OF TYPE (i) OR (ii) ON THESE ANSWERS | NO ART 5(1)(c) ACTION ON THESE ANSWERS |
| 12 Score with recital 31 claim + unrelated block | CHECK BY HAND: LAWFUL SPECIFIC-PURPOSE CLAIM (RECITAL 31) — KEEP THE LEGAL BASIS | CHECK BY HAND |
Step 3: checklist
- Is an AI system evaluating or classifying natural persons or groups (Articles 3(1), 5(1)(c))?
- Is it placed, put into service or used in the EU, or is its output used in the EU (Article 2)?
- Does the score build over a certain period of time across contexts (Article 5(1)(c); recital 31)?
- Are the inputs social behaviour or known, inferred or predicted personal or personality characteristics?
- Does the score lead to detrimental treatment in an unrelated social context (Article 5(1)(c)(i))?
- Or to treatment that is unjustified or disproportionate to the behaviour or its gravity (Article 5(1)(c)(ii))?
- If a lawful specific-purpose evaluation is claimed, what Union or national law and purpose (recital 31)? Keep it in writing.
- If the row is STOP or IN SCOPE, has the practice been switched off? The ban has applied since 2 February 2025 (Article 113).
- Have we told the client that Article 5 fines are the top tier (Article 99(3)/(6))?
- Who decided, on what date, and when is the next review?
Step 4: what to tell the client (templates)
Client email — practice looks in scope
Hello [name], from 2 February 2025 the EU AI Act bans AI social scoring that evaluates people over time on behaviour or personality and then treats them unfavourably in an unrelated context, or in a way that is unjustified or disproportionate (Article 5(1)(c)). The attached one-row-per-practice sheet (twelve answers each) returned STOP or IN SCOPE for [practice]. That is not legal advice. Please switch the practice off (or do not switch it on) and review it with a technology lawyer before any reuse of the score outside its original context.
Client email — out of scope on these answers
Hello [name], on the answers you gave, [practice] sits outside Article 5(1)(c) because [reason from the sheet: not AI / not EU / not over time / no detrimental treatment of type (i) or (ii)]. Keep that reason on file. If you later reuse the score for credit, housing, hiring or another unrelated decision, re-run the sheet — that reuse is the classic (i) trigger.
Decision record (one per practice)
Practice: [name]. AI system: [Y/N]. EU scope: [Y/N]. Period of time: [Y/N/Unsure]. Social behaviour / personality inputs: [Y/N/Unsure]. Unrelated-context detriment (i): [Y/N/Unsure]. Unjustified/disproportionate (ii): [Y/N/Unsure]. Recital 31 claim: [Y/N + law/purpose]. Still in use: [Y/N]. Art 5(1)(c) result: [from sheet]. Decided by: [name, role] on [date]. Next review: [date].
Related free guides
- Article 5 prohibited AI practices: plain SME list
- Emotion recognition: Article 5(1)(f) ban and Article 50(3) notice
- GDPR Article 22 automated decision sheet
- Credit score and AI score explanation sheet (SCHUFA / Dun & Bradstreet)
- Staff monitoring and HR AI tool check sheet (Article 88)
- Annex III high-risk check for small businesses
- Article 6(3) not-high-risk exception check sheet
- EURO AI Register free edition
Keep each scoring practice and its evidence in one place
Record each AI system, each scoring practice, the Article 5(1)(c) answer and the evidence (decision record, switch-off date, recital 31 legal basis) in the EURO AI Register free edition. It runs in your browser with no account and no upload, covers your first 10 AI systems and 10 evidence records, the screening questions, duties by role with dates, and a printable Article 4 AI-literacy record.
When a client has more than 10 systems, the EURO AI Register membership starts at $19 a month and adds unlimited systems, rule updates and email help. Neither tool is legal advice or proof of compliance.
Partner programme opening soon
Partner programme opening soon: join the free waitlist. Planned terms are 50% of each referred sale (75% once you have 5+ paying customers), single level, paid through Gumroad only from revenue received.
Limits and open points
Read for this guide (3 Nov 2026, EUR-Lex): AI Act (EU) 2024/1689 Article 2 (scope), Article 3(1) (AI system), Article 3(3)-(4) and (9)-(11) as needed for provider/deployer/placing/putting into service, Article 5(1)(c) and the surrounding Article 5(1) list, Article 99(3) and 99(6) as they touch Article 5, Article 113 (Chapters I and II from 2 February 2025), recital 31 on social scoring; Regulation (EU) 2026/1744 (Digital Omnibus on AI) Article 5 amendment inserting (ba)/(bb) only — we searched the Omnibus text for social scoring / Article 5(1)(c) changes and found none (our check).
Not read for this guide: Commission guidelines on prohibited AI practices, any Commission FAQ on Article 5, national laws that add or interpret scoring bans, national penalty rules under Article 99(1)-(2), and case law on what counts as "unrelated" contexts or "disproportionate" treatment.
Our reading, not the law's words: the column list and grades; treating STOP as "in scope and still live"; treating a recital 31 claim as CHECK BY HAND rather than automatic out-of-scope; same-shop loyalty with no (i)/(ii) detriment as out of scope; the sample client wording; and the note that Omnibus did not move Article 5(1)(c).
Frequently asked questions
What does Article 5(1)(c) of the AI Act ban?
It prohibits placing on the market, putting into service or using AI systems for the evaluation or classification of natural persons or groups of persons over a certain period of time based on their social behaviour or known, inferred or predicted personal or personality characteristics, where the social score leads to detrimental or unfavourable treatment in unrelated social contexts, or to treatment that is unjustified or disproportionate to their social behaviour or its gravity (Regulation (EU) 2024/1689, Article 5(1)(c)).
When did the social scoring ban start to apply?
Chapters I and II of the AI Act, which include Article 5, apply from 2 February 2025 (Article 113). Non-compliance with Article 5 can attract administrative fines of up to EUR 35 000 000 or 7% of worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher; for SMEs the lower of those two caps applies (Article 99(3) and 99(6)).
Does a shop loyalty score always fall under the ban?
No. Recital 31 says the prohibition should not affect lawful evaluation practices carried out for a specific purpose in accordance with Union and national law. A loyalty score used only for the same-shop reward it was collected for, with no unrelated or disproportionate detriment, sits outside Article 5(1)(c) on that reading. Reusing the same score to refuse credit, housing or another unrelated service is the classic (i) trigger.
Did the Digital Omnibus change Article 5(1)(c)?
No. Regulation (EU) 2026/1744 amended Article 5 by inserting points (ba) and (bb) on non-consensual intimate material and child sexual abuse material (from 2 December 2026). We searched the Omnibus text: it does not amend Article 5(1)(c) social scoring.
Is an ordinary credit score for lending banned?
Not automatically. Recital 31 preserves lawful evaluation for a specific purpose under Union and national law. A score used only for the credit decision it was built for may sit outside the ban; reusing it in an unrelated context (for example hiring) or in a disproportionate way is different. The sheet marks a claimed recital 31 carve-out as CHECK BY HAND so you keep the legal basis.
Not legal advice. The sheet helps sort scoring practices one by one; it does not decide legal questions. Spotted an error? Write to mininglife7@gmail.com and we correct it.
Sources
- Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (AI Act): Articles 2, 3(1), 5(1)(c), 99(3), 99(6), 113, recital 31 — eur-lex.europa.eu, CELEX 32024R1689 (read 3 Nov 2026)
- Regulation (EU) 2026/1744 (Digital Omnibus on AI) of 8 July 2026, OJ L 24.7.2026: Article 5 amendment inserting (ba)/(bb); no amendment to Article 5(1)(c) on our search — CELEX 32026R1744 (read 3 Nov 2026)
Unadhi Guides are free, independent explainers. We correct errors as soon as we find them: write to mininglife7@gmail.com.