Fake urgency check sheet for EU web shops: countdown timers, only-X-left and people-viewing claims under UCPD Annex I point 7 before Black Friday, for accountants, bookkeepers and web agencies
Partner programme opening soon: join the free waitlist. Planned terms are 50% of each referred sale (75% once you have 5+ paying customers), single level, paid through Gumroad only from revenue received.
What you get: a finished fake-urgency check sheet for EU web shops (Shopify, WooCommerce and similar). One row per urgency or scarcity claim (“offer ends in 00:14:59”, “only 3 left”, “23 people are viewing this”): the product scraper fills title and stock, you paste the claim and answer six questions, and the formulas return a word-scan hint, a time-limit status (Annex I point 7), a stock-limit status (Annex I point 7; Article 6(1)(b)), a demand-claim status (Article 6(1); Annex I point 18), a proof status (Article 12), a scope note, a to-do list with the Article behind each line and a result (OK, FIX, CHECK BY HAND or OUT OF SCOPE). Also included: a five-minute checklist, safe banner wording and a client email. We tested the formulas in LibreOffice on twelve made-up claims before publishing.
Short answer: a countdown timer or “only X left” message is fine when it is true. UCPD Annex I point 7 bans, in all circumstances, “falsely stating that a product will only be available for a very limited time, or that it will only be available on particular terms for a very limited time, in order to elicit an immediate decision and deprive consumers of sufficient opportunity or time to make an informed choice.” The Commission Guidance says this “includes fake timers and limited stock claims on websites”. False information about availability is also a misleading action under Article 6(1)(b).
Why accountants, bookkeepers and web agencies should look at this before Black Friday
- Black Friday is 27 November 2026. Timers and “last chance” banners go up in the next two weeks. A timer that resets on reload, or a “sale ends Sunday” banner that is still there on Monday, is the classic fake timer.
- No case-by-case test. Annex I practices are unfair “in all circumstances” (Article 5(5)). The authority does not need to prove the effect on consumers for a point 7 breach.
- Proof is on the shop. Under Article 12 an authority or court can ask the trader to prove a factual claim and treat it as inaccurate if the proof is missing. Column L makes sure proof exists.
- It is a quick, billable catalogue check. Run the product scraper, open the sale pages, answer the columns, and the sheet writes the fix list with Article cites. Pair it with our Black Friday real-discount sheet (30-day lowest price): that one checks the “was” price, this one checks the deadline and stock claims.
Step 1: pull title and stock (scraper, free during launch)
- Put the sale product URLs for each client shop into a list and run the E-commerce Product Data Scraper. It prefers Shopify products.json, the WooCommerce Store API, then JSON-LD, and returns title, brand, price, currency, availability, SKU/GTIN, variants and description.
- Copy the title into column D. Where the shop exposes stock quantity, put it in column J (real stock); otherwise ask the client for a back-office stock export for the same day.
- Open each page in a browser, copy the urgency text into column E and take a dated screenshot. Reload the page after a few minutes: if the timer starts again, column H is
Y. - The scraper does not decide whether a claim is false. It gives you the product data; the answers in F–L are your own check.
Need the client contacts to send the results? The Contact Details Scraper pulls emails, phones and social links from the same shop websites.
Step 2: the sheet, one row per claim (columns A to U)
Create a tab called Claims. Row 1 holds the headers below; paste the formulas into N2 to U2 and fill down. Add a Settings tab with Settings!B1 = 2026-11-09 (or =TODAY()). Type dates in column G as real dates. The formulas use only IF, AND, OR, NOT, LEFT, SEARCH, ISNUMBER and TEXTJOIN (Excel 2019 or later, Microsoft 365, Google Sheets, LibreOffice). Binary .xlsx is kept in our stage only (GitHub text push); rebuild from the formulas below.
| Col | What goes in it | Based on |
|---|---|---|
| A | Shop website | You |
| B | Page URL checked | You |
| C | Sells to consumers? Y or N | Art 2(a)/(b), 3(1) |
| D | Title from the ecom scraper | E-commerce Product Data Scraper |
| E | Pasted urgency / scarcity claim text | You (screenshot) |
| F | Claim type: Time limit, Stock limit, Demand, Other or Not sure | Annex I 7; Art 6(1) |
| G | Stated end date of the offer (date, or blank for a running timer) | Annex I 7 |
| H | Same price/terms still offered after the end, or timer resets on reload? Y, N, Not sure or N/A | Annex I 7 |
| I | Stock number shown on the page (number, or blank) | Annex I 7 per Guidance; Art 6(1)(b) |
| J | Real stock on the same day (back office or scraper) | Annex I 7 per Guidance; Art 6(1)(b) |
| K | Demand claim (“people viewing / bought”) backed by real live data? Y, N, Not sure or N/A | Art 6(1); Annex I 18 |
| L | Dated proof kept? Y or N | Art 12 |
| M | Notes | You |
| N | Word-scan hint | Helper, not the law |
| O | Time-limit status | Annex I 7; Art 6(1) |
| P | Stock-limit status | Annex I 7 per Guidance; Art 6(1)(b) |
| Q | Demand-claim status | Art 6(1); Annex I 18 |
| R | Proof status | Art 12 |
| S | Scope note | Art 3(1); Arts 5-7 |
| T | To-do list with Article cites | As cited |
| U | Result: OK / FIX / CHECK BY HAND / OUT OF SCOPE | Summary |
Formulas (row 2; fill down). In Excel files saved by some tools TEXTJOIN shows as _xlfn.TEXTJOIN; that is the same function.
N2: =IF(A2="","",IF(E2="","NO TEXT PASTED",IF(OR(ISNUMBER(SEARCH("only",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("left",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("ends",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("ending",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("hurry",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("limited",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("last chance",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("today",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("tonight",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("countdown",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("viewing",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("in carts",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("nur noch",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("endet",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("plus que",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("dernier",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("derniers",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("ultimi",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("solo ",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("laatste",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("nog maar",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("quedan",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("últim",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("sólo",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("termine",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("viendo",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("people",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("personas",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("bought",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("gekauft",E2)),ISNUMBER(SEARCH("achet",E2))),"URGENCY/SCARCITY WORDS FOUND","NO URGENCY/SCARCITY WORDS FOUND")))
O2: =IF(A2="","",IF(F2<>"Time limit","N/A",IF(H2="Y","FIX: SAME PRICE/TERMS STILL OFFERED AFTER THE STATED END OR TIMER RESETS - FALSE TIME LIMIT (UCPD ANNEX I POINT 7)",IF(AND(ISNUMBER(G2),G2<Settings!$B$1),"FIX: STATED END DATE HAS PASSED BUT THE TIME-LIMIT CLAIM IS STILL SHOWN (ANNEX I POINT 7; ART 6(1))",IF(H2="N","OK: TIME LIMIT IS REAL ON THESE ANSWERS",IF(H2="Not sure","CHECK BY HAND: WILL THE PRICE/TERMS REALLY END? (ANNEX I POINT 7)","CHECK BY HAND: FILL COLUMN H (ANNEX I POINT 7)"))))))
P2: =IF(A2="","",IF(F2<>"Stock limit","N/A",IF(OR(NOT(ISNUMBER(I2)),NOT(ISNUMBER(J2))),"CHECK BY HAND: FILL SHOWN STOCK (I) AND REAL STOCK (J) (ANNEX I POINT 7 PER COMMISSION GUIDANCE; ART 6(1)(b))",IF(I2<J2,"FIX: PAGE SHOWS FEWER LEFT THAN REAL STOCK - FALSE SCARCITY (ANNEX I POINT 7 PER COMMISSION GUIDANCE; ART 6(1)(b) AVAILABILITY)","OK: SHOWN STOCK IS NOT BELOW REAL STOCK"))))
Q2: =IF(A2="","",IF(F2<>"Demand","N/A",IF(K2="N","FIX: DEMAND/ACTIVITY CLAIM NOT BACKED BY REAL DATA (ART 6(1); ANNEX I POINT 18 IF ABOUT MARKET CONDITIONS)",IF(K2="Y","OK: DEMAND CLAIM BACKED BY REAL LIVE DATA","CHECK BY HAND: IS THE DEMAND CLAIM REAL? (ART 6(1))"))))
R2: =IF(A2="","",IF(OR(F2="Time limit",F2="Stock limit",F2="Demand",F2="Other"),IF(L2="Y","OK: PROOF KEPT","KEEP PROOF: DATED SCREENSHOT + PROMO END SETTING OR STOCK EXPORT (ART 12)"),"N/A"))
S2: =IF(A2="","",IF(C2="N","OUT OF SCOPE: B2B ONLY - UCPD COVERS BUSINESS-TO-CONSUMER PRACTICES (ART 3(1))",IF(C2<>"Y","CHECK BY HAND: FILL COLUMN C (SELLS TO CONSUMERS?)",IF(OR(F2="Other",F2="Not sure",F2=""),"CHECK BY HAND: CLASSIFY THE CLAIM AND TEST IT UNDER ARTS 5-7","IN SCOPE: B2C URGENCY/SCARCITY CLAIM"))))
T2: =IF(A2="","",IF(C2="N","",TEXTJOIN("; ",TRUE,IF(LEFT(O2,3)="FIX","Remove the timer/deadline or make it true: end the offer at the stated time, no reset on reload (UCPD Annex I point 7)",""),IF(LEFT(P2,3)="FIX","Show real stock or remove the only-X-left message (Annex I point 7; Art 6(1)(b))",""),IF(LEFT(Q2,3)="FIX","Remove the people-viewing/bought message or feed it real live data (Art 6(1); Annex I point 18)",""),IF(LEFT(R2,4)="KEEP","Keep dated proof for each claim (Art 12)",""),IF(OR(LEFT(O2,5)="CHECK",LEFT(P2,5)="CHECK",LEFT(Q2,5)="CHECK",LEFT(S2,5)="CHECK"),"Answer the CHECK BY HAND columns",""))))
U2: =IF(A2="","",IF(C2="N","OUT OF SCOPE",IF(OR(LEFT(O2,3)="FIX",LEFT(P2,3)="FIX",LEFT(Q2,3)="FIX"),"FIX",IF(OR(LEFT(O2,5)="CHECK",LEFT(P2,5)="CHECK",LEFT(Q2,5)="CHECK",LEFT(S2,5)="CHECK"),"CHECK BY HAND","OK"))))
Five-minute checklist (per sale page)
- Is the shop selling to consumers? B2B-only shops are outside the UCPD (Article 3(1)) — column C.
- Copy every urgency or scarcity line on the page: timers, “ends tonight”, “last chance”, “only X left”, “X people viewing / bought” (E–F).
- Timers and deadlines: will the price or terms really end at the stated time? Reload the page; check again after the end date. If the same deal is still there, or the timer restarts, it is a false time limit (Annex I point 7).
- Stock: compare the number shown with real stock on the same day. Showing fewer than you have is false scarcity (Annex I point 7 per the Guidance; Article 6(1)(b)).
- Demand: is the “people viewing / bought” number taken from real live data? If it is random or fixed, remove it (Article 6(1); Annex I point 18).
- Also check the advertised price is available in reasonable quantities (bait advertising, Annex I point 5) and that the advertised item is not refused or swapped (Annex I point 6).
- Keep a dated screenshot plus the promotion end setting or stock export for every claim (Article 12).
Tested: twelve made-up claims (LibreOffice)
| Row | Claim (made-up shop) | U (result) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | shoe.de — “Black Friday price ends 30 Nov”, really ends | OK |
| 2 | lamp.nl — “Offer ends in 00:14:59”, timer resets on reload | FIX |
| 3 | bag.fr — “ends 5 November” banner still shown on 9 November | FIX |
| 4 | mug.it — “Solo 3 rimasti”, real stock 3 | OK |
| 5 | coat.at — “Nur noch 2 auf Lager”, real stock 140 | FIX |
| 6 | tea.be — “Low stock - hurry”, no numbers yet | CHECK BY HAND |
| 7 | ring.es — “23 personas lo están viendo”, random number | FIX |
| 8 | sofa.ie — “12 people bought this today”, real orders | OK |
| 9 | bolt.pl — B2B-only trade shop | OUT OF SCOPE |
| 10 | cap.fi — “Exclusive drop”, type Other | CHECK BY HAND |
| 11 | toy.se — “Last chance today”, end not sure | CHECK BY HAND |
| 12 | pan.pt — “Only 5 left”, real stock 4 | OK |
All twelve gave the intended result in LibreOffice (xlsx → ods → csv), with 0 errors; an empty row stays blank. Rebuild the workbook from the formulas above.
Safe banner wording
Black Friday price: EUR [price] until [day date, time, time zone]. From [next day] the price returns to EUR [price]. [Only show a count if it comes from live stock:] [n] in stock now.
Remove: timers that restart on reload; “ends today” banners that run for days; fixed or random “only 2 left” or “people viewing” numbers.
Copy-ready client email
Subject: Black Friday timers and "only X left" on [shop] - quick EU check Hello [name], Before Black Friday (27 November) we checked the urgency messages on your sale pages. Under the EU Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, a false "limited time" or limited-stock claim is banned in all circumstances (Annex I point 7). False availability information is a misleading action (Article 6(1)(b)), and an authority can ask you to prove these claims (Article 12). What we found: [paste column T] If you agree, we will fix the banners this week and keep dated screenshots. [Your name]
Know shops or clients who would use this? Partner programme opening soon: join the free waitlist. Planned terms are 50% of each referred sale (75% once you have 5+ paying customers), single level, paid through Gumroad only from revenue received.
Limits and open points
Read for this guide (9 Nov 2026, from saved official EUR-Lex text; live EUR-Lex empty/403 today): consolidated UCPD 02005L0029-20220528 Articles 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 12, 13 and Annex I points 5, 6, 7 and 18; Commission Guidance 2021/C 526/01 section 4.2.7 (data-driven practices and dark patterns) and section 4.3.4 (air transport: “last seat” and time-limited offers); the Annex to Directive (EU) 2024/825 (new Annex I points).
Not read for this guide: the 27 September 2026 consolidated UCPD version as a whole; national transposition laws and fines; Court of Justice judgments on Annex I point 7; CPC network sweep results; the proposed Digital Fairness Act (not adopted law).
Our reading, not the law's words: treating a stated end date that has passed (while the claim is still shown) as FIX; treating shown stock below real stock as FIX and shown stock above real stock as OK for this sheet; testing “people viewing / bought” claims under Article 6(1) and Annex I point 18; mapping Other and Not sure to CHECK BY HAND; the word-scan word list; and the sample wording.
Related free check sheets
- Black Friday real-discount check sheet (30-day lowest price snapshots)
- EU 30-day lowest price log for Shopify / WooCommerce
- Consumer reviews check sheet (UCPD Art 7(6), Annex I 23b/23c)
- Total price, additional charges and personalised pricing check sheet
- Checkout order button and pre-ticked extras check sheet
- Green claims check sheet (Directive (EU) 2024/825)
Frequently asked questions
Are countdown timers banned in the EU?
Not as such. A countdown timer is fine when it is true. UCPD Annex I point 7 bans, in all circumstances, falsely stating that a product will only be available for a very limited time, or only on particular terms for a very limited time, in order to elicit an immediate decision and deprive consumers of sufficient opportunity or time to make an informed choice. The Commission Guidance (2021/C 526/01, section 4.2.7) says this includes fake timers and limited stock claims on websites.
Is 'only 3 left' allowed?
Yes, if it is true. If the page shows fewer items left than the shop really has, the claim is false scarcity: the Commission Guidance lists limited stock claims on websites under Annex I point 7, and Article 6(1)(b) UCPD treats false information about a product's availability as a misleading action.
What about '12 people are viewing this' messages?
The UCPD has no point naming them, so the sheet tests them under Article 6(1) (false information that deceives the average consumer) and flags Annex I point 18 (materially inaccurate information on market conditions or on the possibility of finding the product). If the number is not taken from real live data, the sheet grades FIX.
Does a shop need intent for this to be unfair?
Annex I practices are unfair in all circumstances, with no case-by-case test of their effect. Point 7 itself speaks of the aim 'to elicit an immediate decision'. The Commission Guidance says the UCPD does not require intention for the deployment of a dark pattern. Our sheet does not try to prove intent; it checks whether the claim is true.
What fines apply?
Article 13 UCPD leaves penalties to Member States. For coordinated cross-border actions under Article 21 of Regulation (EU) 2017/2394, the maximum fine must be at least 4% of the trader's annual turnover in the Member States concerned, or at least EUR 2 million where turnover information is not available. Check national law for the exact amounts.
Why keep dated proof?
Article 12 UCPD lets courts and authorities require the trader to furnish evidence as to the accuracy of factual claims and to consider the claims inaccurate if the evidence is not furnished or is insufficient. A dated screenshot plus the promotion end setting or a stock export is the simplest proof.
Unadhi Guides are free, independent explainers. We correct errors as soon as we find them: write to mininglife7@gmail.com.